Good Debt and Bad Debt – SCOMO you Genius!

Slack Investor doesn’t often comment on the political scene but in Australia it is the yearly budget week and it always pays to keep an ear out for what our politicians are up to. The Australian treasurer Scott Morrison (or SCOMO to the politically aware dudes) presented his budget yesterday with the usual media fanfare. A good summary here … there was a lash at the banks with a new levy on liabilities for the big 5 (Popular with everyone except banks!). The banks took a hit in the share price today … but Australian banks are very good at spreading the costs back to the customers and I am sure that their profits will continue. There was lots of other stuff, putting out a few political fires, bash the bludgers, etc. Of worthy note is the funding of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) with an expansion of the Medicare levy … a revenue raiser that hopefully will be passed by the senate.

I haven’t been inspired by treasurers for a long time … I would have to go back to Paul Keating (Currency floating, tariff reduction, compulsory super) or Peter Costello (Future Fund) to find more than mere twiddlers (I am talking about you here Wayne Swan and Joe Hockey!). But SCOMO looks to be doing a few visionary things that might help the nation. His real contribution as far as Slack Investor is concerned is his introduction of the terms “Good Debt” and “Bad Debt” to the political landscape.

It can be very wise for governments to borrow, especially while rates are low, to lock in longer term financing and invest in major growth producing infrastructure assets, such as transport or energy infrastructure,” From Scott Morrison ABC Audio

These are concepts that Slack Investor has explored before, in the personal sense. The difference in type of debt is such an important concept and understanding of the difference is fundamental to financial independence. Good debt is debt that you take on to buy assets that hopefully appreciate in value (e.g.,  Real Estate, Shares, Education) and contribute to your wealth. Bad debt is debt that you take on just to buy, or do, stuff.

While I applaud Scott Morrison for introducing these debt concepts to the masses, when you drill down into some of the infrastructure spending that is being proposed there is some doubt as to whether all of his proposals will benefit the country. Not all infrastructure is good infrastructure.

Although Slack Investor is cynical enough to think that consultants will give you the answer that you pay for, I think that a compulsory cost-benefit analysis should be required before any major government outlay. At least then, the figures would be out there and the debate would begin on the veracity of the analysis.

In researching this post … well, its “kind of” research … Slack Investor found a couple of SCOMO photos that are so good that I want to share them. They are here below for your delight (or fright)!