Month: December 2022

Imperfections in the Brickwork and … December 2022 – End of Month Update

Detail from the Pen and Ink “Behind Armstrong Street Shops” – the remarkably talented Bren Luke, 2022.

Slack Investor is always on the lookout for new investments … and nothing attracts the jaundiced Slack Eye more quickly than continuous long term results.

Brickworks Ltd (BKW:ASX) have just had their AGM presentation. I was very impressed by the claim that they have maintained, or increased, normal dividends for the last 46 years!

Dividend record – Brickworks 2022 AGM presentation – Brickworks
Tracking the share price of BWK:ASX since 1968 – Brickworks 2022 AGM presentation – Brickworks

As well as being a very good maker of bricks, Brickworks operates as an investment company and own a 26.1% stake of the diversified investing house Washington H. Soul Pattinson (SOL:ASX). SOL, in turn have holdings in

  • TPG Telecom – Australian telecommunications provider
  • Brickworks Limited – Clay and concrete production for the construction industry
  • New Hope Group – Coal and oil mining and energy generation
  • Tuas Limited –  Telecommunications provider
  • Apex Healthcare Berhard – Malaysia-based pharmaceutical production
  • Pengana Capital Group Limited – Fund management
  • Aeris Resources –  Mining and exploration activities

Now Slack Investor does not want to get all preachy here, as as everyone has to draw their own line in the sand – These things are very subjective. I looked up New Hope Mining on the excellent Morningstar Sustainalytics site to get an idea on how well the company is ranked in terms of Environment Sustainability and Governance (ESG).

ESG Risk rating for New Hope Corp. Ltd. – from Sustainalytics

New Hope Group ranked 14571 out of 15559 in terms of ESG risk rating – on a worldwide basis. I personally would feel uncomfortable being a part owner of a thermal coal miner given the current state of the planet.

So despite the most excellent management and performance of BWK, while they still own an interest in the New Hope Group, I will look elsewhere for investments.

Puff Puff MOAT

On the subject of digging deep, I have been a long term holder of the VanEck Morningstar Wide Moat ETF (MOAT:ASX). Slack investor has many vices – Wine and beer just being just two of them … so again, I won’t lecture – as these things are very personal. However, some of the sins that my mother rubbed into me as being “particularly evil” are smoking and gambling. I will do my best to avoid ownership of these type of stocks in deference to my dear Mum.

I noticed back in 2021 that this MOAT ETF had Phillip Morris International as one of its top 10 holdings. According to the Yahoo Finance site – Phillip Morris is 2.5% of the MOAT holdings! Owning a part of a multinational tobacco company that is a leading part of Big Tobacco didn’t really sit well with Slack Investor.

According to the Global Burden of Disease Study, in 2015 alone, smoking caused more than one in ten deaths worldwide and killed more than 6 million people, resulting in a global loss of nearly 150 million disability-adjusted life-years

The Lancet

Slack Investor marked MOAT as an ETF to get rid of, despite liking the concept of its construction – “companies with sustainable competitive advantages”. I had a feeble attempt at shareholder activism and emailed VanEck about this … and enquired whether thy might screen the MOAT ETF with an ethical filter … to get rid of tobacco and gambling stocks – they replied with a polite “no”.

Modified (to protect the innocent!) email from VanEck to Slack Investor

I finally got around to attempt to sell MOAT this month and I thought I should just check the VanEck holdings MOAT site and look at their complete holdings list. Lo and behold … at 29/12/2022, Phillip Morris has now gone from their holdings list! So, for now, MOAT is a keeper!

If at a loose end during the holidays and need a distraction, Slack Investor highly recommends the free exhibition “Streets of Your Town” at the Ballarat Art Gallery, VIC. Bren Luke is an amazing artist, his exhibition runs till 5th Feb 2023.

December 2022 – End of Month Update

The year closes and, I’m not sure if Slack Investor was naughty (probably?)… but, there was no “Santa Rally” this month. All followed markets took a dive in December. The ASX 200 down 3.4%, the FTSE 100 down 1.6%, and the S&P 500 down 5.9%,

Due to the return of all followed share markets to more normal valuations, I have returned my stop-loss upper-limits to 15%. This means that when I work out my stop loss value, I add another 15% to it, this is my upper limit. If the stock price exceeds the upper limit, I will adjust my stop loss upwards. This method helps to lock in some gains if they occur.

Slack Investor remains IN for the FTSE 100, the ASX 200, and the US Index S&P 500.

All Index pages and charts  have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index). The quarterly updates to the Slack Portfolio have also been completed.

Checkmate! ASX

From Chessbase

Slack Investor is all about “continuous improvement” Obviously not me … but everybody else! I normally have low expectations of “clip the ticket”, almost monopoly, systems such as the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX) as there is little incentive for improvement – they are going to get there cut anyway. Last year, I did get off the couch briefly to have a bit of a rant about ASX Paper …I’m Drowning!‘ But I did end the blog on a hopeful note, that system change was just around the corner with a new “blockchain” based system to replace the Clearing House Electronic Sub-register System of the ASX (CHESS).

After reporting five delays on the CHESS replacement project, the ASX has just announced a move to drop the whole project – that it has been thinking about since 2005. In a damning review of the ASX’s handling of the project by Accenture, that has been described by business leaders as “embarrassing”. There are now undermined expectations that the ASX can ever deliver on any new market infrastructure with its current board and management.

The project, which has dragged on for seven years, will now be “reassessed”, the ASX stated in a media release this morning, with the abandoned software being “derecognised” at a gross cost of $245 million to $255 million.

Tahn Sharpe – The Inside Adviser

Although the structure of the current CHESS system is not broken, there are a lot of things that should be fixed.

The underlying software that runs CHESS was a legacy gift from the NASDAQ exchange (i.e. Cost = $0). It is starting to creak a bit though, as it was written over 22 years ago in COBOL. Slack Investor was hoping that the new system would improve on the layers of fee-charging “ticket clippers” that are in the current system – but it seems that the vested interests still have the ear of the ASX.

… the reality is that the CHESS replacement looks more like a replication of all the old systems with its layers of fees being paid to half a dozen different players.

Chanticleer – afr.com

Instead of being the first National Stock Exchange to try use the blockchain technology, perhaps the ASX could wait and see whether other exchanges can bed down this new “distributed ledger “technology – then adapt their systems. After all, using market value, our exchange represents under 2% of the world’s companies.

Countries with largest stock markets worldwide (January 2022), by share of total world equity market value – Statistica

But what would Slack Investor know? – he is only a punter. In the meantime, streamline the current CHESS system – make it better. Whatever we do … it should cost less than $250 million!

Vanguard Super … and November 2022 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor Hero, Jack Bogle, reflecting in casual ware – on how to keep costs down – New York Times

Jack Bogle created Vanguard as a “penny-pinching” financial powerhouse that was owned by the shareholders of its funds. Vanguard pioneered the low-cost index funds revolution.

The Vanguard Effect

The cost of financial products is important, and Slack Investor does his best to minimise any fees that come with financial transactions. It is not often I get to talk about two of my favourite finance things in one blog. Vanguard, the low-cost fund trendsetter and superannuation.

Vanguard have long been a fund manager and ETF provider that have been at the forefront of lower fees in the finance sector. The term “Vanguard Effect” has been coined to explain the phenomena that when Vanguard competes in an area, the expense ratios from their competitors tend to decrease.

Tracking the average Management Expense Ratio (MER) for US Index funds – Vanguard

Vanguard Superannuation in Australia

This month, Vanguard launched into the Australian Superannuation space with a product that is transparent and amongst the lowest fees for an accumulation account. The beauty of their offering is the straight up bundling of all their fees into one simple number – 0.58% of your super balance. Of course, Slack Investor would like a lower management fee – but this is a good start.

0.35% (Administration) + 0.21% (Investment) + 0.02% (Transaction) = 0.58%

The Vanguard MySuper Lifecycle product fees depend on how much Super you have. For a $50,000 balance, the total annual fee would be $290, for a $500,000 balance, the total annual fee would be $2900. The transparency is good – Drag out your own Super annual statement and try to work out your own total fees.

Using the ATO’s comparison of MySuper products tool for a few of the popular industry funds for a $50K balance.

UniSuperAustralianSuperHostPlusHesta
5-yr Net Return6.44%7.07%7.58%6.53%
Annual Fee$316$452$619$510

Of course, fees are not the only consideration. Many of the Industry funds use some sort of stock picking, and may use private equity to enhance their performance. Vanguard Super is made up of a mixture of index funds. I do like the way that the Vanguard Lifecycle automatically adjusts your exposure to risk as you creep towards retirement. 90% growth assets till age 45, then tapering to below 50% when you reach 60. All this is done automatically by Vanguard.

The adjustment of exposure of the Vanguard Livecycle super between growth and defensive assets as you age – Vanguard

Despite this juicy offering, there is often a lack of engagement of Australian workers with their superannuation. Vanguard will probably have a bit of trouble gaining traction in Australia due to the size and popularity of their industry super competitors. This product is currently only for accumulation accounts at this stage. It is a decent starting point by Vanguard and l0ok forward to details of their pension option (coming soon!). I also am hopeful of a bit of the “Vanguard Effect” to put a bit of pressure on existing superannuation fees – which are still too high.

A note that Slack Investor is not sponsored by Vanguard (or anyone else!), but I own a few of their ETF’s and their original founder, Jack Bogle, is one of the Slack Heroes.

November 2022 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor is now back IN for Australian index shares, UK Index shares and UK Index shares.

Last month’s update describes why I feel glad that my 20-yr index timing experiment is coming to an end in 2024. The frustrating moving out … then quickly back in to my Index funds is getting tiresome. I am likely to become just a “buy and hold” investor for my small portfolio of Index funds.

This month, all markets found there were “Reasons to be Cheerful”. There were positive movements all round. The ASX 200 +6.1%, the FTSE 100 +3.3% and the S&P 500 +5.4%.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).