Slack Investor has never seen the film, though well reviewed, but he did struggle through the complex book by John Irving in the late eighties. His interest in GARP has been rekindled by a new ‘Smart Beta’ ETF that has been floated by Global X in October 2024. This one is fresh!
Smart Beta refers to an enhanced indexing strategy that seeks to exploit certain performance factors in an attempt to outperform a benchmark index – Fidelity
This is good … is it possible to get the benefits of passive investing with some of the advantages of active investing strategies? Can you have low fees with better performance than benchmarks? Perhaps all the hard work in selecting growth stocks can be done with a financial selection algorithm and Slack Investor can get back to the couch.
Global X S&P World ex Australia GARP ETF
Exposure to companies with robust earnings growth and solid financial strength trading at reasonable valuations – Global X S&P World ex Australia GARP ETF
Growth at A Reasonable Price (GARP) … in an ETF … am I dreaming? Is this too good to be true? Ahh … there is a management fee. But, it’s 0.3%. Not bad for a fund that has some selection smarts plus international exposure. There is a lot to like about this ETF.
Selection Process for GARP ETF
This ETF tracks the S&P WORLD EX-AUSTRALIA GARP INDEX using a rules based stock section process. From the global shares universe, all companies are assigned a Growth score for their previous 3-yr growth. Then there is a Quality score that combines company assets to debt ratio, return on equity (ROE), and the earnings to price ratio (Inverse of P/E Ratio).
Once the ranking is complete, shares are selected that score highly in both categories and some restrictions on exposure to individual shares and sectors is applied – Mark LaMonica, Morningstar
So, by weeding out some of the companies that are ‘unreasonably’ priced the top 250 global companies are selected according to GARP principles. The price (P/E Ratio) filter should help mitigate the portfolio downside in a market downturn.
Performance
The GARP ASX ETF has only been running a month but Morningstar has gathered some data based upon the GARP principles over time.
GARP seems to perform better than the S&P 500 in some time frames, particularly in the periods that include a share crash. The 5-yr period includes the 2020 ‘Covid Crash’ and, the 20-yr frame includes the 2007–2008 financial crisis (GFC). But these are just index values – without fees. When you factor in the GARP management fee of 0.3% compared to the iShares S&P 500 ETF (IVV.ASX) fees of 0.04%. the outperformance of GARP does not look as good.
Top 15 Holdings GARP
There are a lot of tech companies in here but also some consumer discretionary stocks. Some of the more expensive (high P/E ratios) tech companies must have been filtered out by the GARP process. It is only when Slack Investor takes a closer look at these companies that he start to get ‘cold feet’. Overall, Slack Investor thinks this is a good package to get exposure to reasonably priced growth companies. Two things that hinder Slack Investor from investing are:
- The overlap in holdings to some of the ETF’s that I already own. e.g. Betashares Nasdaq 100 ETF (NDQ.ASX) and Betashares Global Quality Leaders ETF (QLTY.ASX) – a purchase of this ETF would not really add to the diversity of my share ownership
- In the the top 15 holdings, there are 3 Petrochemical companies – Exxon, Chevron and Shell.
Slack Investor will admit to some hypocrisy here. He owns a 15-yr old petrol driven car and regularly uses jet fuel to get to far away places. On the plus side, his roof is making renewable energy. However, the world is getting hotter and he’s aware that we must continue to work toward phasing out the use of fossil fuels Are you listening Donald?
Slack Investor is a part owner of all types of companies through index and broad market ETF’s (e.g. VGS, STW, S&P 500 Index, etc). However, he has a ‘piddly’ moral stance of trying not to bundle into the Slack Portfolio any ETF’s that actively select higher proportions of Tobacco, Gambling, or Fossil Fuel companies.
Is this making a better world? Probably not. But, leave Slack Investor alone to pursue his token activism – no harm done. Besides, it’s likely to be better than doing nothing. This is a personal thing and, Slack Investor encourages all investors to take on any sort investment stance that feels right for you – providing it is profitable in the long term.
Discover more from Slack Investor
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Dear Mr Slack,
after your FY24 blowout are you seriously looking for an edge!
Apart from QLTY, I see you have MOAT, which I think of as quality with pricing power. I haven’t dissected the holdings but am impressed with the unlikely dividends.
I agree, just add to an existing position. If you’re really craving some alpha you could put a big lever under the Nasdaq 🙂
Regards Trevor
(PS will take extra care that my autofill doesn’t use CAPS this time.)
Hi Trevor
Always on the lookout for new stuff. Performance sometimes goes in cycles and, after a good year for existing portfolio was looking for something fresh. Less mature companies that might be in a strong growth stage. This is riskier – and I have abandoned a few along the way.
Hope all is well in Tas Vegas
Mr Slack Moderator,
I don’t see my last comment. It might need a touch-up.
Trevor