Financial Year 2021 Slack Results

“In the business world, the rear view mirror is always clearer than the windshield.”
Warren Buffett

Slack Investor has a proven track record in not being able to predict where speculative assets (such as Bitcoin or precious metals) are going. I would also add to the “speculative list” some companies whose share price have become divorced from the link to their actual earnings. As a rough guide, I try not to invest in companies that have a forward P/E ratio of greater than 50. I get these forward P/E ratios from the excellent Market Screener site.

This means that I have missed out on the great gains of being by in companies like Afterpay (APT – 2023 P/E ratio 190) or TESLA (TSLA – 2023 P/E ratio 193). Some folk have made a lot of money with these companies …. but they are just too speculative for me. Slack Investor tries to “stick to his knitting” with growing companies that have an established earnings record and forward P/E ratios <50.

After an eventful FY 2020 and the COVID-19 dip in the markets around the world. FY 2021, has seen very good gains for most global markets. In the UK, the FTSE 100 Total Return Index is up 18.1% (last FY 20 down 13.8%). Dividends helped the Australian Accumulation Index to be up 27.8% for the financial year (last FY down 7.7%). These Americans remain stupendously optimistic … the S&P 500 Total Return Index was UP 36.4% (last FY up 12.0%) for the same period. All of these Total Return Indexes include any accumulated dividends, wheras the chart below of the ASX 200 for FY 2021, just shows stock prices.

ASX 2oo Weekly chart for FY 2021 – started at 5897 and finished at 7313 (30 June 2020 – 30 June 2021) – Incredible Charts – Click for better resolution.

Slack Portfolio Results FY 2021

All Performance results are before tax. The Slack Portfolio had a cracking year with annual FY 2020 performance of +21.7%. Full yearly results with benchmarks are shown in the table below. It was also a top year for all benchmarks (Median Balance Fund +13.0%, Vanguard Growth Fund +20.3%, ASX 200 Accumulation +27.8%).

Against all Slack Investor predictions … Real Estate turned out to be a great investment in the Brisbane and Melbourne markets for FY 2021 (+17.9% and +10.7%) – Perhaps I should also give up on the “looking ahead” in the residential property market – I just don’t get it!

YEAR	SLACK FUND	MEDIAN BAL	VGARD GROWTH	ASX200Acc	RES BRIS	RES MELB	CASH	CPI
2010	6.6	9.8	12.3	13.1	10.8	26.9	4.2	3.1
2011	2.5	8.7	9.1	11.7	-2.4	0.9	4.4	3.7
2012	8.3	0.4	1.3	-6.7	1.3	-0.9	4.3	1.2
2013	26.5	14.7	18.6	22.8	7.7	8.3	3.2	2.4
2014	23.6	12.7	14.5	17.4	11.5	12.8	2.6	3.0
2015	2.4	9.6	11.8	5.7	7.7	15.6	2.5	1.5
2016	14.2	3.1	4.2	0.6	8.4	9.5	2.2	1.3
2017	19.5	8.1	8.8	14.1	6.5	17.7	1.9	1.9
2018	37.6	7.2	10.0	13.0	5.2	3.9	3.9	2.1
2019	19.7	6.2	9.8	11.5	1.7	-6.0	2.0	1.3
2020	9.4	0.3	0.6	-7.7	8.4	13.8	1.1	-0.3
2021	21.7	13.0	20.3	27.8	17.9	10.7	0.2	3.8

The Slack Fund yearly progress vs BENCHMARKS. The Median Balanced Fund (41-60% Growth Assets), Vanguard Growth Fund, ASX 200 Accumulation Index, Corelogic Residential Property total return in both Brisbane and Melbourne, and Cash (Australian Super Cash Fund) and Consumer Price Index (CPI)

The five-year compound annual performance gives me a much better idea about how things are going and will smooth out any dud (or remarkable!) results.

Slack Investor 5-year compound annual rate of return – compared to benchmarks *– Click for better resolution.*

The beauty of compounding with a succession of good performance results can be seen in the chart below showing the growth of an initial investment in June 2009 of $10000.

The rate of growth of $10000 invested by *Slack Investor in FY 2009 – compared to benchmarks – Click for better resolution.*

The lessons of long term investing

Every year Vanguard publish their performance data on each asset class. Slack Investor looks forward to this – as it reminds him of the power of the appreciating asset classes of Shares and Property. Vanguard highlights the volatility of asset values in the short term – but also emphasizes the joys of holding and accumulating shares or property for long periods of time. These asset classes have steadily increased in value over the last 30 years. $10000 invested in Australian Shares in 1990 would have compounded to $160 498. Staying in Cash would have yielded $38 938.

2021 Vanguard Index Chart

Financial year total returns (%) for the major asset classes

In the chart below, for each asset class the total annual returns are given and the best performing class for each year is marked in green … and the worst in gold. What stands out to Slack Investor is that is rare for and asset class to lead in annual returns (green) for two years in a row – and there are years where the leading asset class (green) becomes the worst performer (gold) in the next year. This drives home the often repeated sentence in the finance world.

Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.

Total returns for each asset class for the 30 years since 1991 – Check out the full glory of the Vanguard 2021 PDF *– Click for better resolution.*

This table highlights the benefits of diversification across asset classes for the long term investor.

Sitting on the couch, Slack Investor is quietly pleased with his 2021 results – Roll on Financial year 2022. However, when comparing this year’s bumper returns with the long term average returns for Australian and International shares of around 10% – Slack Investor can’t help but be a little nervous.

FY2021 Nuggets and Stinkers and July 2021 – End of Month Update

“It’s not whether you’re right or wrong that’s important, but how much money you make when you’re right and how much you lose when you’re wrong.“
George Soros

Now George knows how to make a dollar and, to his great credit, is a generous philanthropist. I am sure, like any successful investor, that George looks back at times on his investment decisions. Slack Investor looks forward to this time of year when I can reflectively analyse my greatest investing failures. Fortunately, my stinker to nugget ratio was good this year.

The percentage yearly returns quoted in this post include costs (brokerage) but, the returns are before tax. This raw figure can then be compared with other investment returns. I use Market Screener to analyse the financial data from each company and extract the predicted 2023 Return on Equity and 2023 Price/Earnings Ratio on the companies below. This excellent site allows free access (up to a daily limit) to their analysts data once you register with an email address.

Slack Investor Stinkers – FY 2021

Growth stocks (High Return on Equity >15% and increasing sales) are fantastic companies to associate with as they are growing and hopefully, their earnings per share, are growing also. The downside to this is that these companies are usually sought after in the stock market and command high prices in relation to their current earnings because the “future earnings” of the company are priced into the current price. This gives them a high PE Ratio. Whenever there is a future earnings revision, or a stutter in growth, there is usually a dramatic drop in price.

Slack Investor has a look at his stocks every weekend on a free chart program (Thanks Incredible Charts!). I actually pay a small amount to get the chart data early in the morning. Both of my “stinkers” this year were actually “nuggets” from last year. For FY 2020, Appen +58% and A2M +26%. Such is the cyclic nature of some growth stocks.

Appen (APX) -24%

APX (2023 ROE 14%, 2023 PE 19) remains a company that puzzles me “the development of human-annotated datasets for machine learning and artificial intelligence”. The company has had a few problems due to COVID-19 and a hit to its underlying profit and increased competition. Slack Investor got out late last year at $25.87 as the weekly chart moved below the stop loss at $28.11. However, this represented a loss of 24% for the financial year.

The downward trend marked by the thick blue line is setting up niciely for one of Slack Investors favourite chart trading patterns – “The Wedgie”. When the share price punches through a downward trend line of at least 6 months … and the fundamentals are right, Slack Investor is interested. Given the forward PE for 2023 is a relatively low 19 – I might have another crack at this once the price has poked above the blue wedge line.

A2 Milk (A2M) -21%

A2M (2023 ROE 17%, 2023 PE 23) sells A2 protein milk products to the world. The actual benefits of the A2 only protein seem to be limited to easier digestion. Long term independent studies with large data sets are still in the works … but the marketing skill of this company is undisputed. COVID-19 brought big changes to sales with the collapse of the “daigou” market and worries about China trade sanctions. Slack Investor sold about half way through the downtrend – but not before taking a hit for the team.

Slack Investor Nuggets – FY 2021

A great benefit of investing in companies that have a high Return on Equity, and with a track record of increasing earnings, is that they sometimes behave as “golden nuggets”.

Codan (CDA) +161%

What a company! Codan is a technology company that specializes in communications and metal detecting. It has made a major US acquisition this year and paid with cash. Sales are up and predicted to keep increasing. The high 2023 ROE 32%, and relatively low 2023 PE 24 (for a growth company) makes me think there will be more price growth over the next few years – I will try and top up my position this year on any price weakness.

Alphabet (GOOGL) +61%

(GOOGL – 2023 ROE 23%, 2023 PE 23) The Alphabet list of products continues to grow. I use a ton of Alphabet products every day and the company is growing fast into the cloud with cloud computing revenue jumping 46% in the March quarter. There are a few regulatory problems coming up with the US Justice department claiming that Google’s actions harmed consumers and competition. There is also the ongoing work of G7 nations trying to make international tech companies pay their rightful share of tax on revenues in each country.

Despite this, if there is one company that Slack Investor could invest in and then pay no attention to for 10 years, and still sleep well, … it would be Alphabet.

REA Group (REA) +59%

The owners of RealEstate.com.au. which is the go to portal for house selling and buying (REA – 2023 ROE 38%, 2023 PE 44). The group has just completed an acquisition of Mortgage Choice and picked up a big chunk of a Mortgage software company. This expanding of the business must be good. 65% of Australia’s adult population are checking the site every month looking at property listings and home prices. However, the 2023 projected PE is very high (44). Using the Slack Investor bench marks, suggests the stock is expensive at the moment.

Integral Diagnostics (IDX) +37%

This medical image company (2023 ROE 16%, 2023 PE 24) provides diagnostic image services to GP’s and specialists. IDX seems to be getting a few tail winds with an ageing population and more demand for their MRI, CT and PET scans.

Macquarie Group (MQG) +36%

Macquarie is a complex business(2023 ROE 14%, 2023 PE 17) with a range of banking and financial services, and plays in global markets and asset management. The latter division looks for undervalued companies. Despite COVID-19, profits are increasing. The management seem to know what they are doing – Slack Investor remains a fan.

Betashares Global Robotics And Artificial Intelligence ETF (RBTZ) +36%

RBTZ ASX | Global Robotics & AI ETF | BetaShares

This ETF tracks the megatrend of robotics and artificial intelligence. Although the PE ratio is a bit high (2021 PE Ratio 37), this is a disruptive sector that should make gains against existing industries with the advantage of technology against rising labour costs.

Most honourable mentions to those other companies that returned over 20% for the tax year. Cochlear (COH) +34%, BetaShares Nasdaq ETF (NDQ) +33%, VanEyk MOAT ETF (MOAT) +32%, Vanguard International ETF (VGE) +29%, BetaShares HACK ETF (HACK) +31%, Vanguard Asia ETF (VAE) +28%, BetaShares QLTY ETF (QLTY) +25%. To these companies, I am grateful for your service.

Slack Investor Total SMSF performance – FY 2021 and July 2021 end of Month Update

A great year for shares, Chant West reports Super funds have delivered their strongest financial year result in 24 years, with the median growth fund (61 to 80% in growth assets) returning 18% for FY21. The FY 2021 Slack Investor preliminary total SMSF performance looks like coming in at around 22%. The 5-yr performance is a more useful benchmark to me – as it takes out the bouncing around of yearly returns. At the end of FY 2021, the Slack Portfolio has a compounding annual 5-yr return of over 21%.

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares The FTSE 100 had a flat month (-0.1%) but rises in the US Index S&P 500 (+2.3%) and the ASX 200 (+1.1%).

The party with the US S&P 500 just keeps on going. As the S&P 500 has moved more than 20% higher than its stop loss on the monthly chart, I have adjusted the stop loss upward to 4056 from 3622. It is difficult to decide where to put the stop loss on the monthly US Index chart. In these cases, I go to the weekly chart and look for a “sensible place” to put the stop loss coinciding with a minimum value (dip) on the chart. The current stop loss is 8% below the end of month price.

US Index (S&P 500) weekly chart showing a moving up of the stop loss this month.

The US economy entered a recession in February 2020 and has now entered a phase of expansion (since June 2020). Slack Investor is nervous though and has his stop losses live for all Index funds. I will be checking these charts on a weekly basis for breaches of the stop loss.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

A Further look at three pile theory … and May 2021 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor presented his version of a bucket strategy – The “Three Pile Theory”. It is the three pillars of a House, Stable Income, and Investments that have supported me through most of my working life and now the three piles are still supporting me in early retirement.

These piles have been continually interacting with each other as I was trying to build them all up. At the start, the Prince of all piles was a good income and, as I have very poor entrepreneurial skills, the key for me to get a good income was to have a good education. I was lucky enough to have parents that encouraged me to go as far as my wit would take me.

Without education you’re not going anywhere in this world
Malcolm X

When originally talking about three pile theory, I glossed over the retirement phase and how the investment and stable income piles can keep you going … hopefully, for a long time. By retirement, if possible your house will be paid off – and this will be left as a dormant house pile which keeps giving back in lots of ways … but only as a last resort will you use it to fund your lifestyle in retirement!

Lets do the sums on just two piles – Your Retirement Fund

Consider a retirement fund with just two piles – Stable Income and Investments. In order to generate 4% of income per year, you need have most of your retirement fund in investments rather than stable income. According to his two pile theory, Rob Berger from Forbes Magazine recommends that you should have between 50% and 75% of the retirement fund in the investments pile 0f equities (stocks). Decide on a ratio of stable income to investments that you can sleep well with – a higher amount investments will mean potentially more growth … but definitely more volatility.

A bit of mathematics here … my original ratio of house:stable income:investments was 30%:20%:50%f Net Worth. When taking my house out of the calculations, my ratio of Stable Income: Investments is about 30%:70% – this is just the numbers that I am comfortable with.

My original plan was to use dividends and interest from the two piles of my retirement fund to give me income. That means taking out money from both piles every year – even when stock markets have fallen. Rob Bergen points out that this is exactly the wrong approach. Taking dividends out reduces the investments pile – it has the same effect on your investments pile as if you sold some of your stocks. In a down-trending stock market, for your long-term investments pile, you want to use those dividends to reinvest in a stock market that is undervalued.

(Using the traditional bucket strategy), assets are taken from (Investments) when market prices have fallen, which is exactly when dividends should be reinvested.
Rob Berger – outlining the folly of taking money out of your Investments account when the market is falling.

How to make your piles last in retirement phase – Rebalancing the Retirement Fund

This heading has Slack Investor lapsing into what my mother called “Plumber’s Humour”. Using the Rob Berger simple strategy, you maintain your piles. Even though you have the competing interests of wanting to withdraw annual amounts for a great lifestyle, and yet, keeping enough in your retirement fund to generate future income for many many years. There are lots of articles on buckets to fund your retirement but, it can get complicated – I really like the clarity of Rob Berger’s approach. He explains in detail how the traditional bucket strategy is flawed.

By the time you retire, you will have a good idea of your expenses, While you are healthy and fit, add a good chunk of income to fund some travel. At the start of the financial year, this amount gets withdrawn to your cash account to fund yearly living expenses. The remainder is your retirement fund comprising of Stable Income pile (Annuities/Bonds/Term Deposits/Fixed Interest) and Investments pile. Slack Investor is happy with 70% of his Retirement Fund in Investments (Equities/Stocks).

Set up a ratio of Stable income: Investments in Your Retirement Fund that you are happy with and take your annual expenses out of the pile that is over allocated at the end of the year. In the above case, Investments.

In a good year for investments (outlined above) your next years annual income requirements can be withdrawn from the investments pile. If you get a bad year for investments, then dip into the stable income pile. Take out enough from each pile so that after your yearly expenses withdrawal, the initial allocations are roughly intact – I should do some algebra here to make this easier … but you can do it for your homework!

Using this method, you are always selling from your investments pile when the market is high and buying when the market is low – masterful investing, Warren Buffet would approve!

May 2021 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100.

There were modest rises in all followed overseas markets (S&P 500 +0.6%, and the FTSE 100 +0.8%). The Australian stock market is powering on (ASX 200 +1. 9%) despite Slack Investor and the state of Victoria being in a (hopefully only one week!) COVID inspired lock down. All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

Always Watching

Slack Investor is not known for his fast work … and have often taken the couch when action was probably needed. There are some stocks that I will hold for the long run, and their weekly charts are not of big concern to me. However, about half of my portfolio is on a weekly watch – I review the charts on a weekend and cast the Slack Investor jaundiced gaze over each stock that I own (Thanks Incredible Charts!)

“You can observe a lot by watching”
Yogi Berra – American Baseball Legend and Master of Tautology

I do have some routines though …

Daily

This is the least satisfying timescale and, if I could successfully train myself to ignore this daily oscillation of my investments – I would. The reason to avoid daily swings of the share price is that I have absolutely no idea about whether the price of a stock or index will go up or down on the next day – the share price is determined by others! In the chart below, in the first 7 days shown, the daily index went down, down, up, down, down, up, up, etc – monitoring daily prices can be frustrating!

I have to admit that I follow my investments every few days through a portfolio in Yahoo Finance and will download prices to my accounting software – the free Microsoft Money Sunset International Edition available at the most excellent Ameridan’s Blog. I download share prices into Microsoft Money with MS Money Quotes with a 10 USD lifetime licence. In the USA, Personal Capital is recommended.

I am happy to say that, when on holiday, or busy, I have no need to monitor on the daily timescale. Regardless, no decisions are made on this daily basis.

Weekly

Weekly is where the “rubber hits the road” for Slack Investor – and I look forward to my weekly sessions with my portfolio. I set aside an hour on the weekend to make sure my portfolio prices are updated and the charts are reviewed. The weekly time scale smooths out a bit of the volatility and I then open up Incredible Charts to scroll through my portfolio.

Incredible charts offer a free month sign up and then $9.95 per month for access to worldwide updated delayed charts daily from 6pm Australian time. This package is not in “real time” and does not suit a day trader. But for an investor on my slower time scale, it is very good value. These charts open up the whole world of technical analysis as it allows you to monitor trends in your stocks and mark in trend lines and stop losses.

I have always used the weekly charts to make decisions on buying a company – looking for a momentum shift in the trading using the Directional Movement System. I also like to trade a “breakout”, or a “wedgie”

Monthly

This is the timescale when I am most happiest and would like to make decisions just every month. After a life of work where decisions were a constant grind – It is a gift not to make decisions!

It is still my aim to make selling decisions monthly – but things seem a little precarious lately and, for now, I am on a weekly decisions cycle for selling. The sell happens when a stock price finishes below my stop loss at the end of the week/month (see Technical Sell below).

Yearly

This is the “Look at yourself in the mirror” period where Slack Investor does the evaluation of his portfolio performance against benchmarks at the end of each financial year. Although the financial year ends at June 30, it usually takes until the middle of August for me to get my final results and benchmarks together. I present my results at the annual Financial Year Results post.

Special Occasions Selling

Slack Investor is in one of those right now and he has to free up some cash to by selling some shares. I like to do things a bit methodically and here is my process for a sell.

Technical Sell

This is my first port of call. Technical Analysis uses charts and trends and I have been watching the charts for the past 4 weeks for a technical sell signal in my portfolio. For me, this happens when the stock price falls below the pre-determined stop loss that I have set. I will then try to sell at the start of the next week/month. My rules are not rigid here, if the stock starts to rebound after I have made my sell decision, I might stick with it for a little while longer.

Another technical signal is when a stock loses its momentum – but this is a more subjective signal than when a stock simply moves below a line.

Slack Investor bought into ESPO in October 2020 at $10.39 and sold this week at a small loss $10.19. The stock didn’t grow like I thought it would – but that’s fine. I like the concept of this ETF but I am happy to be out for now and look forward to be getting back in when a strong upward trend establishes itself.

I was also able to exit on a technical sell for the Betashares ASIA ETF and I am not sure what is going on here as I thought the tailwinds for this sector were good. Small profit this time and will get back in if the trend changes.

Weekly chart for the VanEck ESPO ETF showing a breach of the stop loss – Incredible Charts.

Fundamental Sell

Fundamental Analysis revolves around trying to determine the real value of a stock by looking at its financial data (e.g, Price/Earnings ratio, Return on Equity, Debt, etc) over time and, in reference to its competitors. This is a much more complicated process.

If Slack Investor can’t find a technical sell, I look for a fundamental sign. I will list all of my sellable stocks (Shares that I don’t hold for “the long run“). The first step is to get some financial data on each company from the very good Market Screener then put them in a table and hope that something stands out as a sell. A sell signal might be a trend of falling earnings, increasing debt, or decreasing Return on Equity (ROE). I also get nervous about a stock if its predicted (+ 2 years) Price Earnings (PE) ratio goes over 50. Fortunately, I didn’t have to resort to any fundamental analysis this this time … and this approach probably needs a post in itself.

In the meantime, like my pumpkin friend … always watching …

R&B? … No, R&D!

James Brown Performing At The Apollo by New York Daily News Archive — Mr James Brown (1933 – 2006) – an R&B, funk, and soul music legend – “**The hardest thing about being James Brown is I have to live. I don’t have no down time**” – Image from Rolling Stone

Slack Investor might be showing his age here … but when I think of R&B (Rhythm & Blues), it’s not Drake or The Weeknd that I think of, its “The Hardest Working Man in Show Business” that comes to mind. James Brown had a bit of a trouble in his life but there is no denying his talent and influence – 4 minutes of his genius can be seen here.

The one thing that can solve most of our problems is dancing
James Brown

But I digress, when the dancing is finished, R&D (Research and Development) is another thing that gets Slack Investor attention – especially when it comes to finding a company to invest in. Lets have a look at the world top ten spenders on Research and Development. This quality list of companies is peppered with representation from the tech, pharmaceutical and (electric) car sectors. One of the ways that a company can keep growing is to develop an upstream pipeline of products through research, patenting, and testing. It may take many years before they are released so the companies must be patient and long sighted – not all products in the pipeline will be a success.

Ranking of the 20 companies with the highest spending on R & D in 2018 *(in billion U.S. dollars)* – From Statista.com

I don’t often read company annual reports as I lack forensic accounting skills and they are usually thick and masterpieces of obfuscation. But, I am usually very impressed when, in the overview, a decent slab of profits are going back into R&D. Slack Investor would rather invest in companies that are constantly innovating, and investing in future products. Only some of these products will yield fruit, but you would hope that these high spending R&D companies would generate bigger profits than those that don’t. Although, this is not always the case! In some cases, the world of R&D can be full of questionable spending, uncertain results.

Even though R&D spending does not guarantee profitability and ever increasing stock prices, there is a correlation- future earnings are positively associated with current R&D.

Commonwealth Serum Laboratories (CSL)

Despite a 20% price fall in the CSL share price in the past 6 months, there is no thought of Slack investor selling this great company. It is one of my “Long Run” stocks. I have often written about share prices fluctuating above and below a “fair value” for a stock . This is just a characteristic of share investing – depending on the mood of the market.

A weekly chart of the CSL share price showing a 20% fall in the last 6 mth -From incrediblecharts.com

CSL is not in the world R&D big spending league in dollar terms. But, in Australia, it is one of our best R&D spenders with almost a billion dollars (US) per year. This amount is very high as a percentage of its revenue, in an environment where a typical manufacturer will spend 1-2%, CSL spending on Research and Development is between 10 to 11 per cent of turnover. Slack Investor thinks this is a good thing and is happy that CSL is occupying a big chunk of his portfolio.

CSL have many products in the R&D pipeline and have a good track record of converting at least some of these products into successful earners. Some other analysts agree and have a target price of $310 on the stock. With current pricing at $253.26 (12 Mar 21) – this smells good!

I taught them everything they know, but not everything I know
James Brown

That’s right James … “Hit it”

Colin Nicholson – A Great Australian Investor … and February 2021 – End of Month Update

I have a few people that have greatly influenced my investing life – One such figure is Colin Nicholson. I have never met him, but he has taught me a vast amount through his long running website “Building Wealth Through Shares” (bwts.com.au).

This great Australian investor Colin Nicholson, has been investing for over 50 years and documenting his adventures with shares since 2001 on his site. Colin has only stopped actively contributing at the end of 2019. Fortunately, this website is still running and his knowledge and experience keeps on giving. As well as education material on technical and fundamental analysis, he often discusses the psychology necessary to be a successful investor.

We tend to have an impulse to snatch profits quickly and to let losses run, hoping things will come good if we hold on. This natural impulse is the exact opposite to what a successful investor must do.
Colin Nicholson

Colin started bwts.com.au when financial blogs were in their infancy and Australian contributors were rare. Colin is a private investor, an author, and educator. He has been contributing to his site for over 20 years and answered hundreds of questions from other investors. His site is an incredibly detailed knowledge base covering all aspects of owning a share portfolio. His Investing – Twelve Key Lessons is essential reading to anyone thinking of entering this fascinating world. His results over a 20-yr period are very impressive. Colin has retired from active contributions to his website but has hinted that he would maintain his website for the education of future investors.

There are countless bits of wisdom as Colin relentlessly tackles investment according to a defined, well-tested, and logical plan. No matter what the investing subject, search his site, and Colin Nicholson will offer some useful and reasoned discussion.

The source of most frustration in investors is that they are expecting the impossible. They want to sell at the top. I repeat that it simply cannot be done except by sheer luck.
Colin Nicholson – Take Profits or Wait for the Stop-Loss?

My first introduction to his site was through his meticulous documentation on how he calculated his end of financial year performance returns. Year after year he would list his portfolio and investment returns.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is ColNichReturn.png — Colin Nicholson’s documented returns over 20 years comparing his returns(red) and the ASX 200 accumulation index (green). A 12.01% Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) is very impressive over a 20-yr period and has enabled Colin to have a hopefully financially carefree retirement.

… I do not wish to advise people or to manage their money. Rather, my focus is on my own investments and passing on what I have learned to others.
Colin Nicholson

In addition to his website and public speaking, Colin has also authored Building Wealth in the Stock Market and Think Like the Great Investors. Like another of Slack Investor heroes, Warren Buffet, Colin has a plan for “retirement mode” and intends to become more passive with his investments and half of his portfolio is now in LICs and index funds.

I am not retired – I am a full-time investor
Colin Nicholson

Colin Nicholson, Slack Investor salutes you for your enormous contribution to my investment life and for helping countless others with your education materials and your disciplined and methodical approach to investing in shares. Dive deep and long into bwts.com.au and you will be a better investor.

February 2021 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100.

When having a look at the end of month charts, I noticed that all index trackers were well above their stop losses (>16%). My Mum (and Kath and Kim) would say that she could “feel it in her waters” when she had a premonition about something. My index rules allow the end of month stock price to be up to 20% above the stop loss. However, in a tip of the hat to Mr Nicholson, who is far more disciplined than Slack Investor in the investing arts, some action this month. As “new highs” have been established, I decided that now wouldn’t be a bad time to adjust the stop loss levels upwards.

I place my stops below the low of the last trough in the uptrend and move it up to just under the next trough every time a new high is made for the trend.
Colin Nicholson

Weekly Chart of the ASX 200 Index – incrediblecharts.com

For February 2021, there were falls in the growth oriented Slack Portfolio due to rising long-term bond yields. But stock prices have always fluctuated above or below a “fair price” – for one reason or another. Slack Investor is still on the couch.

Tech stocks are susceptible to rising yields because their value rests most heavily on future earnings, which get discounted more negatively when bond yields go up.
From The Bull

Despite the end of month sell off, there were modest rises in all followed index funds (ASX 200 +1. 0%, S&P 500 +2.6%, and the FTSE 100 +1.2%). All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

SMSF is it a superpower OR Kryptonite? … and January 2021 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor hasn’t written much about Self Managed Super Funds (SMSF’s) despite his love affair with his own fund. SMSF’s are only found in Australia and represent a “hands on” way to accumulate, nurture, and eventually release your super funds as a pension or lump sum. They have the same status as a normal retail or industry super fund (e.g. Australian Super) but they are “self managed” and give the trustees (members of the fund) power over where the fund is invested. This control is a double edged sword, as it is also possible to destroy your super wealth with a SMSF by making unwise investments.

SMSF’s offer

Control
Flexibility in investments – But this can be dangerous!
Estate Planning and Taxation advantages

There are nearly 600,000 SMSFs in Australia with over a million member (March 2020). Although this represents less than 5% of Australia’s population, about 25% of the $2.7 trillion invested in superannuation is invested in SMSF’s. The average member balance for an SMSF was a whopping $678,621 (ATO Data 2018).

It is possible to structure an SMSF so that the investment fees are very low. A surprising finding from a SuperConcepts study was that the average annual expense ratio for SMSF’s was 2.8% for the over 20000 funds surveyed. This seems particularly high when compared to the Slack Investor SMSF portfolio expense ratio of 0.12% through a “no advice” online SMSF services provider like e-superfund. This suggests that most of the funds surveyed used the relatively high cost route of engaging an accountant to administer the fund. There are many SMSF providers – Slack Investor uses e-superfund which provides the legal structure and web-based audits and education. The yearly operating expenses are an amazingly low $999. The SMSF is so integral to Slack Investor’s strategy that I have set aside an SMSF page on the Slack Investor site – Alas, there is not much on there yet … but it will come!

Rainmaker are producing monthly comparisons of SMSF’s with the larger low cost My Super products offered by Industry and Retail Super Funds. The analysis can be found on their Superguard360 site.

SG360Jun17_2 — A comparison of the Asset mix of SMSF funds (left column) with MySuper funds – From Superguard360

SMSF funds (above left) traditionally hold more cash, property and less international shares than the larger Industry/Retail funds (My Super – above right). SMSF’s have outperformed MySuper since the GFC (see below, SMSF’s Blue line, My Super Red block). However, with the recovery of equities, the MySuper funds have been catching up and as at June 2017, 10-year returns from both types of funds are near identical at 4.2%. Under current asset allocations, the more diversified Industry and retail funds should overtake SMSF performance – on average.

SG360Jun17_1 — Comparison of how SMSF’s (Blue Line) have done , on average, against the default My Super Fund Index (Red Block) – From Superguard360

Self Managed Super is NOT for Everyone

“… That a little knowledge is apt to puff up, and make men giddy, but a greater share of it will set them right, and bring them to low and humble thoughts of themselves.”
From an anonymous author, published in 1698 as “The Mystery of Phanaticism”

Running a SMSF takes time and I wouldn’t recommend it to anyone that doesn’t want to be fully engaged with their financial future. Luckily, Slack Investor finds the whole finance and ATO compliance scene most interesting. Trustees of SMSF’s are held responsible for compliance with super and tax laws and there are many other risks in running a SMSF fund. A long term study of SMSF data by SuperConcepts, “When Size Matters” found that that SMSF’s below $200000 in total funds generally underperformed. However, the larger SMSF’s were comparable in performance with industry funds.

Over 10 years, there’s hardly any difference between the performance of not-for-profit funds, such as industry funds, and DIY (SMSF) funds.
SMH article (2017) summarising Rainmaker data from the ATO

Despite how well an SMSF style really suits Slack Investor – The large majority of people should not get into an SMSF – but stick with a good performing Industry Fund. Unless you are justifiably confident in your investing abilities, most people will be better of with a well diversified industry fund for long-term Super performance. It is always better to “have low and humble thoughts of ourselves” – it is too easy to destroy the value of your hard earned super.

January 2021 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100.

Some tested COVID-19 vaccinations have started to be rolled out internationally – but uncertainty prevails. Slack Investor followed markets all fluctuated but, overall, remained pretty flat this month. For January 2021, the Australian ASX 200 rose 0.3%, the S&P 500 fell 1.1%, and the FTSE 100 down 0.8%.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

Golden Triangle of Happiness … and December 2020 – End of Month Update

After just going through a Christmas period where, in these COVID-19 times, I was lucky enough to spend time with some family – I was struck with an unusual contentment. It is easy to get bogged down with the day to day challenges of life, but Slack Investor occasionally gets self reflective and has long realised that he is a happy bloke. This state is much sought after and it often doesn’t naturally happen. A recent publication that has lodged in my tiny brain is the Australian Wellbeing Index. This research has been conducted twice a year over the last 15 years and involves more than 60,000 participants.

Personal wellbeing appears to increase with age, with some of the happiest Australians aged 65 and over.
Australian Wellbeing Index – 2019 Joint Research between Deakin University and Australian Unity.

The latest instalment of one of Australia’s largest wellbeing surveys has found that, besides genetics, there are three simple indicators of a happy life. Financial security, a sense of purpose in life, and good personal relationships make up the “golden triangle” of happiness. The full report can be found here.

well-being2 — Source: thenewdaily.com.au

Financial Security

This is really what this blog posts mostly about – so I wont expand too much here. But if you feel that you are in control of your money then you can avoid many of the financial stresses. While having money does not make you happy, if you don’t have any, it can make you miserable. Not surprisingly, the survey found that the feeling of wellbeing gradually rises for household earnings up to about $100,000 a year. Surprisingly, earnings over this point found the relationship between happiness and wealth drops off dramatically.

Relationships

… the people who fared the best were the people who leaned into relationships, with family, with friends, with community,”
Dr. Robert Waldinger , Harvard University

We are humans and (mostly) social creatures – a sharing of your life and having someone who cares about you makes you feel better about yourself. A Harvard study that has been going for 80 years found that people who are more socially connected to family, friends, or community are “happier, they’re physically healthier and they live longer than people who are less well connected,”

“It doesn’t need to be a sexual relationship, but it needs to be an emotionally intimate relationship where you can share troubles and sorrows and joys,”
Prof Bob Cummins, Deakin University

Sense of Purpose

Something to do … your get up in the morning and you have a project, part time job, volunteering, exercise, a hobby – but it is something! People are happier when they are active.

But, beyond the “golden triangle” of happiness, there are other approaches – Rather than take on each corner of the triangle, just try to just make little micro changes to your life – Perhaps a little more exercise, or contact an old friend …

An older friend once pointed out to me that we were lucky enough to have choices with our lives. He stressed our limited life span and suggested I make a list of the things that I really liked doing – and then try to engineer my life to maximise these good things and then minimise the other, less enjoyable. but necessary stuff. When you collect all the moments that make you happy … you might just … be happy!

Spend more time with people you like, get outdoors a bit more, listen to some music, have some new experiences, help other people …
“Happiness thinker” Professor Paul Dolan

December 2020 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. All Slack Investor followed overseas markets this month had rises (ASX 200 +1.1%; FTSE 100 +3.1%; S&P 500 +3.7%).

I still remain nervous about the US market with its high valuations. The closing value of the S&P 500 (3756) is now 18% above the current stop loss at 3200. If the margin gets to 20% (UPR LIMIT 3840)), then I will find a place to move my stop loss upward. In these uncertain times, I will monitor my index funds weekly and if, at the end of the week my Index funds are below the stop loss, then I will put a post on the blog and sell at the next opportunity. All Stop Losses are Live.

S&P 500 Monthly chart December31 2020- From incrediblecharts.com

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index). The quarterly updates to the Slack Portfolio have also been completed.

Hits and Misses … and November 2020 – End of Month Update

Back in happier times, September 2019, the Mayfair 101 business founder, James Mawhinney. His skills are described by Mayfair as “generating substantial value for shareholders”. Sadly for investors, the signature Mayfair 101 investment in Dunk Island has now fallen through due to Mayfair being “unable to meet their obligations”– Original image from the Courier Mail

Mayfair 101 bites the dust

It may take some years, but this Mayfair 101 thing … it’s not going to end well for the punters!
Slack Investor – November 2019

It has now been 12 months since Slack Investor warned about investing in the highly promoted glitzy “alternative to term deposits” Mayfair 101. I urged any investors to get their money out while they could. Things have now gone pear-shaped for participants in Mr Mawhinney’s vehicles – as well as the Dunk Island resort repossession, one of Mayfair 101’s three main investment products, IPO wealth, has had its investor’s money frozen.

I take no solace in being right as many small and large investors have since been hurt by the appointment of receivers to Mayfair 101’s $86 million IPO Wealth fund. ASIC alleges that the money raised by the Mayfair group was not fully secured, and investors may be unable to recover the full amount of their principal investment.

According to The Guardian, Mayfair 101 had received more than $67.5m from investors but, by 1 July, had just $2,765 in the bank and that investor’s money was “used to fund a loan that was not adequately secured”. They were unable to come up with the $32m that would have completed the purchase of Dunk Island. ASIC feared the fundraising was “akin to arrangements colloquially referred to as a ‘Ponzi scheme’.”

A year ago there were full page ads in the AFR, full of glowing self praise as the “new face of investment” In investing, it pays to be wary of big announcements, “management speak” and things that sound too good to be true … trust the nostrils!

“[Mayfair Platinum CEO, James Mawhinney, is] an experienced business builder who is focused on creating win-win outcomes for investors, clients, suppliers and staff
A quote from Mayfair (sourced from crikey.com )from the golden days of Mayfair 101 … but perhaps win-lose might be more appropriate. I am hoping that investors can get a decent portion of their capital returned.

Bitcoin again

Bitcoin chart (USD) since 2014 – From Coindesk

This would be objectively classified as a miss by Slack Investor – the bitcoin price is now higher than when I initially talked about bitcoin as a “bubble” at around $7000 USD. Despite the rocketing bitcoin price, the Slack Investor view has not changed and it is not the type of investment that appeals to me. Bitcoin is a speculative investment that depends entirely on what the next buyer is willing to pay for it.

Bitcoin is the dominant cryptocurrency (Etherium, Ripple, Litecoin, etc) that uses the potentially useful blockchain technology to monitor transactions. The Guardian points out that bitcoin is not a true currency as it not widely accepted as legal tender, the transaction costs are not small (it costs between 3 and 6 USD per transaction) and, it does not have a relatively stable value that would help vendors in setting prices. Central banks and Facebook have outlined plans for their own digital currencies that would be in competition with existing cryptocurrencies.

There is also a high energy cost in the “mining” of bitcoin. The current “Proof of Work” algorithm requires 215 kw/h of electricity to produce each bitcoin – the equivalent of an average US home energy consumption for a week.

Slack Investor holds no regrets about not buying in. He will stick with investing in growing real companies that produce tangible things that people want. An investment should be something that has a real monetary or social value, regardless of whether someone wants to buy it from you.

My assessment in 2017 that bitcoin is a casino investment still holds. Well done to anyone that has made money with bitcoin. In the same way that I will always congratulate someone who has made money on a bizarre sports bet – or who has won money on 5 reds in a row in roulette table – but, it is not investing, it is not for me.

November 2020 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100.

During a time when world COVID-19 related deaths are 8866 per day and there are 54.9m cases confirmed globally – the stock markets have gone a little crazy . It is a good demonstration of how difficult it is to predict short-term stock market movement. Slack Investor followed markets all grew by more than 10% this month. For November 2020, the Australian ASX 200 rose 10.0%, the S&P 500 up 10.8%, and the FTSE 100 up 12.4%.

All it took was a US election and some good vaccine news.

“Most Americans who want to be vaccinated will be able to do so by April or May next year”
Dr. Anthony Fauci – from CNN

On the FTSE 100 Index a new “Higher Low” was established and this gave me the opportunity to move up my monthly stop loss to 5525 – see Monthly UK Index chart.

The US economy entered a recession in February 2020 and still in uncertain times, Slack Investor has his stop losses live for all Index funds.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

Know when to Fold’em … and October 2020 – End of Month Update

“He said, “If you’re gonna play the game, boy
You gotta learn to play it right …
You’ve got to know when to hold ’em
Know when to fold ’em
Know when to walk away
And know when to run
Excerpt from “The Gambler” written by Don Schlitz and recorded by Kenny Rogers.

Kenny makes this sound easy, but selling shares is tricky and Slack Investor does not always get this decision right – and I’m OK with that. The Slack Investor art is just to attempt to get things “mostly right”. There are some stocks that I will hold for the long run, and their weekly and monthly charts are not of a big concern to me. However, about half of my portfolio is on a weekly or monthly watch – I review the Incredible Charts output for each of these stocks on the weekend or at the end of the month.

I pay particular attention when the stock price falls below my stop loss on the monthly chart. In hindsight, I should have been more alert back in August. A2M is a good company with a unique product and has shown excellent growth in the last 5 years. However, earnings season is always a bit volatile for the growth sector.

The FY20 results showed a record profit but there were some question marks about FY21. The real catalyst for a downward price move was the later release of an acquisition and that members of the board and senior executive team had sold over 1.8 million shares. Selling by insiders is not always bad, as the executives might just be diversifying their portfolios – However, in this case, the market took a dim view. Overall, the A2 Milk Company Ltd (ASX: A2M) share price has slumped more than 15% since the release of its FY21 outlook.

Monthly Price chart of The A2 Milk Company (A2M) showing a buy in at $11.66 in January 2019 and a sell at $15.40 at the end of September 2020. I took the opportunities to gradually creep up my stop loss from the original value of $11.11 to $17.08 – From incrediblecharts.com

I am not known for my fast work and have tended to take the couch rather than make a decision in the past. However, in the spirit of incremental improvement, I didn’t wait till the end of the month and pounced on the sell button on the day that the A2M fell more than 10%, 28th September 2020.

*Daily Price chart of The A2 Milk Company (A2M)*. Slack investor sold on the day news leaked out about insider selling on September 28 *– From* incrediblecharts.com

I am not put off A2M forever. The end of month share price was $13.67. There is now a reasonable case for re-investing given the growth pathway beyond 2021 and the Market Screener , relatively low, 2023 predicted PE of 19. There has now been a downward trend of 3 months and Slack Investor’s favourite pattern has started to emerge … “The Wedgie”. If there is a break above “the Wedgie”, I will reinvest and hope the share price resumes an uptrend.

” … the secret to survivin’
is knowing what to throw away,
and knowing what to keep …”
Further … from The Gambler

Ooooh Kenny … the secret to investing is simple to describe, but harder to do … but you knew how to tell a good story!

October 2020 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. However, the US and UK charts are hovering close to their monthly stop losses.

The state of recent COVID-19 surges in Europe and the US seems to be worrying punters and monthly falls were recorded in these markets (S&P 500 -2.8%; FTSE 100 -4.9%). In Australia, the governments are handling the response to the virus in a constructive fashion and the ASX 200 rose 1.9%.

On the ASX 200 Index monthly chart, a new “Higher Low” was established and this gave me the opportunity to move up my monthly stop loss to 5763.

The US economy entered a recession in February 2020 and Slack Investor has his stop losses live for all Index funds.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).