Slack Investor tries to diversify his investment risk by keep a 70% growth oriented investments portfolio with a 30% stable income portion. So far this financial year, my Investments portfolio performance has been a bit lacklustre – so I have gone to the “hall of mirrors” and had a long, hard look at myself. I decided to do a sector analysis of my investments portfolio. The biggest revelation is the large proportion of Investments in the Information Technology (INFT) and Healthcare (HLTH) sectors.
A breakup of the Slack investments portfolio by sector. Dominated by Information Technology (INFT) and Healthcare (HLTH) – but a scattering of Financials (FINL), Broad Index-type funds (INDX), Consumer Discretionary (COND), Communication Services (COMS/TELS), and Consumer Staples (CONS)
Both of my main sectors have had a rough time these last few months – as can be seen by the monthly sector performance chart below. Materials (Resources) and Energy have done well – But these are sectors that I do not own.
Monthly Sectors heatmap for S&P 500 Sectors – Click on Image for better resolution – From Livewire
Slack Investor is not too old to learn new tricks … or, at least, evolve a little. so I was interested to see how my sector analysis compared with the US S&P 500 (below). I chose the S&P 500 f0r comparison as it not dominated by Financials and Resources like the ASX 200. My weightings are very different to the S&P 500.
I came across a great graphic showing how each sector of the S&P 500 performs annually
10 yr excerpt from the annual S&P 500 Sector Performance ranking – Click on the Chart to get the full interactive experience – From Novel Investor
Some explanation of this beautifully coloured quilt is in order. The vertical columns represent each of the last 10 years performance of each sector of the S&P 500 in ranked order. The right hand column is for 2021. The 2021 sector leader was Energy (ENRS) after a long period in the doldrums. Next is Real Estate (REAL), Financials (FINL), Information Technology (INFT), S&P 500 (S&P), Materials (MATR), Health (HLTH), Consumer Discretionary (COND), Communication Services (TELS), Industrials (INDU), Consumer Staples (CONS) and Utilities (UTIL). The full glory of this graphic is found on the Novel Investor website with a bit of interactivity.
Some things that I have gleaned from this graphic
Every dog has its day – Depending on the year, each sector can have it’s day in the sunshine.
If you want neither the best of returns or the worst sector returns – buy the S&P 500 Index.
Often … if a sector tops the rankings in one year, it usually performs much worse in the next year.
The Information Technology (INFT) sector, to which Slack Investor is heavily exposed, is in the top four rankings for performance for 7 of the last 10 years. This year is not one of them.
Should I change my sector allocation?
There are good arguments for passive investing and, if I did not enjoy investing in individual companies, and my 5-yr results were not OK), then that is what I would do. To completely diversify my investment portfolio to match the S&P 500 would mean that I would be investing solely in an S&P 500 Index fund. This has been an excellent idea for the past 50 years.
Berkshire Hathaway has tracked S&P 500 data back to 1965. According to the company’s data, the compounded annual gain in the S&P 500 between 1965 and 2020 was 10.2%
However, Slack Investor still thinks that the S&P 500 is over valued. Regardless of the current cycle, to invest in the whole index would be lumbering my portfolio with some cyclical and low growth companies.
I will continue to skew my investments portfolio with growing businesses – regardless of which sector they are in. I will not always get the company selection right – and will suffer the occasional whack. That’s fine, as long as I get it “mostly right”.
At the moment, many of the high P/E, growing businesses that Slack Investor owns are being sold down as analysts adjust down future earnings because of anticipated inflation. But the companies I own were usually selected for their ability to set their own prices and increase their earnings … these are the qualities of businesses that will prevail – regardless of short-term fluctuations.
I did a north to south crossing of Africa 36 years ago, mostly in a 4-wheel drive truck and, if we stopped in a village, my routine would be to grab the water containers and find a well. This was always a pleasant task as it involved a line-up, sign language and usually a few giggles at the strange visitor’s expense. Overwhelmingly, the well would be attended by women and there was usually an air of joy and strong comradery in the queue.
CSL have just gone to the “well” – with a Share Purchase Plan (SPP). They have purchased a Swiss company, Vifor Pharma (VIFN:SWX), which specialises in iron deficiency and renal disease. The acquisition cost US$11.7 billion and they have already covered most of this with an institutional placement and some new debt. CSL is trying to raise another $750 million from the “well” of shareholders pockets – and they seem likely to get it – let’s hope they will be welcomed back when they need water next time.
It seems to be the way of things that institutions (Brokers and Super Funds) get the first slice … and when this is done, there is a limited offer to retail investors – just to stop them whinging. Most of the time I participate in any share purchase plans as a convenient way to accumulate shares without the cost of brokerage. The CSL offer is set at $273 (or a 2% discount to the share price if CSL shares fall below this mark). Bids for the stock must be lodged by the 7th February, 2022.
“The combination with Vifor Pharma is expected to be financially compelling for our shareholders while expanding and diversifying our revenue base. It is expected to be immediately earnings accretive in the first full year of CSL ownership …”
Nice words Mr Perreault … but I have never ever read a share purchase plan that didn’t offer these comforting sentiments – CEO’s usually love to inform us of their astute decisions. “earnings accretive” just means that after all costs and synergies, the earnings per CSL share (EPS) should go up … and, when earnings go up, the share price should go up.
The projections for acquisitions and mergers are always complicated – the only real proof … will be down the track.
(There is) 30 years of evidence demonstrating that most acquisitions don’t create value for the acquiring company’s shareholders
CSL do have a good track record of acquiring new assets and turning them into future growth engines. However, The CSL offer to acquire Vifor Pharma was generous at 40% above the Vifor list price. But this is where it gets even more complicated, the size of the premium is historically not a good predictor of how the deal will turn out. The most pertinent question is “Has CSL paid more than the acquisition was worth to to CSL.” Slack Investor has no answers yet … We will see how this deal settles.
On 14/01/2022, the CSL share price was $276.00 – A premium of $3.00 to the $273 offer price – or about 1% – so the SPP offer price is no real bargain. Despite Slack Investor’s endless devotion for the company, it seems that the market is currently out of love with CSL.
In the background, despite ongoing problems with plasma collection due to COVID-19, CSL has increased its profit for the past two financial years by 20% – but its share price does not really reflect that. After a rapid increase in 2019, the share price has gone nowhere in the last two years. Macquarie analysts have a 12-month price target on CSL of $338.
Unlike Big Kev, I’m not super excited … The investor presentation, as always, looks compelling – full of talk about global reach, synergies and “developing a significant renal franchise”. But what really impressed me was the confirmation of CSL FY22 NPAT guidance of US$2,150 million – US$2,250 million. This is not advice, even though Slack Investor already has a big holding in this company, he will be participating in a slice of the CSL 2022 SPP.
Scaling Back
One of the annoying things about share purchase plans is the “scaling back”. If the SPP represents a good deal … they are usually oversubscribed. The 2021 Commonwealth Bank (CBA) SPP was such a good deal for retirees that they stumped up $18 billion more than the amount of shares on offer. Their share bids were scaled back by 79.4%. If you applied for $20 000 of CBA, you would have to send off this amount – and you would have been rewarded with $4120 of shares – and then have to wait for your refund.
The CSL 2022 SPP is not as immediately financially rewarding as the CBA offer and will probably not be scaled back as much. CSL has assured share owners that after the SPP, they will at least retaining their percentage shareholding in the company,
Slack Investor has done some rough calculations. As this new placement and SPP represents approximately 5.1% of current CSL ordinary shares on issue -This means that I should be able to buy at least 5.1% of my current holdings in the SPP without the inconvenience of scaling back.
If I owned $120 000 of CSL shares, I would be guaranteed to get at least $6120 (120K x 0.051) in the new SPP without scaling back. I round this up to the nearest allowable dollar value parcel, which is $10000 – and that’s how much I will apply for. Most people would apply for more (up to $30K) – but my portfolio is heavy with CSL, and this scaling back process just annoys me! CSL will of course refund any scaled back monies as soon as practicable after 14/02/2022 – without interest.
Pizza scissors – The new “Must Have” – These highly rated Kitchen Maestro Pizza Scissors were available at Amazon for $12 USD, but sadly, for pre-Christmas shoppers – currently out of stock.
Fish swim, birds fly, humans think, create and innovate. Thinking is not something that people do because we like it, we do it because it is our way of surviving.
An amazing trait that we humans have is the ability to innovate. Slack Investor admires the innovators and the intellectual capital that they bring to businesses. Ideas and research are a vital part of a growth company. Research and Development (R&D) may lead to more efficient production processes or better products that give a company future growth. I have long been a big fan of companies with a high spend on R&D and I am happy to invest in these stocks.
According to the data from EFPIA, in the percentages below, the big spenders are in just a few sectors. The survey looked at 2,500 companies around the world. Technology companies usually have a big R&D budget, but the pharmaceutical and biotechnology industry lead by spending 15% of revenue on R&D. NASDAQ figures for specific companies, show R&D expenditure for Google (Alphabet) was 15% of its revenue in 2020, CSL about 11%, and Microsoft 13%. Apple was a relatively low 7% – but they have a very small range of products.
Proportion of Revenue spent on R&D by each Industry sector – EFPIA
Just because a company has a high R&D spend does not always guarantee success. As well of the discovery of ideas that might be useful in the business, a company must be really good at the Incubation, and Acceleration of these ideas. It is important to look for an established record in the way a business brings new products to fruition.
However, there is a broad link between innovation and value. The Boston Consulting Group(BCG) compile a yearly list and map the performance of the 50 most innovative companies. In 2021, they found that the more innovative businesses had an average Total Shareholder Return (TSR) premium of 3.3% over the MSCI World Index.
Outperformance of the most Innovative companies – From the VisualCapitalist
“If I have 1,000 ideas and only one turns out to be good, I am satisfied.”
Alfred Nobel
Top 10 Most Innovative companies – published in the Visual Capitalist from BCG data.
The full list of top 50 innovators is worth a look and is a reminder that these are the companies that a lot of people interact with every day.
I have been a continual investor in theBetashares NASDAQ ETF(ASX: NDQ) that gives me access many of these great innovative companies. Every time that Slack Investor looks at the businesses that make up the NASDAQ 100, I think that this technology area must be where growth is still happening – and I want to be invested here.
According to GuruFocus the 12-mth forward PE of the NASDAQ 100 is 27 (A bit expensive) but the Return on Equity is at 18% – and growing (This is good).
Slack Investor also owns a slice of the Asian Technology giants with BetaShares Asia Technology Tigers ETF (ASX: ASIA). The heavy hand of Chinese government interference in some tech stocks has led to a pullback in price this year. But I have maintained my holding because Chinese companies like the search engine Baidu, the e-commerce giant Alibaba, and the technology beast Tencent will not be held back for long.
A good compromise, if you want a more whole world approach, is the ETFS Morningstar Global Technology ETF(ASX: TECH). This ETF has holdings distributed across the United States (89.6%), Australia (5.8%), Japan (2.4%), and Germany (2.2%) and has a “moat” filter that will only select companies that have built a competitive advantage around their businesses. All of this for a Management fee of less than 0.5%.
Innovative company shares do not always go up. An example of this is is the new Cathie Wood disruptive innovation stocks ETF – (ARKK). Early investors are very happy, recent investors not. However, with a 3-5 year time frame, exposure to the whole NASDAQ index – the top 100 of the (mostly) great NASDAQ companies must be a good thing.
This is not advice, but if I cant buy pizza scissors for Christmas – I might as well top up with some more NDQ or ASIA, or expand into TECH.
That old troubadour Bob Dylan released this back in 1964 …on vinyl … I might add! Bob’s lyrics were written almost 60 years ago about the cultural and political divide that existed way back in the early 1960’s. His message to “start swimmin’ or you’ll sink like a stone” continues to have relevance – even to investors.
Music has been an important part of Slack Investor’s life and starting with my first “record” vinyl purchase in high school, I then went through the cassette phase. Cassettes were always a bit dodgy, but they did have their moments – who can forget the sublime “mix tape” given to you by a friend. The gradual degradation of cassette musical quality as they lost their magnetism and, the ultimate tragedy when your precious “mix tape” starts unravelling in the car. All this made me glad when CD’s were introduced in 1982. Aaahh … the beautiful world of the CD – Digital quality and a format that I thought would live forever. Only in hindsight do we see that “Peak CD” was in 1999 and this was also the peak of recorded music revenue for artists. I could look at the below chart for hours.
The changing shape of revenues from recorded music delivery 1980 – 2020. – This incredible graphic is from Statista
Despite the recent uptick in vinyl sales, it seems obvious that the days of owning music are numbered. It is also sad to note that revenues from recorded music in 2014 sank to a third of those in 1999. Revenues are on the increase but royalties from streaming remain pitifully low and artists can be paid as little as 13% of the streaming income generated. The recording artists must resort to touring and merchandising to provide the bulk of their income. The highest grossing act of 2017 was U2. According to Billboard – their streaming income was only just over 1% of their total revenue of 54.4 million USD.
Spotify generally pays between $US.003 and $US.005 per stream, meaning you’ll need about 250 streams to make a dollar.
In an unbelievable turn of events for all “Boomers”, streaming is now the way to access recorded music and now accounts for 83 percent of music industry revenues in the U.S. Physical CD’s and even music downloads are in major decline.
All of that music stuff was just to provide an example about how unexpected change can happen in just a few decades. Slack Investor had built up an impressive CD collection over the past 30 years and, he thought he was set up for life. This collection is now in a box as I now tend to now use digital versions for my musical pleasures. To the great dismay of my children, I am still hanging on to ownership of my music – they tell me this is typical “boomer” behaviour and are urging me to get on board the streaming train.
We always overestimate the change that will occur in the next two years and underestimate the change that will occur in the next ten. Don’t let yourself be lulled into inaction.
Bill Gates
Bill has pointed to a bit of a weakness in the vision of investors … and Slack Investor obviously cherishes his moments of inaction – but will act if he has to. He has already made a few tweaks in his portfolio
I have been thinking of relatively safe investments lately … and this is tricky in these weird times as, besides precious metals, it is difficult to name a sector that would be unaffected by an inevitable downturn in the markets. Will bricks and mortar retail be the same? Will CBD office real estate be the same? Will banks be the same with the new competition from Neobanks?
With the exception of consumer staples, safety may not be found in traditional industries. Technology is such a large part of our lives now – and this is where growth will happen. I keep returning to the utility of an Index like the NASDAQ 100. It has the beautiful self correcting mechanism where dud technologies get shuffled out of the bottom of the index and the companies that are still making money tend to stay in.
I have been a buyer of this ETF along the way and a recent dip in price (perhaps due to the recent Facebook revelations) point to an increasing mood for more regulation in some of the tech stocks. Barrons have the current PE at 34.5 which does not make it cheap but the PE based upon the forward 12-mth earnings forecast is a bit more reasonable for the growth sector at 28.0. In this changing world, the one thing that you can bank on is that the technology industry will be an important part of it. Not advice … but I think I will buy some more.
As much as Slack Investor hates retail shopping – he loves to have the opportunity to buy into companies. Like any new relationship, when you buy a stock, you are not really sure about how its going to work out – but its exciting!
I have never been good at predicting when the stock market will have a correction … and the current high valuations (PE Ratios well above the long term average) do make me nervous. However, Slack Investor would much rather be in the game than out of it and I have been looking for a few companies that would hopefully not suffer too greatly if a correction occurred in the stock market.
This is not advice … just an insight to the Slack Investor bumbling buying process. My rate of converting bought shares into winners of 55% is not that impressive – but my overall performance results are good.
I get heaps of buying ideas from investment sites such as Motley Fool, Livewire, ShareCafe. But I will always, always, check things out for myself before parting with any Slack Dollars. This involves a rigorous screening of the fundamental financial metrics PLUS a look at how the stock chart is going on Incredible Charts. This technical analysis consists of a quick scan to see if the chart is in a continual growth trend … or has just had a “breakout”, or broken out of a downtrend.
Let’s put on the buying boots. As well as the companies below, Slack Investor has also recently added to some small positions in PPK.ASX and TNE.ASX.
Slack Investor Buys Alphabet (GOOGL.NASDAQ)
Half of my buying cash went into an existing holding – Alphabet (GOOGL), This money making juggernaut is part of the new economy and I could buy this company all day. The first step is to go to the phenomenal MarketScreener.com. Registration is free on this site and they allow you to look at analyst data for up to 5 stocks a day.
Search for your stock and then finding the Financials Tab for that company. Firstly, I look at the chart Income/Sales and Earnings per Share. An increasing trend is good and, if the estimated earnings (2021 – 2023) are also increasing, I’m acutely interested. I do a quick check on debt levels. Alphabet is a cash king – has more cash than debt – solid tick.
Income statement for Alphabet (GOOGL on the US NASDAQ exchange) – from MarketScreener
I continue with MarketScreener to extract the Return on Equity (ROE), both past and forecast. I hope that it is above 15% – Big Tick. The final bit of vital information is the Price Earnings (PE) Ratio and it is here that I gauge whether the stock price is too high for Slack Investor. For a good growth stock, I try not to buy into companies that have a projected PE of more than 40-(50 at a pinch). The analyst estimates for GOOGL is a forecast PE of 23.0 in 2023 – Tick
YEAR
2018
2019
2020
2021(e)
2022(e)
2023(e)
ROE
18.6
19.3
19.0
27.2
25.8
25.2
PE Ratio
23.9
27.2
29.9
28.0
26.6
23.0
Table of fundamental financial metrics for Alphabet. The documented Return on Equity (ROE) and Price Earnings (PE) Ratio are shown for 2018-2020. Analyst estimates are shown for later years – MarketScreener.com
Slack Investor Buys NASDAQ 100 ETF (NDQ.ASX)
Not everyone has access to direct access to US shares – if you only have an ASX broker, then to get exposure to Alphabet, a good substitute is to buy the BetaShares NASDAQ ETF (NDQ) – Alphabet represents 8.1% of this ETF – and you get profit machines like Apple, Amazon, Microsoft and Facebook thrown in. I topped up my holding here as well.
The ROE for the NASDAQ Index is 17.7 and increasing (30 June 21) – Above 15, Tick. The projected 2023 estimate for the Price/Earnings Ratio for the NASDAQ Index is 22.47 – Below 40, Tick – Very reasonable for growth sector companies.
NASDAQ 100 Index 2020 PE Ratios and Forward Estimates of PE for 2021, 2022. 2023 – From nasdaq.com
Slack Investor Buys Coles Group (COL.ASX)
YEAR
2019
2020
2021(e)
2022(e)
2023(e)
2024(e)
ROE
29.8
32.8
37.0
34.9
33.3
34.3
PE Ratio
12.4
22.9
22.4
23.4
22.8
21.4
Table of Fundamental metrics for Coles Group . The documented Return on Equity (ROE) and Price Earnings (PE) Ratio are shown for 2019-2020. Analyst estimates are shown for later years– MarketScreener.com
The Return on Equity (ROE) for this retail business is pretty impressive and, the PE Ratio would be pretty good for a growth company – but the Income Chart below reveals that Coles is not really a “growth” company – so the expectation is that the PE Ratios should be much lower, in the early 20’s or below would be the Slack Limits for slow growth companies.
Income statement for Coles Group (COL.ASX) showing a very gradual increase in projected income – Compare this with the Alphabet chart above – from MarketScreener
The income chart shows some pretty shallow growth and the slow earnings per share (EPS) growth makes the Coles Group something that Slack Investor would not usually be interested in. But, I go to Coles Supermarket at least twice a week and I actually like going there as a company part owner. Coles is in the “stable income” section of the Slack Portfolio rather than “Growth”. Even if the worst of times was thrust upon us and there was a recession in the next few years, a business like Coles will keep on performing. I would much rather put up with the price fluctuation of shares and have my money in a business like this at a projected yield of 3.5 – 4% p.a. than have Slack Dollars tied up in cash for 2 years in a Big 4 bank term deposit at 0.3%.
August 2021 – End of Month Update
Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100.
There were significant rises in all followed markets (S&P 500 +2.9%, and the FTSE 100 +1.2%). The Australian stock market is also in record territory (ASX 200 +1. 9%). This is all happening during extensive COVID-19 related lockdowns in the populous South Eastern part of Australia.
Slack Investor is normally relaxed about most things, but I am moving to the edge of my couch and starting to get ready for action. Looking at the monthly charts for all the indexes, in these boom times, the index prices have been getting too far ahead of my stop losses for comfort. I have tightened up my rules for adjusting stop losses upwards.
All Stop Losses are live and are being moved upwards every month if the index price exceeds the stop loss by 10% or more. All Indexes have got this treatment this month – It is sometimes difficult to work out where to put the stop losses on the monthly chart. I usually go to the weekly charts and find a minimum on the weekly price range that is within 10% of the current price (see below). If the stock price is below the stop loss at the end of the week – I will usually sell at the next opportunity.
The weekly US S&P 500 Index chart showing an upward adjustment of the stop loss from 4056 to 4233 – Thanks Incredible Charts
All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).
“In the business world, the rear view mirror is always clearer than the windshield.”
Warren Buffett
Slack Investor has a proven track record in notbeing able to predict where speculative assets (such as Bitcoin or precious metals) are going. I would also add to the “speculative list” some companies whose share price have become divorced from the link to their actual earnings. As a rough guide, I try not to invest in companies that have a forward P/E ratio of greater than 50. I get these forward P/E ratios from the excellent Market Screener site.
This means that I have missed out on the great gains of being by in companies like Afterpay (APT – 2023 P/E ratio 190) or TESLA (TSLA – 2023 P/E ratio 193). Some folk have made a lot of money with these companies …. but they are just too speculative for me. Slack Investor tries to “stick to his knitting” with growing companies that have an established earnings record and forward P/E ratios <50.
After an eventful FY 2020 and the COVID-19 dip in the markets around the world. FY 2021, has seen very good gains for most global markets. In the UK, the FTSE 100 Total Return Index is up 18.1% (last FY 20 down 13.8%). Dividends helped the Australian Accumulation Index to be up 27.8% for the financial year (last FY down 7.7%). These Americans remain stupendously optimistic … the S&P 500 Total Return Index was UP 36.4% (last FY up 12.0%) for the same period. All of these Total Return Indexes include any accumulated dividends, wheras the chart below of the ASX 200 for FY 2021, just shows stock prices.
ASX 2oo Weekly chart for FY 2021 – started at 5897 and finished at 7313 (30 June 2020 – 30 June 2021) – Incredible Charts – Click for better resolution.
Slack Portfolio Results FY 2021
All Performance results are before tax. The Slack Portfolio had a cracking year with annual FY 2020 performance of +21.7%. Full yearly results with benchmarks are shown in the table below. It was also a top year for all benchmarks (Median Balance Fund +13.0%, Vanguard Growth Fund +20.3%, ASX 200 Accumulation +27.8%).
Against all Slack Investor predictions … Real Estate turned out to be a great investment in the Brisbane and Melbourne markets for FY 2021 (+17.9% and +10.7%) – Perhaps I should also give up on the “looking ahead” in the residential property market – I just don’t get it!
The five-year compound annual performance gives me a much better idea about how things are going and will smooth out any dud (or remarkable!) results.
Slack Investor 5-year compound annual rate of return – compared to benchmarks – Click for better resolution.
The beauty of compounding with a succession of good performance results can be seen in the chart below showing the growth of an initial investment in June 2009 of $10000.
The rate of growth of $10000 invested by Slack Investor in FY 2009 – compared to benchmarks – Click for better resolution.
The lessons of long term investing
Every year Vanguard publish their performance data on each asset class. Slack Investor looks forward to this – as it reminds him of the power of the appreciating asset classes of Shares and Property. Vanguard highlights the volatility of asset values in the short term – but also emphasizes the joys of holding and accumulating shares or property for long periods of time. These asset classes have steadily increased in value over the last 30 years. $10000 invested in Australian Shares in 1990 would have compounded to $160 498. Staying in Cash would have yielded $38 938.
2021 Vanguard Index Chart
Extract from the 2021 Vanguard Index chart (Just the 2008-2021 portion) – the dollar values on the right are the results of investing $10000 in index funds in each asset class for 30 years (since July 1991). – Check out the full glory of the Vanguard 2021 PDF chart – Click for better resolution.
Financial year total returns (%) for the major asset classes
In the chart below, for each asset class the total annual returns are given and the best performing class for each year is marked in green … and the worst in gold. What stands out to Slack Investor is that is rare for and asset class to lead in annual returns (green) for two years in a row – and there are years where the leading asset class (green) becomes the worst performer (gold) in the next year. This drives home the often repeated sentence in the finance world.
Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.
Total returns for each asset class for the 30 years since 1991 – Check out the full glory of the Vanguard 2021 PDF – Click for better resolution.
This table highlights the benefits of diversification across asset classes for the long term investor.
Sitting on the couch, Slack Investor is quietly pleased with his 2021 results – Roll on Financial year 2022. However, when comparing this year’s bumper returns with the long term average returns for Australian and International shares of around 10% – Slack Investor can’t help but be a little nervous.
“It’s not whether you’re right or wrong that’s important, but how much money you make when you’re right and how much you lose when you’re wrong.“
George Soros
Now George knows how to make a dollar and, to his great credit, is a generous philanthropist. I am sure, like any successful investor, that George looks back at times on his investment decisions. Slack Investor looks forward to this time of year when I can reflectively analyse my greatest investing failures. Fortunately, my stinker to nugget ratio was good this year.
The percentage yearly returns quoted in this post include costs (brokerage) but, the returns are before tax. This raw figure can then be compared with other investment returns. I use Market Screener to analyse the financial data from each company and extract the predicted 2023 Return on Equity and 2023 Price/Earnings Ratio on the companies below. This excellent site allows free access (up to a daily limit) to their analysts data once you register with an email address.
Slack Investor Stinkers – FY 2021
Growth stocks (High Return on Equity >15% and increasing sales) are fantastic companies to associate with as they are growing and hopefully, their earnings per share, are growing also. The downside to this is that these companies are usually sought after in the stock market and command high prices in relation to their current earnings because the “future earnings” of the company are priced into the current price. This gives them a high PE Ratio. Whenever there is a future earnings revision, or a stutter in growth, there is usually a dramatic drop in price.
Slack Investor has a look at his stocks every weekend on a free chart program (Thanks Incredible Charts!). I actually pay a small amount to get the chart data early in the morning. Both of my “stinkers” this year were actually “nuggets” from last year. For FY 2020, Appen +58% and A2M +26%. Such is the cyclic nature of some growth stocks.
Appen (APX) -24%
APX (2023 ROE 14%, 2023 PE 19) remains a company that puzzles me “the development of human-annotated datasets for machine learning and artificial intelligence”. The company has had a few problems due to COVID-19 and a hit to its underlying profit and increased competition. Slack Investor got out late last year at $25.87 as the weekly chart moved below the stop loss at $28.11. However, this represented a loss of 24% for the financial year.
The downward trend marked by the thick blue line is setting up niciely for one of Slack Investors favourite chart trading patterns – “The Wedgie”. When the share price punches through a downward trend line of at least 6 months … and the fundamentals are right, Slack Investor is interested. Given the forward PE for 2023 is a relatively low 19 – I might have another crack at this once the price has poked above the blue wedge line.
A2 Milk (A2M) -21%
A2M (2023 ROE 17%, 2023 PE 23) sells A2 protein milk products to the world. The actual benefits of the A2 only protein seem to be limited to easier digestion. Long term independent studies with large data sets are still in the works … but the marketing skill of this company is undisputed. COVID-19 brought big changes to sales with the collapse of the “daigou” market and worries about China trade sanctions. Slack Investor sold about half way through the downtrend – but not before taking a hit for the team.
Slack Investor Nuggets – FY 2021
A great benefit of investing in companies that have a high Return on Equity, and with a track record of increasing earnings, is that they sometimes behave as “golden nuggets”.
Codan (CDA) +161%
What a company! Codan is a technology company that specializes in communications and metal detecting. It has made a major US acquisition this year and paid with cash. Sales are up and predicted to keep increasing. The high 2023 ROE 32%, and relatively low 2023 PE 24 (for a growth company) makes me think there will be more price growth over the next few years – I will try and top up my position this year on any price weakness.
Alphabet (GOOGL) +61%
(GOOGL – 2023 ROE 23%, 2023 PE 23) The Alphabet list of products continues to grow. I use a ton of Alphabet products every day and the company is growing fast into the cloud with cloud computing revenue jumping 46% in the March quarter. There are a few regulatory problems coming up with the US Justice department claiming that Google’s actions harmed consumers and competition. There is also the ongoing work of G7 nations trying to make international tech companies pay their rightful share of tax on revenues in each country.
Despite this, if there is one company that Slack Investor could invest in and then pay no attention to for 10 years, and still sleep well, … it would be Alphabet.
REA Group (REA) +59%
The owners of RealEstate.com.au. which is the go to portal for house selling and buying (REA – 2023 ROE 38%, 2023 PE 44). The group has just completed an acquisition of Mortgage Choice and picked up a big chunk of a Mortgage software company. This expanding of the business must be good. 65% of Australia’s adult population are checking the site every month looking at property listings and home prices. However, the 2023 projected PE is very high (44). Using the Slack Investor bench marks, suggests the stock is expensive at the moment.
Integral Diagnostics (IDX) +37%
This medical image company (2023 ROE 16%, 2023 PE 24) provides diagnostic image services to GP’s and specialists. IDX seems to be getting a few tail winds with an ageing population and more demand for their MRI, CT and PET scans.
Macquarie Group (MQG) +36%
Macquarie is a complex business(2023 ROE 14%, 2023 PE 17) with a range of banking and financial services, and plays in global markets and asset management. The latter division looks for undervalued companies. Despite COVID-19, profits are increasing. The management seem to know what they are doing – Slack Investor remains a fan.
Betashares Global Robotics And Artificial Intelligence ETF (RBTZ) +36%
This ETF tracks the megatrend of robotics and artificial intelligence. Although the PE ratio is a bit high (2021 PE Ratio 37), this is a disruptive sector that should make gains against existing industries with the advantage of technology against rising labour costs.
Most honourable mentions to those other companies that returned over 20% for the tax year. Cochlear (COH) +34%, BetaShares Nasdaq ETF (NDQ) +33%, VanEyk MOAT ETF (MOAT) +32%, Vanguard International ETF (VGE) +29%, BetaShares HACK ETF (HACK) +31%, Vanguard Asia ETF (VAE) +28%, BetaShares QLTY ETF (QLTY) +25%. To these companies, I am grateful for your service.
Slack Investor Total SMSF performance – FY 2021 and July 2021 end of Month Update
A great year for shares, Chant West reports Super funds have delivered their strongest financial year result in 24 years, with the median growth fund (61 to 80% in growth assets) returning 18% for FY21. The FY 2021 Slack Investor preliminary total SMSF performance looks like coming in at around 22%. The 5-yr performance is a more useful benchmark to me – as it takes out the bouncing around of yearly returns. At the end of FY 2021, the Slack Portfolio has a compounding annual 5-yr return of over 21%.
Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares The FTSE 100 had a flat month (-0.1%) but rises in the US Index S&P 500 (+2.3%) and the ASX 200 (+1.1%).
The party with the US S&P 500 just keeps on going. As the S&P 500 has moved more than 20% higher than its stop loss on the monthly chart, I have adjusted the stop loss upward to 4056 from 3622. It is difficult to decide where to put the stop loss on the monthly US Index chart. In these cases, I go to the weekly chart and look for a “sensible place” to put the stop loss coinciding with a minimum value (dip) on the chart. The current stop loss is 8% below the end of month price.
US Index (S&P 500) weekly chart showing a moving up of the stop loss this month.
“Bull markets are born on pessimism, grow on skepticism, mature on optimism and die on euphoria.”
Sir John Templeton
John Templeton (1912 – 2008) was a great investor, fund manager and philanthropist. He is best known for setting up the Templeton Growth Fund which averaged returns of over 15% per year for 38 years. Slack Investor salutes this kind of behaviour and listens when great investors say something. If Mr Templeton is right, this game should be pretty easy and we wait till the “Euphoria” sets in and the we sell … Right?
Well, according to the CitiGroup Panic and Euphoria Index , which looks at sentiment in the market back to 1950. The section from 1987 through to the start of 2021 is shown below – Euphoria is already well and truly established by December 2020. However, most markets have gone up considerably further since then!
Source: Haver Analytics, Pinnacle Data, and Citi Research – diamondportfolio.com.au– Click image for better resolution
This is a bit of a complex chart, and the grey solid columns represent the return from the US Stock market for the next 12 months (forward return) and the Magenta line is the Citibank Euphoria Index which tracks market sentiment.
Visually, it looks like whenever the Euphoria Index (LHS – Magenta) goes to a high value, there is a downturn in the next 12-month return (RHS – Grey). Citibank have defined a range (Blue Lines) where the market is operating “normally” and outline areas of Euphoria and Panic when the market is beyond that range. According to Citibank, we are in a period of Euphoria and the prospect of good returns in the next 12 months looks bleak. The Chief Economist from Citigroup, Tobias Lekovich, suggests that there is a “100% historical probability of down markets in the next 12 months at current levels.” – that proclamation was made 5 months ago.
Another Slack Investor hero, Warren Buffet, talks about the ratio of total United States stock market valuation to US Gross Domestic Product (GDP). This is now known as the “Buffet Indicator” – and, although he admits to its limitations, it still is “the best single measure of where valuations stand at any given moment“. At April 22, 2021 the Buffett Indicator is calculated to be 234% – the highest value since 1950. In contrast, the Australian market using this indicator is either “fair valued” or “modestly overvalued”
From Current Market Valuation – The Buffett Indicator is the ratio of total US stock market valuation to GDP – Click image for better resolution
By our calculation (the US Stock Market) that is currently 88% (or about 2.9 standard deviations) above the historical average, suggesting that the market is Strongly Overvalued
There are a lot of current examples of “investor exuberance” in the stock markets – particularly in the US. There is no doubt that the pricing of some companies has got well out of hand. The earnings of a company are critical when I look at my investments.
Another risk is that pockets of the market at the moment appear to be speculative bubbles. You can easily tally about US$5 trillion of assets, from cryptocurrencies to Tesla, that are not underpinned by any fundamental earnings. They’re speculation. And if these bubbles were to pop, that could drag down a wider range of investments.
There are a group of companies that I like that I have no intention of selling – because they have a good track record of increasing earnings and there future prospects look good – no matter what the market does in the short term. There is also about 40% my portfolio in stocks where I am not so sure of their long term prospects. It is these stocks that I will be watching closely at the end ofevery week and have set stop losses that will indicate to me that I should sell if the price falls below the stop loss.
Slack Investor is happy to go along for the ride and has no real faith in his prediction ability. Sure, stocks are at extreme valuations but these are very unusual times. Interest rates are very low and there has been an unprecedented amount of government spending to keep economies going along.
Still on the couch, I don’t feel euphoria … but I feel OK … I have a plan.
April 2021 – End of Month Update
Despite the “exuberance”, Slack Investor is still on the wave and remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. All Slack Investor followed markets this month had strong rises (ASX 200 +3.5%; FTSE 100 +3.8%; S&P 500 +5.3%).
In these uncertain times, especially with the high prices on the US market, I am monitoring my index funds weekly and if, at the end of the week my Index funds are below the stop loss, then I will put a post on the blog and sell at the next opportunity. All Stop Losses are Live.
All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).
Mr James Brown (1933 – 2006) – an R&B, funk, and soul music legend – “The hardest thing about being James Brown is I have to live. I don’t have no down time” – Image from Rolling Stone
Slack Investor might be showing his age here … but when I think of R&B (Rhythm & Blues), it’s not Drake or The Weeknd that I think of, its “The Hardest Working Man in Show Business” that comes to mind. James Brown had a bit of a trouble in his life but there is no denying his talent and influence – 4 minutes of his genius can be seen here.
The one thing that can solve most of our problems is dancing
James Brown
But I digress, when the dancing is finished, R&D (Research and Development) is another thing that gets Slack Investor attention – especially when it comes to finding a company to invest in. Lets have a look at the world top ten spenders on Research and Development. This quality list of companies is peppered with representation from the tech, pharmaceutical and (electric) car sectors. One of the ways that a company can keep growing is to develop an upstream pipeline of products through research, patenting, and testing. It may take many years before they are released so the companies must be patient and long sighted – not all products in the pipeline will be a success.
Ranking of the 20 companies with the highest spending on R & D in 2018 (in billion U.S. dollars) – From Statista.com
I don’t often read company annual reports as I lack forensic accounting skills and they are usually thick and masterpieces of obfuscation. But, I am usually very impressed when, in the overview, a decent slab of profits are going back into R&D. Slack Investor would rather invest in companies that are constantly innovating, and investing in future products. Only some of these products will yield fruit, but you would hope that these high spending R&D companies would generate bigger profits than those that don’t. Although, this is not always the case! In some cases, the world of R&D can be full of questionable spending, uncertain results.
Despite a 20% price fall in the CSL share price in the past 6 months, there is no thought of Slack investor selling this great company. It is one of my “Long Run” stocks. I have often written about share prices fluctuating above and below a “fair value” for a stock . This is just a characteristic of share investing – depending on the mood of the market.
A weekly chart of the CSL share price showing a 20% fall in the last 6 mth -From incrediblecharts.com
CSL is not in the world R&D big spending league in dollar terms. But, in Australia, it is one of our best R&D spenders with almost a billion dollars (US) per year. This amount is very high as a percentage of its revenue, in an environment where a typical manufacturer will spend 1-2%, CSL spending on Research and Development is between 10 to 11 per cent of turnover. Slack Investor thinks this is a good thing and is happy that CSL is occupying a big chunk of his portfolio.
CSL have many products in the R&D pipeline and have a good track record of converting at least some of these products into successful earners. Some other analysts agree and have a target price of $310 on the stock. With current pricing at $253.26 (12 Mar 21) – this smells good!
I taught them everything they know, but not everything I know
– Adapted from ‘Three Mounds’ by Yoko Ono is displayed at the Serpentine Gallery on June 18, 2012 in London, England – From Getty Images.
With apologies to Yoko for interfering with her art, but Slack Investor first thought of his own “Three Pile Theory” back in 1989 when I had got myself a “Proper Job” and enough stability in my life to make the big plunge into Real Estate. At that time, I owned a few grains of dirt in my House pile (the Bank owned the rest), My income was OK, and my investments (which would later morph into the Slack Fund) contained a few thousand dollars in shares.
Now, 32 years later, Slack Investor still has these three financial pillars to keep himself steady.
House – Home ownership gives me great security and pleasure. The bank owned most of this 30 years ago – but now I have the upper hand! (~30% of Net Worth)
Stable Income – This used to be my job, but in retirement I have some stable income annuity style investment (~20% of Net Worth) that would pay my bills and maintain a basic Slack Lifestyle should Armageddon befall the stock markets for a few years. This income is supplemented by income from the Slack Portfolio.
Slack Portfolio Investments – (~50% of Net Worth) – Now currently in my Self Managed Super fund (SMSF) which is almost exclusively invested in growth companies. These are great businesses to be invested in if you have a long term horizon – however, stock prices can be volatile in these high Return on Equity (ROE) companies. I am currently retired and do not rely on the Slack Portfolio for stable income. Because of the stability of my other two pillars, I can be quite aggressive in the allocation of my investments in the Slack Portfolio – as I know I will not have to panic sell (for income) during any downturn.
Slack Investor didn’t really invent “Pile theory” – it has been around for a while in various guises – Three Buckets is a tried and true way to manage your retirement expenses by dividing your retirement stash into buckets of cash, conservative investments and more risky, growth investments.
House
My home may not feel like a palace to you, but to me, it is a whole Kingdom.
There are some who argue that you are financially better off by renting over a 10-year period rather than buying. But for Slack Investor, the tax advantages – no capital gains tax on your own home in Australia; the leverage – banks are usually willing to lend at least 80% of the house value; the forced saving – your mortgage payment is a big monthly portion of your income which you set aside for a long period; and, the stability provided by home ownership make this a clear winner for me. “The Serenity” is just a bonus.
Stable Income
To cover living expenses and to give yourself “peace of mind” it is so important to have a slab of money that is not subject to the vagaries of the sharemarket. In Australia, if you haven’t enough super to go independently, you might qualify for a full or part pension.
If going the fully self-funded route, many advisors recommend your stable income should be in two parts. You should work out your living expenses for a year and then keep between 2 and 5 years worth of expenses in stable cash deposits – Let’s start with 3 years of expenses in accessible cash. The rest of you stable income pile can be in longer term cash deposits, bonds or REITS. Because the investments pile (Slack Portfolio) is in growth shares that can be very volatile, my stable income must be something that is not highly correlated to to the sharemarket.
Term Deposits– although interest rates are woefully low now on bank term deposits, it is still possible to get ~1% p.a. from some of the minor banks that still have the Government Guarantee for the first $250 000.
MER (0.20%) – Annual performance over 1/5 years – (4.08%/4.49%)
Challenger Fixed Term Annuity – Rates are pretty low at the moment, locking away a deposit for 5 years will earn a measly 1.65%.
Real Estate or Real Estate Investment Trusts (REIT) – these are a bit higher up the risk curve but as they produce income (rent) and can be associated with longer term leases – are usually less volatile than the share market. For example, Vanguard Australian Property Securities Index ETF (VAP) – MER (0.23%) – Annual performance over 1/5 years – (-13.3%/6.23%)
Investments – The Slack Fund
Because the Slack Portfolio is mostly in growth shares, I have steeled myself that this particular pile is volatile and changes value every day. I am prepared for a few low performing (or even negative) years in a row for this pile. Even great investors that have much more knowledge than Slack Investor have the occasional bad year – during some periods, share investments just perform poorly. I am accepting of this truth.
Because this Investment pile is mostly in my Self Managed Super Fund (SMSF), I am usually obliged to withdraw 4% of its total value each year – this percentage increases with age – but this payment is currently tax free for those over 60. I can use this income in a discretionary way. My living expenses should be covered by income from the Stable Income pile – and any other income is gravy.
Pile Rebalancing
Once you are in a house that you are happy in and hopefully will be near paying off any outstanding loans as you get into retirement – other than maintenance, you can leave this pile alone.
The Stable Income cash pile might occasionally need a bit of topping up from the longer term stable Income or Investments fund. Any dividend or interest income from your investments is fair game. The investment Slack Fund usually produces 2 -3% income.
Hopefully, with 3-years worth of living expenses in the stable income pile, you can ride out a few bad years in the share market and only sell shares to top up the stable income pile when the share market has had a good run. Ideally, you would only sell share assets out of this pile when the share market is above the long term trend line. However, realistically, from the chart below (in red) there are long periods when the market is below trend. Have no fear, your basic expenses are always covered by a mixture of stable income, interest and dividends.
The long term chart of the US S&P 500 with the dotted inflation-adjusted long term trend line – from seeitmarket.com
There are other piles worthy of attention such as Health and Relationships but the finance stuff is necessary too. So get the shovel out … and start working on those piles!
