Kenny makes this sound easy, but selling shares is tricky and Slack Investor does not always get this decision right – and I’m OK with that. The Slack Investor art is just to attempt to get things “mostly right”. There are some stocks that I will hold for the long run, and their weekly and monthly charts are not of a big concern to me. However, about half of my portfolio is on a weekly or monthly watch – I review the Incredible Charts output for each of these stocks on the weekend or at the end of the month.
I pay particular attention when the stock price falls below my stop loss on the monthly chart. In hindsight, I should have been more alert back in August. A2M is a good company with a unique product and has shown excellent growth in the last 5 years. However, earnings season is always a bit volatile for the growth sector.
The FY20 results showed a record profit but there were some question marks about FY21. The real catalyst for a downward price move was the later release of an acquisition and that members of the board and senior executive team had sold over 1.8 million shares. Selling by insiders is not always bad, as the executives might just be diversifying their portfolios – However, in this case, the market took a dim view. Overall, the A2 Milk Company Ltd(ASX: A2M) share price has slumped more than 15% since the release of its FY21 outlook.
Monthly Price chart of The A2 Milk Company (A2M) showing a buy in at $11.66 in January 2019 and a sell at $15.40 at the end of September 2020. I took the opportunities to gradually creep up my stop loss from the original value of $11.11 to $17.08 – From incrediblecharts.com
I am not known for my fast work and have tended to take the couch rather than make a decision in the past. However, in the spirit of incremental improvement, I didn’t wait till the end of the month and pounced on the sell button on the day that the A2M fell more than 10%, 28th September 2020.
Daily Price chart of The A2 Milk Company (A2M). Slack investor sold on the day news leaked out about insider selling on September 28 – From incrediblecharts.com
I am not put off A2M forever. The end of month share price was $13.67. There is now a reasonable case for re-investing given the growth pathway beyond 2021 and the Market Screener , relatively low, 2023 predicted PE of 19. There has now been a downward trend of 3 months and Slack Investor’s favourite pattern has started to emerge … “The Wedgie”. If there is a break above “the Wedgie”, I will reinvest and hope the share price resumes an uptrend.
” … the secret to survivin’ is knowing what to throw away, and knowing what to keep …”
Ooooh Kenny … the secret to investing is simple to describe, but harder to do … but you knew how to tell a good story!
October 2020 – End of Month Update
Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. However, the US and UK charts are hovering close to their monthly stop losses.
The state of recent COVID-19 surges in Europe and the US seems to be worrying punters and monthly falls were recorded in these markets (S&P 500 -2.8%; FTSE 100 -4.9%). In Australia, the governments are handling the response to the virus in a constructive fashion and the ASX 200 rose 1.9%.
On the ASX 200 Index monthly chart, a new “Higher Low” was established and this gave me the opportunity to move up my monthly stop loss to 5763.
But it’ll be all right, it’ll be all right, it’ll be all right in the long run …
Excerpt from the “Long Run” lyrics by Redgum (John Schuman) released in 1980.
Slack Investor looks at the shares that he owns occasionally and has a bit of a tinker. Earlier this year I had a portfolio review that saw a dumping of managed funds and high fee ETF’s. I also made an attempt to exit shares that I thought might be severely affected by gloomy economic times. However, sometimes it is good to lift the sights to the horizon and forget about the short term pricing of the market.
“Over the 210 years I have examined stock returns, the real return on a broadly diversified portfolio of stocks has averaged 6.6 percent per year.”
Although the last financial year was a bit bleak for the median of super growth funds (-0.5%), Slack Investor has been around long enough to know that the gloomy times are periodic, and that, “In the Long Run” shares are a very good investment – as can be seen on the 28-year performance chart below.
The Performance of the median Australian Superannuation Growth Fund over the past 28 years. A “Growth Fund” is defined to have between 60 – 80% of Growth Assets – From Chant West
During my portfolio review I realised that over half my portfolio is in several companies that I would never sell – unless circumstances changed greatly! These companies usually have great management, a plan for growth, and an established track record in increasing Earnings per Share (EPS). Prices may go up and down, but great companies ride though all this and figure out a way to keep growing.
Coles (COL)
COL (2022 ROE 36%, 2022 PE 23) – With around 30% of all supermarket sales, Coles is one of the lucky retailers classified as essential and is getting a boost from COVID-19. This boost wont last forever, and, I cant see any big growth ahead. But, I can’t see myself selling this company as I visit it twice a week to “kick the tyres” and they are doing a good job. There is also the perverse satisfaction of knowing that if I am waiting at the checkout for a time … that it must be good for the bottom line!
Altium (ALU)
ALU (2022 ROE 32%, 2022 PE 56). The PE ratio of Altium has it priced for big future growth and it would be a stretch to buy it now. But this printed circuit board designer is a company for the times and it has a well defined, and so far achievable, global growth strategy.
Although relatively expensive (Forecast PE 56), Altium has no debt, a decent cash balance and keeps growing its profit margin and market share. In 2019, Altium spend 14% of its revenue on Research and Development – This is a commitment to growth in a changing industry.
Commonwealth Serum Laboratory (CSL)
CSL (2022 ROE 29%, 2022 PE 38) – Slack investor first bought into this company 10 years ago at around $30 and I have had the good fortune to add to my holding (at much higher prices!) along the way. CSL is expensive at a forecast PE of 38, but I can remember at my initial purchase in 2010, I thought it was expensive then! With great companies, sometimes you just have to hold your nose and jump in – they are rarely cheap! If it wasn’t already such a large part of my portfolio, Slack Investor would buy more CSL if I could get it below $300. The price chart below is reassuring.
(GOOGL – 2022 ROE 18%, 2022 PE 24). Alphabet is listed on the US-based NASDAQ exchange and needs an International Broker to invest directly (Commsec will set you up for a cost of 0.31% for trades above USD $10,000). For a growth company, Alphabet is not outrageously expensive with a forecast Price to Earnings Ratio of 24.
One of the first charts I look at before buying a stock is how its income has evolved – Thank you Market Screener. The GOOGL income chart below is typical of how I like to see them. A steady track record of 3 years growth of sales/income, and then a plan to grow income over the next 3 years.
Income and Forecast Income for Alphabet (GOOGL) – from marketscreener.com
A common theme amongst companies that I am reluctant to sell is their willingness to invest in new projects that might feed back into the earnings of the company. Alphabet spent a staggering US$ 16.2 Billion on research and development – 14.6 % of its revenue in 2018
BetaShares NASDAQ 100 ETF – (NDQ)
(NASDAQ Index – Current ROE 14%, Current PE 23) – Australian exposure to this index comes at a cost (MER of 0.48%) through the NDQ Betashares ETF, but Slack Investor thinks this is well worth it – my costs in owning GOOGL directly are around 0.43%. This ETF is Slack Investors favourite way to own International Tech stocks. With NDQ, you get exposure to 100 of the world’s best tech companies. The NASDAQ Index is a collection of growing household tech names e.g. Apple 13.9%, Microsoft 11.2%, Amazon 10.9%, Alphabet 7.2%, Facebook 4.5%. With a forecast PE of around 23, it still looks reasonably priced if tech world keeps growing.
August 2020 – End of Month Update
Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. Rises all round for Slack Investor followed overseas markets this month ( ASX 200 +2.2%; FTSE 100 +1.1%) In Crazy Brave USA, the S&P 500 had a monthly rise of an astonishing 7.0%.
At the end of August, the US S&P 500 had a 12-month trailing PE Ratioof 30.09 . The mean and median values are 15.81 and 14.83.
Not that I think Slack Investor is worth quoting – but I searched high and low for a quote that expressed the Slack aim. The great Warren Buffet got closest to the sentiment with “You only have to do a very few things right in your life so long as you don’t do too many things wrong.” – but I used this quote last year!
It is good for me to have a yearly display of my failures. It reminds me of the bumbling path of Slack Investor in the pursuit of financial independence. As for the nuggets, just get the foundations right … and luck might intervene.
“You can never be a first class human being, until you have learnt to have some regard for human frailty.”
The percentage yearly returns quoted in this post include costs (brokerage) but are before tax. This raw figure can then be compared with other investment returns.
Slack Investor Stinkers – FY 2020
From Pixabay
The Slack Investor Portfolio comprises of (mostly) high Return on Equity (ROE>15%) and high Price to Earnings (PE) ratio stocks. Historically, these companies are quite volatile as they are priced to account for future growth. If there is an earnings revision … or a change that would affect future earnings, then the price of the share usually plummets. Slack investor accepts that stinkers are just part of life when dealing with growth stocks.
Slack Investor has a look at his stocks on a chart (Thanks Incredible Charts!) every weekend – and, I eventually get the message if a stock price is moving lower and take the exit.
Rhipe (RHP) -22%
After being a star performer last year … this software technology company took a dive in share price this time last year. Slack investor bailed out in February 2020 – but not before taking a few licks.
Treasury Wine Estate (TWE) -13%
In Wine is Truth .. and this became evident at the start of this year as the global wine oversupply made it difficult for Treasury to raise prices. Their attempts to break into the US market were floundering and the stock price took a tumble. Slack investor “cleared the decks” in February 2020.
Centuria Industrial REIT (CIP) -11%
Centuria invests in industrial properties and was a victim of my COVID-19 portfolio trim. I sold out in April 2020 on my fears that the virus would affect tenancies. It seems that I took flight a little early as the stock price has rebounded 17% since I sold – Ah well … that’s investing!
Costa Group (CGC) -11%
Costa is agricultural company that grows and distributes mushrooms, berries, tomatoes, citrus, avocados and heaps more. My involvement with this company unfortunately coincided with a 2-year price slide due to a series of farming misfortunes. I parted ways with Costa in October 2019. Slack Investor held this stock for far too long. However, owning this stock taught me a lesson – avoid business that are “price takers” – where the cost of goods is set by seasonal factors or competitors. The best businesses have an exclusive product that people want and there are barriers to entry for other competitors.
Slack Investor Gold Nuggets – FY 2020
The other side of investing in companies that have a high Return on Equity, and with a track record of increasing earnings, is that you can sometimes expose yourself to some pleasant surprises. The Return on Equity (ROE) and forward Price Earnings (PE) ratio values quoted below are “forward looking” and are analyst predictions for the year 2022. They were extracted from the excellent Market Screener site. These ratios are just predictions, but Slack Investor finds them very useful.
Appen (APX) +58%
APX (2022 ROE 19%, 2022 PE 32) remains a company that I don’t really understand but after taking profits and selling last year, I bought back in during November 2019 after a price fall and then a breakout from a “falling wedge”. Another excellent year for this machine learning and artificial intelligence company – Ignorance can be bliss!
Commonwealth Serum Laboratory (CSL) +31%
CSL (2022 ROE 31%, 2022 PE 32) is now the largest company on the ASX. Their blood products and expertise in gene therapy and vaccinations are used worldwide and there are projected increasing sales. Driving this fabulous company is a commitment to innovation. Spending on Research and Development is in the target range of 10 to 11 per cent of turnover – in an environment where a typical manufacturer will spend 2%. It is no coincidence that this company is doing well.
Alphabet (GOOGL) +30%
The Alphabet list of products is large … and getting larger. Everyday I use Google, GoogleMaps, gmail, android devices and YouTube. Alphabet (GOOGL – 2022 ROE 19%, 2022 PE 32) has just announced a quarterly rise in profits of 22% as it moves deeper into peoples lives. Alphabet and the other FAANG Stocks have been acting a bit like pirates in the multinational tax world. There are some regulatory risks on the horizon though. Nations are rightfully demanding a share of these tech giants revenue as taxation. There is also a bit of “pushback” by governments and media companies who want a fair share of revenue generated by their content. However, on the plus side, profits should continue to grow as advertisers are spending more to reach an expanding number of customers that are engrossed with their smartphones and YouTube.
A2 Milk (A2M) +26%
A2M (2022 ROE 28%, 2022 PE 29) sells A2 protein type branded milk, infant formula and other related products to the world. The actual benefits of the A2 only protein have been indicated in small studies but longer-term studies with larger sample sizes are needed. However, in the mean time, sales are increasing and the share price is still going north.
Honourable mentions for Slack Investor Portfolio stocks BetaShares NASDAQ Index NDQ, Integral Diagnostics IDX and BetaSharesRBTZ that increased more than15% in this financial year.
Slack Investor Total SMSF performance – FY 2020 and July 2020 end of Month Update
A tough financial year for shares through the COVID-19 financial crisis. Chant West reports the median of “growth” super funds struggled to a small loss of 0.5%. The FY 2020 Slack Investor preliminary total SMSF performance looks like coming in around 9%. The 5-yr performance is a more useful benchmark to me. At the end of FY 2020, the Slack Portfolio has a compounding annual 5-yr return of over 19%.
My wise mother used to say to me that “Self praise is no recommendation” So Slack Investor will meekly slink back to the couch and get prepared for what might be a tough time ahead in the share market. The full FY 2020 results and benchmarks will be expanded on next post.
Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. A mixed bag for Slack Investor followed overseas markets this month ( ASX 200 +0.5%; FTSE100 -4.4%; S&P500 +5.5%).
The US S&P 500 has shown more resistance to gravity than the Trump hairstyle – but all parties must end some time. As the S&P 500 has moved more than 20% higher than its stop loss, I have adjusted the stop loss to 2965 from 2721.
Cripes … it seems that even cyber criminals with circuit board faces wear hoodies!
Slack Investor has had minor issues with PC viral infections over the years – these types of virus seem very benign in current circumstances. I also had a distant brush with a more organized form of cyber hacking back in 2015 with my previous employer.
“I can confirm reports that the Bureau of Meteorology suffered a significant cyber intrusion which was first discovered early last year”
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull in 2016 – the ABC News
Were the Chinese after my 30 years of sea breeze wind data? Probably not. This breach triggered an injection of government funds to try and combat cyber attacks. More recently, the current Australian government is talking about a huge $1.35 billion investment to increase Australia’s cyber security capabilities, Even smaller businesses are having to invest in cyber security as technology invades our lives.
As well as worrying about cybersecurity, the COVID-19 crisis lurches on. It is not just the retailers that are suffering, In the US, major companies such as Hertz and several US airlines have recently filed for bankruptcy due to COVID-19. At the moment, many companies are drawing down on available credit, standing down their staff, delaying projects and taking advantage of government relief programs.
It will be a delicate dance by national governments trying to support the economy with limited funds until a viable vaccine is established. When they halt these stimulus programs, each company will start burning through their cash. That’s when bankruptcy cases are likely to soar and stay elevated.
… this year (2020) will easily set a record for so-called mega bankruptcies — filings by companies with $1 billion or more in debt … the number of merely large bankruptcies — at least $100 million — to challenge the record set the year after the 2008 economic crisis.
Edward I. Altman, Professor Emeritus of Finance at New York University’s Stern School of Business – from Intelligencer
A Graph of US stocks showing valuation trend since 1998. Valuations derived from P/E ratios and comparing them to the long term mean and scaling it to 50. Companies in the US look definity over valued. Sourced from Livewiremarkets.
Slack Investor has been a big fan of some of the companies in the technology sector – as these shares are exposed to growth. This internet thing keeps increasing its grip on our lives. The recent “recovery rally” has led to stock prices being “fully” or “over valued” – particularly in the US. It is difficult to argue against this in these uncertain times as estimates for future US earnings decrease.
In an environment when many sections of the economy are in big trouble, in many ways, it might be a good time to take a bit of risk off the table and build up a little cash. However, not all tech companies are tied to the consumer economy and there will be a continuing need for individual companies and governments to make investments for the protection of their internet structures. Cyber security is now the fastest growing technology sector.
BetaShares Global Cybersecurity ETF (HACK)
HACK is a BetaShares ETF that provides exposure to the leading companies in the global cybersecurity sector. Most of these companies are based in the US (87%). HACK is currently invested in 49 companies that include well known names such as Broadcom and Cisco. There are many other companies that Slack Investor has never heard of such as Crowdstrike, Splunk and OKTA – and, I assume the fund managers know much more about the sector than I do.
Weekly chart of HACK for the past 12 months. On June 30, 2020 there was a 91c distribution which accounts for the big price drop – incrediblecharts.com
The management expense ratio is high at 0.67%. I will “suck this up” while it is performing well. Can’t argue with past yearly HACK performance – over 1-year (+19.9%) and 3-years (+20.3%). Probably not the best time to buy, but Slack Investor can’t help himself – this must be close to a recession-proof section of the economy. I dived in last month as I can’t resist a growing industry!
In honour of the upcoming International Geek Pride Day to be celebrated on 25 May.
Being a geek is cool (Just ask Bill Gates!). They have rights … the top 5 rights of a Geek are:
1. The right to be even geekier.
2. The right to not leave your house.
3. The right to not like football or any other sport.
4. The right to associate with other nerds.
5. The right to have few friends (or none at all).
During the past month. Slack Investor has certainly lived the geek lifestyle and he has reflected on the magnificent gift that geeks gave to the world – technology!
The NASDAQ (National Association of Securities Dealers Automated Quotations) is a special US based electronic stock exchange that was created in 1971 and now lists over 3500, mostly tech, companies. The top 15 companies in the NASDAQ consist of the household names below.
Name
Weight (%)
MICROSOFT CORP
12%
APPLE INC
12%
AMAZON.COM INC
10%
FACEBOOK INC
4%
ALPHABET INC
4%
ALPHABET INC
4%
INTEL CORP
3%
NETFLIX INC
2%
NVIDIA CORP
2%
PEPSICO INC
2%
CISCO SYSTEMS INC
2%
ADOBE INC
2%
PAYPAL HOLDINGS INC
2%
COMCAST CORP
2%
TESLA INC
2%
The growth of the NASDAQ composite index since 1971 – Shown on a log scale – From Macrotrends
Despite a few downturns, mostly in recessions (shaded grey columns above), being invested in technology has really delivered. Betashares, an Australian company, offers simple exposure to the top 100 companies in the NASDAQ through NDQ, their Australian listed NASDAQ ETF. Slack Investor owns some US Listed shares directly and the hassle of different currencies, maintaining a US Broking account, and filling out US taxation forms make the NDQ ETF Management Expense Ratio (MER) of 0.48% seem reasonable. Morningstar also offers a Global technology ETF TECH. Good global technology access for a 0.45% management fee.
Weekly chart of Australian listed Betashares NDQ – Incredible Charts
The use of technology to connect people and develop new businesses has been well demonstrated during the COVID-19 crisis – these tech businesses are growing. Slack Investor has a big amount of technology stocks – over 35% of his Portfolio. NDQ has grown over 50% in the 18 months since the original Slack Investor buy.
One of the things that Slack Investor has learned over the decades is that a high PE is OK, providing that there is a lot of growth involved. Stamped on the little Slack Investor brain is that technology is becoming increasingly important in our lives – this sector is definitely growing.
The NASDAQ index usually has a relatively high average PE Ratio – but as of May 13 2020 it has slipped down to a very reasonable 20.55. There is also a decent trailing dividend yield of 1.73% – the dividend is showing an increasing trend.
This is not advice, as Slack Investor has no divine guidance on what will happen in the next 12 months. – but, with a 2-3 year time frame, will Slack Investor invest more into NDQ or TECH as funds become available? You bet your geekin’ life he will!
COVID-19 (SARS-CoV-2) was first first recorded in China in December 2019. In a few short months, the world is in turmoil. There is panic in the streets and this coronavirus epidemic is likely to be an exceptionally serious global problem with many fatalities. Slack Investor couldn’t buy toilet paper last week. That’s when this problem got the attention of my small brain!
It is a good thing that governments are acting decisevely to try and stem the spread of this virus. No one really knows how this pandemic will play out. It is a fact that the world GDP will suffer – but the extent will depend on whether the pandemic is mild, moderate or severe. A good snapshot of how things are going can be found at the World Health Organisation (WHO) Dashboard which keeps a world wide tally of confirmed COVID-19 cases and tracks the drift of concern towards Europe.
Based on current knowledge, the case fatality risk for COVID-19 is higher than observed for seasonal influenza virus, which has a fatality risk of about 0.1%. Annually, seasonal influenza virus is estimated to cause up to 290,000 deaths globally.
The latest WHO data on COVID-19 have the death rate (currently over 5000) from confirmed cases at 3.7% – but this is likely to decline as testing is rolled out and the number of confirmed cases more adequately reflect the actual number of those with the virus. This is a major health problem and will impact the world economies for the immediate future – but is unlikely to have a long-term effect.
The MSCI World Index since 1970 with various world epidemics marked – Original source Charles Schwab but found in marketwatch.com
The important thing from the chart above is that even though COVID-19 is a significant challenge for the world. The world MSCI Index always recovers from viral epidemics – It just takes a bit of time.
The way things are going, Slack Investor will probably sell his remaining Index funds (US S&P500 and ASX 200) at the end of this month if they are below their stop loss level – as this is system that I am running with my Index funds.
For the individual companies that make up over 95% of the Slack Portfolio, I am not selling into a panicked market. Again, I tap into the wisdom of Warren Buffet. Rapidly falling markets are a test for every investor. Buffett says that investors should treat their stocks like a house – what matters is the 10, 20 and 30-year outlook of each company, not the latest newspaper headlines. To paraphrase Mr Buffet, If you bought a house for $500 000 and a month after someone offers you $350 000, you probably wouldn’t take it – You would have your own idea of the house value and hopefully wait until you are offered a more suitable price. Slack Investor feels the same way about his carefully selected shares in a growing companies with good prospects – the sell-off is probably over done.
In the meantime, while lamenting that I have no spare cash for the inevitable upturn. Slack Investor will be washing his hands a lot and trying to avoid close contact with those with flu-like symptoms, and trying not to touch his well-worn face.
Australian lifeguards are known to roll their Speedos up during surfboat races to give better contact between the buttocks and the wooden seat of the boat while rowing. The image is gratuitously included because “Wedgies” are just …just … funny! -Downloaded from http://westalai.blogspot.com/ – may be subject to copyright
Slack Investor introduced one of his favourite technical chart patterns in January 2019 … “The Wedgie”. I promised to look at the results in 12 months time.
Looking at charts of stock prices and trying to recognise useful patterns is known as Technical Analysis. Some investors do not have faith in in this dark science … and Slack Investor would not act on chart signal alone – the underlying company must be sound with established earnings and good prospects.
“The Wedgie” is Slack Investor’s name for a pattern more boringly known as the “breaking of a long-term downtrendline“. You have to admit … “the Wedgie” has a more of a ring to it.
The breakout from a Wedgie on a share price chart is discussed in detail in the original post and it is when the share price rises out of the wedge pattern. The top of the wedge downtrend line should be drawn for a period of at least 3 months and connect at least 2 (and preferably 3) descending high points.
This pattern has the potential to be a trend “reversal” – Lets see how it has performed over 12 months for the Slack Investor bought stocks. The first 3 are all still in the portfolio.
CSL – Commonwealth Serum Laboratory
This great company share price was consolidating a year ago but has recently boomed with a 71% gain.
In the January 2019 post, ALU, APX, CAR, CCP, FPH, SEK, and A2M were also mentioned as breaking the wedgie pattern. All of them have made very good gains since the breakout from “the wedgie”. Gains of 73%, 64%, 48%, 76%, 74%, 29% and 25%, respectively – from January 18, 2019 to February 10, 2020. Slack Investor thinks that, so far, the Wedgie is working in most cases! – but, it has no guarantee – vigilance is required.
The Wedgie does not always work, CGC – Costa Group –
Weekly Chart for CGC showing two distinct wedge patterns. The first one showed promise then the price quickly turned south after some earnings downgrade announcements. The second wedgie looks worthy of investigation – from incrediblecharts.com
CGC was not mentioned in the original post and clearly the first break of the downtrend in November 2018 lost a bit of steam due to drought and supply problems – Slack Investor was, sadly, an investor in this stock at the time – and it was a loser! This is an example of the wedgie pattern NOT working. However, for all of 2019, CGC has been in a long-term downtrend but the pattern is starting to get interesting again as the longer the downtrend line the more bullish it will be when the stock breaks above the trendline.
As always, however great the pattern may look, Slack Investor is interested in the fundamentals of this stock before he will invest. Wisetech (WTC) is also breaking its Wedgie. Using marketscreener.com, CGC has a good 2021 forecast PE and yield, but the 2021 ROE is too low (<15%). WTC has good Return on Equity (ROE) but the 2021 forecast PE is too high for me (Slack Investor likes the forecast PE to be less than 40-50) … So, despite good looking technical patterns, it is no investment from Slack Investor for these two.
SI Wedgie 2020
P/E 2021
Yield % 2021
ROE % 2021
Costa Group
CGC
17
3.3
9
Wisetech
WTC
82
0.2
21
Let’s visit CGC and WTC in 12 months for the sake of curiosity. Long live the Wedgie!
Slack Investor’s in-depth reviews of performance are done at the end of the Australian financial year (30 June) – but a brief look at how things went in calendar year 2019 is in order. It has been a great year for the share investor. Roger Montgomery reports that the Australian All Ordinaries Accumulation Index delivered a return of 24.0% in calendar 2019 – more than double long-term average annual total return. Other World Index yearly changes for 2019 (without dividends) are listed below.
Slack Investor puts a bit of time into initial stock selection. Before entry to the Slack portfolio, I comb the company universe for high Return on Equity stocks that have low debt and a proven track record of increasing dividends. Delighted to report that a couple of Australian ETF’s have recently emerged that do a similar thing, using parallel principles to the great Benjamin Graham in selecting quality stocks – automatically!
BetaShares Global Quality Leaders ETF – QLTY
QLTY provides access to the 150 highest quality global companies (ex-Australia) based on a combined ranking of four key factors – return on equity, debt-to-capital, cash flow generation ability and earnings stability.
VanEck Vectors MSCI World ex Australia Quality ETF – QUAL
QUAL has a similar objective screening process, to fill its stock register. Companies must have a high return on equity, stable annual earnings growth, and low financial leverage.
There are common elements to the top 10 holdings for each ETF. Companies like Apple, Visa, Facebook and Alphabet feature on both registers. Either of these ETF’s would be a great addition to a portfolio but Slack Investor would lean towards BetaShares QLTY because of their slightly less expensive management costs (0.35% vs 0.40%). Past results indicate there is outperformance attached to this “quality” approach.
Cumulative “Quality” index performance vs world Benchmark – net returns (30 November 1994 to 30 April 2015) – From Van Eck Whitepaper
My only criticism is that both ETF’s have quality filters that do not seem take into account how expensive the stock is. When Slack Investor researches stocks, I usually dismiss a company if the forecast earnings (+2 years) produce a PE that is over 40. With QUAL and QLTY, it is quality first, regardless of price. I am mollified slightly by the determination that, in the past,
MSCI World Quality Index traditionally has its strongest relative performance during economic downturns
Sometimes people ask me what stocks to buy – and I seldom have a good answer for them – particularly if they are just starting out on the path of buying shares and their portfolio carries the risk of just one or two stocks. These two ETF’s have given Slack Investor an easy answer.
Instant Diversification – International exposure
Access to high growth companies with a good track record of increased earnings
Rules based stock selection – no ‘active manager’ fees -this should keep expenses low ~ 0.4% … but could be lower!
The early results are not bad either with Morningstar listing one-year performance for 2019 for QUAL and QLTY at 35.8% and 34.5%, respectively.
These sort of products might just put Slack Investor out of a job!
With great thanks and acknowledgement to the insightful and talented Randy Glasbergen
KPMG have just reported that banks are starting to lose their shine and the big 4 banks in Australia have reached a “turning point”. Slack Investor would argue that, after a pretty good recovery post the GFC, Australian Banks have been in decline since early 2015. NAB is the last to confess this reporting season … They are all businesses that will find growth difficult.
With its full-year profit of $4.8 billion, down 13.6 per cent, it joined ANZ, Commonwealth and Westpac in announcing a big decline in earnings.
The ASX Bank Index since 2000. Except for the GFC 2008/9, the banks have performed well – as well as paying high dividends. Things changed in March 2015 where, despite temporary recoveries, there has been a general decline in share price. From Investing.com
Self Managed Super Funds are a great place to park your super money for the hands-on investor. But, they are not for everyone. You really need to have a real interest in investing and at least $200 000 in your super savings. According to ATO Data, at 31 December 2017, the most commonly held SMSF share investments (by investment size) are below: There are a lot of banks!
Commonwealth Bank Westpac Banking Corporation National Australia Bank Magellan Global Fund BHP Billiton Limited Platinum International Fund ANZ Limited Telstra Corporation CSL Wesfarmers
Not a bad portfolio for the past 10 years … but, the tide for the banks has already turned with low interest rates affecting margins, increased competition from the more nimble digital banks, the Hayne Royal commission “blowback” forcing the banks to separate from their profitable wealth management businesses, and recent dividend cuts announced. A closer look at the top 5 SMSF shares with financial statistics from the excellent marketscreener.com. The 1-yr returns over the past year for each stock are lifted from marketindex.com.au .
SMSF 2017 Top 5 Shares
P/E 2020
Yield %
ROE %
1-yr Ret %
Commonwealth Bank
CBA
15
5.5
13
12.4
Westpac Bank
WBC
14
5.9
11
-3.7
National Bank
NAB
12
6
12
16.7
BHP Billiton
BHP
12
5.3
22
10.9
ANZ
ANZ
12
6
12
-3.9
Average
13
5.7
14
6.5
Slack Investor can understand the lure of juicy bank dividends for SMSF funds. But, if the dividend is coming with a reducing share price due to the bank business shrinking – then this is not a good deal – and perhaps look to higher yield industrial shares or industrial/office REITs for that cherished income rather than banks.
Sing the praises for Return on Equity (ROE) and Earnings per Share (EPS) Growth
This is one of the first financial statistics that I look at when deciding on a company to buy. Return on Equity is a company’s Net Profit ÷ Average Shareholder Equity. If a company had a net worth of $10 million and made a profit of $2 million, its ROE would be 2/10 x 100 = 20%.
High ROE companies generate a lot of cash – this cash they can then use to grow their business. If they also have a good increase in their Earnings Per Share (EPS) – Slack Investor would classify them as “Growth” Companies.
CSL Earnings per Share- and projected EPS for 2022 -2024
Generally, companies with a ROE of >15% get Slack Investor’s attention but some businesses require lot of infrastructure before they can generate profit. For this reason ROE is best used to compare companies in the same industry. For contrast with the 2017 SMSF, let’s have a look at Slack Investor’s Top 5 stocks from the Portfolio page (This is not advice!). Data gathered from marketscreener.com and marketindex.com.au .
Slack Investor Top 5 Shares
P/E 2020
Yield %
ROE %
1-yr Ret %
CSL Ltd
CSL
38
1.2
35
38.3
Altium Ltd
ALU
46
1.6
31
44.9
Cochlear Ltd
COH
41
1.7
38
26
Macquarie Group Ltd
MQG
16
4.4
16
11.5
REA Group Ltd
REA
40
1.3
35
27.9
Average
36
2.0
31
29.7
The average ROE for the Slack Portfolio is much higher than for the 2017 SMSF top 5 (31% vs 14%) . They also all have a projected increasing Earnings per Share (EPS) – and this indicates the Slack preference for growth companies.
However, with growth comes volatility and the Slack Investor top 5 would not suit those who rely on their investments for income. The Slack portfolio would probably suit an investor with a longer term view and a separate income. If you are still working and want to grow your wealth through shares … then the ROE should be one of your guiding lights for company selection.
On the theme of a trim … who doesn’t like a bit of topiary. My portfolio has had a little haircut in the past 3 months as I have been thinking about the potential of a recession and the effect it might have on my investments. Lacking the skills of Nostradamus, Slack Investor has chosen the “middle path” for his individual stocks i.e . Between doing nothing and “selling everything”, I have chosen to fiddle with about 20% of the portfolio. Some of the things I have bought are expanded on below, in order of investment commitment. This is not advice, just a random walk through stock selection. To make room for the new purchases I sold a few high PE stocks and a few underperformers. The sold stocks include APX, CGC, PMC, AGL and CTD.
Alphabet -Google ( GOOGL)
This is new ground for Slack Investor as GOOGL is US based company and the investment has the additional complexity that I have to use an international broker (Saxo) to purchase shares on the NASDAQ exchange. But, I feel the extra effort is worth it as I can’t think of a better company to ride with through the next 10 years.
Google search has 92% global market share. Chrome is the world’s most widely used web browser. Android is the world’s most popular mobile operating system with 2 billion-plus active users. YouTube is watched for more than 1 billion hours a day. Alphabet has about US$100 billion in cash which, for a sense of scope, is larger than the combined market values of Telstra, Woolworths, and Macquarie.
I use Google products countless times a day and with a Return on Equity of 21 % and a reasonable Price Earnings ratio (for the growth tech sector!) of 24. I would like to own more of this and will seek to add to my position over time. The international shares thing is a bit of a hassle and has some extra expenses. A far easier, way to get a slice of Google (and other great tech growth companies) is by buying the Australian-listed NASDAQ ETF (NDQ). Alphabet represents 8.6% of the NASDAQ Index.
Vanguard Australian Fixed Interest ETF (VAF)
For ETF’s, I naturally lean towards Vanguard due to their relatively low fees and a commitment to keep them low (Thanks Jack Bogle!) I bought this ETF to try and derisk my shares portfolio by getting some exposure to the Australian Government Bond and Fixed Interest Market. I have also bought some Vanguard Emerging Markets ETF (VGE) and Vanguard Global Infrastructure (VBLD).
Centuria Industrial REIT (CIP)
The lure of property rentals during tough times and a bit of exposure to Industrial Real Estate has brought me to this area. I was tossing up buying Goodman (GMG) or Centuria. Both have a similar Weighted Average Lease Expiry (WALE) and occupancy rate. GMG has a relatively high 2020 PE of 26.1 compared with a CIP 2020 PE of 14.8. CIP also has a more fruity yield of 5.7%. Case Closed.
United Overseas Australia (UOS)
A Malaysian real estate developer … Steady on, this sounds a bit wacky! – UOS is a bit of a speculator for Slack Investor. Real estate is a place where I am underdone and I am alway convinced by good arguments. A respected investor (by me), Tony Hansen, from EGP Capital has this stock as his highest portfolio allocation. UOS has a solid cash position, a decent yield and the discount to net worth got me over the line. What is life without a little bit of risk!
Fitcats – Get your super runnin’
With apologies to the legendary Steppenwolf, Slack Investor has the news from Chris Brycki (the tireless CEO of Stockspot and author of the Fatcat/Fitcat report). He has produced his yearly assessment of the best super funds (Fit Cats) and the worst (Fat Cats). Fat Cat Super Funds on average charge 2% a year in fees, while, in comparison Fit Cat Super Funds charge less than 1% a year in fees.
“One of our golden rules of superannuation is; the less you pay, the more you get. Always pay less than 1% p.a. in fees so your super isn’t eroded by high fees. I know 1% doesn’t sound like a lot, but for the Aussies stuck in these Fat Cat Funds they’ll be worse off by $200,000 or more compared to their friends who are in a low-fee fund,”
So, if you haven’t already done so … get financially fit, grab yourself an account number in one of these top performers. Most will allow new customers. Then continue to get some Fit Cat action by asking your employer to make any future contributions to your new account. Then rollover your super to the new fund and your sweet.
