Portfolio Management | Slack Investor

Hits and Misses … and November 2020 – End of Month Update

Back in happier times, September 2019, the Mayfair 101 business founder, James Mawhinney. His skills are described by Mayfair as “generating substantial value for shareholders”. Sadly for investors, the signature Mayfair 101 investment in Dunk Island has now fallen through due to Mayfair being “unable to meet their obligations”– Original image from the Courier Mail

Mayfair 101 bites the dust

It may take some years, but this Mayfair 101 thing … it’s not going to end well for the punters!
Slack Investor – November 2019

It has now been 12 months since Slack Investor warned about investing in the highly promoted glitzy “alternative to term deposits” Mayfair 101. I urged any investors to get their money out while they could. Things have now gone pear-shaped for participants in Mr Mawhinney’s vehicles – as well as the Dunk Island resort repossession, one of Mayfair 101’s three main investment products, IPO wealth, has had its investor’s money frozen.

I take no solace in being right as many small and large investors have since been hurt by the appointment of receivers to Mayfair 101’s $86 million IPO Wealth fund. ASIC alleges that the money raised by the Mayfair group was not fully secured, and investors may be unable to recover the full amount of their principal investment.

According to The Guardian, Mayfair 101 had received more than $67.5m from investors but, by 1 July, had just $2,765 in the bank and that investor’s money was “used to fund a loan that was not adequately secured”. They were unable to come up with the $32m that would have completed the purchase of Dunk Island. ASIC feared the fundraising was “akin to arrangements colloquially referred to as a ‘Ponzi scheme’.”

A year ago there were full page ads in the AFR, full of glowing self praise as the “new face of investment” In investing, it pays to be wary of big announcements, “management speak” and things that sound too good to be true … trust the nostrils!

“[Mayfair Platinum CEO, James Mawhinney, is] an experienced business builder who is focused on creating win-win outcomes for investors, clients, suppliers and staff
A quote from Mayfair (sourced from crikey.com )from the golden days of Mayfair 101 … but perhaps win-lose might be more appropriate. I am hoping that investors can get a decent portion of their capital returned.

Bitcoin again

Bitcoin chart (USD) since 2014 – From Coindesk

This would be objectively classified as a miss by Slack Investor – the bitcoin price is now higher than when I initially talked about bitcoin as a “bubble” at around $7000 USD. Despite the rocketing bitcoin price, the Slack Investor view has not changed and it is not the type of investment that appeals to me. Bitcoin is a speculative investment that depends entirely on what the next buyer is willing to pay for it.

Bitcoin is the dominant cryptocurrency (Etherium, Ripple, Litecoin, etc) that uses the potentially useful blockchain technology to monitor transactions. The Guardian points out that bitcoin is not a true currency as it not widely accepted as legal tender, the transaction costs are not small (it costs between 3 and 6 USD per transaction) and, it does not have a relatively stable value that would help vendors in setting prices. Central banks and Facebook have outlined plans for their own digital currencies that would be in competition with existing cryptocurrencies.

There is also a high energy cost in the “mining” of bitcoin. The current “Proof of Work” algorithm requires 215 kw/h of electricity to produce each bitcoin – the equivalent of an average US home energy consumption for a week.

Slack Investor holds no regrets about not buying in. He will stick with investing in growing real companies that produce tangible things that people want. An investment should be something that has a real monetary or social value, regardless of whether someone wants to buy it from you.

My assessment in 2017 that bitcoin is a casino investment still holds. Well done to anyone that has made money with bitcoin. In the same way that I will always congratulate someone who has made money on a bizarre sports bet – or who has won money on 5 reds in a row in roulette table – but, it is not investing, it is not for me.

November 2020 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100.

During a time when world COVID-19 related deaths are 8866 per day and there are 54.9m cases confirmed globally – the stock markets have gone a little crazy . It is a good demonstration of how difficult it is to predict short-term stock market movement. Slack Investor followed markets all grew by more than 10% this month. For November 2020, the Australian ASX 200 rose 10.0%, the S&P 500 up 10.8%, and the FTSE 100 up 12.4%.

All it took was a US election and some good vaccine news.

“Most Americans who want to be vaccinated will be able to do so by April or May next year”
Dr. Anthony Fauci – from CNN

On the FTSE 100 Index a new “Higher Low” was established and this gave me the opportunity to move up my monthly stop loss to 5525 – see Monthly UK Index chart.

The US economy entered a recession in February 2020 and still in uncertain times, Slack Investor has his stop losses live for all Index funds.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

Know when to Fold’em … and October 2020 – End of Month Update

“He said, “If you’re gonna play the game, boy
You gotta learn to play it right …
You’ve got to know when to hold ’em
Know when to fold ’em
Know when to walk away
And know when to run
Excerpt from “The Gambler” written by Don Schlitz and recorded by Kenny Rogers.

Kenny makes this sound easy, but selling shares is tricky and Slack Investor does not always get this decision right – and I’m OK with that. The Slack Investor art is just to attempt to get things “mostly right”. There are some stocks that I will hold for the long run, and their weekly and monthly charts are not of a big concern to me. However, about half of my portfolio is on a weekly or monthly watch – I review the Incredible Charts output for each of these stocks on the weekend or at the end of the month.

I pay particular attention when the stock price falls below my stop loss on the monthly chart. In hindsight, I should have been more alert back in August. A2M is a good company with a unique product and has shown excellent growth in the last 5 years. However, earnings season is always a bit volatile for the growth sector.

The FY20 results showed a record profit but there were some question marks about FY21. The real catalyst for a downward price move was the later release of an acquisition and that members of the board and senior executive team had sold over 1.8 million shares. Selling by insiders is not always bad, as the executives might just be diversifying their portfolios – However, in this case, the market took a dim view. Overall, the A2 Milk Company Ltd (ASX: A2M) share price has slumped more than 15% since the release of its FY21 outlook.

Monthly Price chart of The A2 Milk Company (A2M) showing a buy in at $11.66 in January 2019 and a sell at $15.40 at the end of September 2020. I took the opportunities to gradually creep up my stop loss from the original value of $11.11 to $17.08 – From incrediblecharts.com

I am not known for my fast work and have tended to take the couch rather than make a decision in the past. However, in the spirit of incremental improvement, I didn’t wait till the end of the month and pounced on the sell button on the day that the A2M fell more than 10%, 28th September 2020.

*Daily Price chart of The A2 Milk Company (A2M)*. Slack investor sold on the day news leaked out about insider selling on September 28 *– From* incrediblecharts.com

I am not put off A2M forever. The end of month share price was $13.67. There is now a reasonable case for re-investing given the growth pathway beyond 2021 and the Market Screener , relatively low, 2023 predicted PE of 19. There has now been a downward trend of 3 months and Slack Investor’s favourite pattern has started to emerge … “The Wedgie”. If there is a break above “the Wedgie”, I will reinvest and hope the share price resumes an uptrend.

” … the secret to survivin’
is knowing what to throw away,
and knowing what to keep …”
Further … from The Gambler

Ooooh Kenny … the secret to investing is simple to describe, but harder to do … but you knew how to tell a good story!

October 2020 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. However, the US and UK charts are hovering close to their monthly stop losses.

The state of recent COVID-19 surges in Europe and the US seems to be worrying punters and monthly falls were recorded in these markets (S&P 500 -2.8%; FTSE 100 -4.9%). In Australia, the governments are handling the response to the virus in a constructive fashion and the ASX 200 rose 1.9%.

On the ASX 200 Index monthly chart, a new “Higher Low” was established and this gave me the opportunity to move up my monthly stop loss to 5763.

The US economy entered a recession in February 2020 and Slack Investor has his stop losses live for all Index funds.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

Stocks for the “Long Run” and August 2020 – End of Month Update

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is virgin-ground.jpg

… It’s going to rain and it’s going to blow
But it’ll be all right, it’ll be all right, it’ll be all right in the long run …
Excerpt from the “Long Run” lyrics by Redgum (John Schuman) released in 1980.

Slack Investor looks at the shares that he owns occasionally and has a bit of a tinker. Earlier this year I had a portfolio review that saw a dumping of managed funds and high fee ETF’s. I also made an attempt to exit shares that I thought might be severely affected by gloomy economic times. However, sometimes it is good to lift the sights to the horizon and forget about the short term pricing of the market.

“Over the 210 years I have examined stock returns, the real return on a broadly diversified portfolio of stocks has averaged 6.6 percent per year.”
Jeremy J. Siegel, Stocks for the Long Run

Although the last financial year was a bit bleak for the median of super growth funds (-0.5%), Slack Investor has been around long enough to know that the gloomy times are periodic, and that, “In the Long Run” shares are a very good investment – as can be seen on the 28-year performance chart below.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 2020GrothFundsChart-4-MR-Jul20.png — *The Performance of the median Australian Superannuation Growth Fund over the past 28 years. A “Growth Fund” is defined to have between 60 – 80% of Growth Assets – From* Chant West

During my portfolio review I realised that over half my portfolio is in several companies that I would never sell – unless circumstances changed greatly! These companies usually have great management, a plan for growth, and an established track record in increasing Earnings per Share (EPS). Prices may go up and down, but great companies ride though all this and figure out a way to keep growing.

Coles (COL)

COL (2022 ROE 36%, 2022 PE 23) – With around 30% of all supermarket sales, Coles is one of the lucky retailers classified as essential and is getting a boost from COVID-19. This boost wont last forever, and, I cant see any big growth ahead. But, I can’t see myself selling this company as I visit it twice a week to “kick the tyres” and they are doing a good job. There is also the perverse satisfaction of knowing that if I am waiting at the checkout for a time … that it must be good for the bottom line!

Altium (ALU)

ALU (2022 ROE 32%, 2022 PE 56). The PE ratio of Altium has it priced for big future growth and it would be a stretch to buy it now. But this printed circuit board designer is a company for the times and it has a well defined, and so far achievable, global growth strategy.

Although relatively expensive (Forecast PE 56), Altium has no debt, a decent cash balance and keeps growing its profit margin and market share. In 2019, Altium spend 14% of its revenue on Research and Development – This is a commitment to growth in a changing industry.

Commonwealth Serum Laboratory (CSL)

CSL (2022 ROE 29%, 2022 PE 38) – Slack investor first bought into this company 10 years ago at around $30 and I have had the good fortune to add to my holding (at much higher prices!) along the way. CSL is expensive at a forecast PE of 38, but I can remember at my initial purchase in 2010, I thought it was expensive then! With great companies, sometimes you just have to hold your nose and jump in – they are rarely cheap! If it wasn’t already such a large part of my portfolio, Slack Investor would buy more CSL if I could get it below $300. The price chart below is reassuring.

Weekly chart of CSL over 5 years – From Incredible charts.com

Alphabet – (GOOGL)

(GOOGL – 2022 ROE 18%, 2022 PE 24). Alphabet is listed on the US-based NASDAQ exchange and needs an International Broker to invest directly (Commsec will set you up for a cost of 0.31% for trades above USD $10,000). For a growth company, Alphabet is not outrageously expensive with a forecast Price to Earnings Ratio of 24.

One of the first charts I look at before buying a stock is how its income has evolved – Thank you Market Screener. The GOOGL income chart below is typical of how I like to see them. A steady track record of 3 years growth of sales/income, and then a plan to grow income over the next 3 years.

Income and Forecast Income for Alphabet (GOOGL) – from marketscreener.com

A common theme amongst companies that I am reluctant to sell is their willingness to invest in new projects that might feed back into the earnings of the company. Alphabet spent a staggering US$ 16.2 Billion on research and development – 14.6 % of its revenue in 2018

BetaShares NASDAQ 100 ETF – (NDQ)

(NASDAQ Index – Current ROE 14%, Current PE 23) – Australian exposure to this index comes at a cost (MER of 0.48%) through the NDQ Betashares ETF, but Slack Investor thinks this is well worth it – my costs in owning GOOGL directly are around 0.43%. This ETF is Slack Investors favourite way to own International Tech stocks. With NDQ, you get exposure to 100 of the world’s best tech companies. The NASDAQ Index is a collection of growing household tech names e.g. Apple 13.9%, Microsoft 11.2%, Amazon 10.9%, Alphabet 7.2%, Facebook 4.5%. With a forecast PE of around 23, it still looks reasonably priced if tech world keeps growing.

August 2020 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. Rises all round for Slack Investor followed overseas markets this month ( ASX 200 +2.2%; FTSE 100 +1.1%) In Crazy Brave USA, the S&P 500 had a monthly rise of an astonishing 7.0%.

At the end of August, the US S&P 500 had a 12-month trailing PE Ratio of 30.09 . The mean and median values are 15.81 and 14.83.

In the real world, the US economy entered a recession in February 2020 and Slack Investor has his stop losses live for all Index funds.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

FY2020 Nuggets and Stinkers and July 2020 – End of Month Update

“Just get things mostly right“
Slack Investor 2020 –

Not that I think Slack Investor is worth quoting – but I searched high and low for a quote that expressed the Slack aim. The great Warren Buffet got closest to the sentiment with “You only have to do a very few things right in your life so long as you don’t do too many things wrong.” – but I used this quote last year!

It is good for me to have a yearly display of my failures. It reminds me of the bumbling path of Slack Investor in the pursuit of financial independence. As for the nuggets, just get the foundations right … and luck might intervene.

“You can never be a first class human being, until you have learnt to have some regard for human frailty.”
Abhijit Naskar, Conscience over Nonsense

The percentage yearly returns quoted in this post include costs (brokerage) but are before tax. This raw figure can then be compared with other investment returns.

Slack Investor Stinkers – FY 2020

The Slack Investor Portfolio comprises of (mostly) high Return on Equity (ROE>15%) and high Price to Earnings (PE) ratio stocks. Historically, these companies are quite volatile as they are priced to account for future growth. If there is an earnings revision … or a change that would affect future earnings, then the price of the share usually plummets. Slack investor accepts that stinkers are just part of life when dealing with growth stocks.

Slack Investor has a look at his stocks on a chart (Thanks Incredible Charts!) every weekend – and, I eventually get the message if a stock price is moving lower and take the exit.

Rhipe (RHP) -22%

After being a star performer last year … this software technology company took a dive in share price this time last year. Slack investor bailed out in February 2020 – but not before taking a few licks.

Treasury Wine Estate (TWE) -13%

In Wine is Truth .. and this became evident at the start of this year as the global wine oversupply made it difficult for Treasury to raise prices. Their attempts to break into the US market were floundering and the stock price took a tumble. Slack investor “cleared the decks” in February 2020.

Centuria Industrial REIT (CIP) -11%

Centuria invests in industrial properties and was a victim of my COVID-19 portfolio trim. I sold out in April 2020 on my fears that the virus would affect tenancies. It seems that I took flight a little early as the stock price has rebounded 17% since I sold – Ah well … that’s investing!

Costa Group (CGC) -11%

Costa is agricultural company that grows and distributes mushrooms, berries, tomatoes, citrus, avocados and heaps more. My involvement with this company unfortunately coincided with a 2-year price slide due to a series of farming misfortunes. I parted ways with Costa in October 2019. Slack Investor held this stock for far too long. However, owning this stock taught me a lesson – avoid business that are “price takers” – where the cost of goods is set by seasonal factors or competitors. The best businesses have an exclusive product that people want and there are barriers to entry for other competitors.

Slack Investor Gold Nuggets – FY 2020

The other side of investing in companies that have a high Return on Equity, and with a track record of increasing earnings, is that you can sometimes expose yourself to some pleasant surprises. The Return on Equity (ROE) and forward Price Earnings (PE) ratio values quoted below are “forward looking” and are analyst predictions for the year 2022. They were extracted from the excellent Market Screener site. These ratios are just predictions, but Slack Investor finds them very useful.

Appen (APX) +58%

APX (2022 ROE 19%, 2022 PE 32) remains a company that I don’t really understand but after taking profits and selling last year, I bought back in during November 2019 after a price fall and then a breakout from a “falling wedge”. Another excellent year for this machine learning and artificial intelligence company – Ignorance can be bliss!

Commonwealth Serum Laboratory (CSL) +31%

CSL (2022 ROE 31%, 2022 PE 32) is now the largest company on the ASX. Their blood products and expertise in gene therapy and vaccinations are used worldwide and there are projected increasing sales. Driving this fabulous company is a commitment to innovation. Spending on Research and Development is in the target range of 10 to 11 per cent of turnover – in an environment where a typical manufacturer will spend 2%. It is no coincidence that this company is doing well.

Alphabet (GOOGL) +30%

The Alphabet list of products is large … and getting larger. Everyday I use Google, GoogleMaps, gmail, android devices and YouTube. Alphabet (GOOGL – 2022 ROE 19%, 2022 PE 32) has just announced a quarterly rise in profits of 22% as it moves deeper into peoples lives. Alphabet and the other FAANG Stocks have been acting a bit like pirates in the multinational tax world. There are some regulatory risks on the horizon though. Nations are rightfully demanding a share of these tech giants revenue as taxation. There is also a bit of “pushback” by governments and media companies who want a fair share of revenue generated by their content. However, on the plus side, profits should continue to grow as advertisers are spending more to reach an expanding number of customers that are engrossed with their smartphones and YouTube.

A2 Milk (A2M) +26%

A2M (2022 ROE 28%, 2022 PE 29) sells A2 protein type branded milk, infant formula and other related products to the world. The actual benefits of the A2 only protein have been indicated in small studies but longer-term studies with larger sample sizes are needed. However, in the mean time, sales are increasing and the share price is still going north.

Honourable mentions for Slack Investor Portfolio stocks BetaShares NASDAQ Index NDQ, Integral Diagnostics IDX and BetaShares RBTZ that increased more than 15% in this financial year.

Slack Investor Total SMSF performance – FY 2020 and July 2020 end of Month Update

A tough financial year for shares through the COVID-19 financial crisis. Chant West reports the median of “growth” super funds struggled to a small loss of 0.5%. The FY 2020 Slack Investor preliminary total SMSF performance looks like coming in around 9%. The 5-yr performance is a more useful benchmark to me. At the end of FY 2020, the Slack Portfolio has a compounding annual 5-yr return of over 19%.

My wise mother used to say to me that “Self praise is no recommendation” So Slack Investor will meekly slink back to the couch and get prepared for what might be a tough time ahead in the share market. The full FY 2020 results and benchmarks will be expanded on next post.

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. A mixed bag for Slack Investor followed overseas markets this month ( ASX 200 +0.5%; FTSE100 -4.4%; S&P500 +5.5%).

The US S&P 500 has shown more resistance to gravity than the Trump hairstyle – but all parties must end some time. As the S&P 500 has moved more than 20% higher than its stop loss, I have adjusted the stop loss to 2965 from 2721.

The US economy entered a recession in February 2020 and Slack Investor has his stop losses live for all Index funds.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

Is Market Timing Just Too Hard?

Slack Investor has not too many attributes … but one of his few features is self-awareness and the constant need to review techniques on the way to financial independence.

I have been trying to run a timing strategy with my index funds since 2004. With some success, but I would only give a “try harder” sticker to the results.

The average yearly gain for the Slack Monthly “market timing” method over the alternate strategy of “buy and hold” (leaving funds in the ASX Index, UK Index, and the US Index), is respectively is 2.7%, 2.3% and 0.3% (At March 2020). Check out the charts, trades and the gains at the page links for each index.

Although these figures show outperformance for the Slack “market timing” method. These gains might have been outweighed by share dividends if I had held the shares instead of trading out to cash. At the moment cash returns are very low (0.5 – 1.5%) and, at the current average ASX 200 yield of 5.2%, shares make a lot of sense – But being in stocks is not for the faint-hearted.

The bear market of March of 2020 — Chart showing the historical number of days to reach a Dow Jones market fall of 30% – From a Beth Kindig article in Forbes

2020 has been the financial equivalent of the “Battered Sav” with wild swings in the stock market – and the fastest fall in stock market prices in history. The ASX fell 20.5% in 14 days to enter “Bear Market” territory on March 11. It was down 30% from its peak by March 16. It is the speed of the market falls that is making Slack Investor starting to question his monthly timing strategy. For the US Dow Jones index, the rapid fall of 30% in just 18 days during March 2020 has set new records.

Things are getting freaky!

A visualization of the daily moves for the US Market 2010-2019 shows that usually most daily movements are less than 1% either way – This is Slack Investors comfort zone. But, occasionally, the market moves much more in a day. I think these large moves are getting much more common with the increased prominence of high frequency trading.

A great visualization from 2019 showing the daily percentage movements of the US stock market since 2009. **Most** of the daily moves are between -1% band +1% – but higher fluctuations do occur. – from www.chartr.co

Compare the size of daily movements on the US market in January 2020 with March 2020 – where most days had changes more than 3%.

A comparison of daily percentage change on the US Dow Jones Index in January 2020 with March 2020. From Bloomberg ofdollarsand data.com

Large share brokers and investment firms use trading systems that automatically buy into rising markets and sell into falling markets. These trades are executed by computers that use a defined set of instructions known as an algorithm to place a trade. If the market is moving up or down then these trading systems inflate the movements of the market as they try to get in or out of a trade. These computer trades make it hard for individual investors as their trades happen in microseconds. Algorithmic trading is growing rapidly at 11% per year.

“fundamental discretionary traders” accounted for only 10 percent of stock trading volume
JP Morgan quote from 2017

That means that we individual traders are up against the machines for 9 out of every 10 trades.

“Investors may have to get used to big, sudden moves in the stock market due to fewer institutions pushing equities to attractive valuations while hedge funds reach unprecedented levels of employing computerized momentum-based strategies. The result will be “faster and deeper” corrections.”
JP Morgan

I will keep my market-timing experiment for index funds (Less than 3% of my Portfolio) going for another 4 years (to make it a 20-year trial). My feeling is that by waiting till the end of the month, sometimes the market has corrected too far. However, for the bulk of my stocks, my message is to embrace the volatility of the stock market … it is what it is! The share market is still one of the most convenient way to build wealth for the investor.

Slack Investor cannot beat the computers in a momentum trade. But I do have some advantages over the the machines. I can try to judge what a business is worth. Does it have barriers to entry for other companies? Is it growing? Does it have too much debt? Find yourself some good growing companies with a track record of increasing earnings. Do a little “tweaking” to suit the times … and stay safe in these troubled times.

Coronovirus Panic

A 3d rendered illustration of a *Coronavirus –* from hopkinsmedicine.org

COVID-19 (SARS-CoV-2) was first first recorded in China in December 2019. In a few short months, the world is in turmoil. There is panic in the streets and this coronavirus epidemic is likely to be an exceptionally serious global problem with many fatalities. Slack Investor couldn’t buy toilet paper last week. That’s when this problem got the attention of my small brain!

It is a good thing that governments are acting decisevely to try and stem the spread of this virus. No one really knows how this pandemic will play out. It is a fact that the world GDP will suffer – but the extent will depend on whether the pandemic is mild, moderate or severe. A good snapshot of how things are going can be found at the World Health Organisation (WHO) Dashboard which keeps a world wide tally of confirmed COVID-19 cases and tracks the drift of concern towards Europe.

Based on current knowledge, the case fatality risk for COVID-19 is higher than observed for seasonal influenza virus, which has a fatality risk of about 0.1%. Annually, seasonal influenza virus is estimated to cause up to 290,000 deaths globally.
From Coronovirus: The Conversation

The latest WHO data on COVID-19 have the death rate (currently over 5000) from confirmed cases at 3.7% – but this is likely to decline as testing is rolled out and the number of confirmed cases more adequately reflect the actual number of those with the virus. This is a major health problem and will impact the world economies for the immediate future – but is unlikely to have a long-term effect.

The MSCI World Index since 1970 with various world epidemics marked – Original source Charles Schwab but found in marketwatch.com

The important thing from the chart above is that even though COVID-19 is a significant challenge for the world. The world MSCI Index always recovers from viral epidemics – It just takes a bit of time.

The way things are going, Slack Investor will probably sell his remaining Index funds (US S&P500 and ASX 200) at the end of this month if they are below their stop loss level – as this is system that I am running with my Index funds.

For the individual companies that make up over 95% of the Slack Portfolio, I am not selling into a panicked market. Again, I tap into the wisdom of Warren Buffet. Rapidly falling markets are a test for every investor. Buffett says that investors should treat their stocks like a house – what matters is the 10, 20 and 30-year outlook of each company, not the latest newspaper headlines. To paraphrase Mr Buffet, If you bought a house for $500 000 and a month after someone offers you $350 000, you probably wouldn’t take it – You would have your own idea of the house value and hopefully wait until you are offered a more suitable price. Slack Investor feels the same way about his carefully selected shares in a growing companies with good prospects – the sell-off is probably over done.

In the meantime, while lamenting that I have no spare cash for the inevitable upturn. Slack Investor will be washing his hands a lot and trying to avoid close contact with those with flu-like symptoms, and trying not to touch his well-worn face.

That’s not a Bull … This is a Bull!

The “Fearless Girl” statue in front of the “Charging Bull” sculpture in New York City on March 29, 2017 – **Photo by Volkan Furuncu/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images**

Slack Investor is a little bit saddened to discover that the great combination of the “fearless girl” and the “Charging Bull” in New York City was only a temporary thing. The girl was removed at the end of November 2018 due to an artistic dispute with the Bull creator Arturo Di Modica. The “Charging Bull” remains in Manhattan as a reminder of the inspiration that a bull market can bring after a market crash.

Bull Markets start when there is a 20% rise in the stock market from a previous low point. The current Bull Market has been a whopper – although there have been a few “corrections” along the way, it has now lasted over a decade and is setting new records (see chart below). The reasons behind this magnificent rise are obvious in hindsight – a mixture of the rise of technology stocks and a slow-but-steady economic growth, record corporate profits and record low interest rates.

From Schroders Australia. Chart showing the extent of the last 6 bull markets. The previous bull run, Sep 2002 to October 2009 (shown in light green) lasting 61 months *(6 1/2 years )* is eclipsed by the current bull run shown as the dark green line at 127 months (to 30 September). The use of the word “Correction” in this chart to indicate the extent of the bull market collapse is a bit confusing. Normally, a “correction” is defined as at least a 10% decline, it turns into a “Bear Market” when there is a 20 percent drop in a major U.S. index

A reminder of some of the spectacular bull markets in the past 60 years is in the table below prepared by Schroders.

The table above outlines the reasons for the end of each bull market and their is usually a trigger, prior to a market collapse.

a weakening economy, or an increase in the cost of money (higher interest rates)
“irrational exuberence” – where buyers are paying grossly inflated prices for assets
a cataclysmic world event

I can’t rule out the last one … but the US economy seems to be rolling along alright. Over the past week there have been a couple of events that bode well for the bull market to continue. In the UK, “buffoon in chief” Boris Johnson, has beaten the unelectable Labour candidate Jeremy Corbyn and now a quick Brexit looks on the cards. Stock markets generally love the removal of the uncertainty that elections present. The Trump/China trade deal seems to have also made some progress with a “phase one” deal announced. This should avert an escalation of the trade war. Low interest rates seem to around for quite some time. Stock valuations are high but not crazy high.

Slack Investor eases back onto the couch. There has to be really good reasons for Slack Investor to exit the world of high earning companies with products that the world wants.

Slack Investor is off on a bike riding adventure in Vietnam over Christmas and New Year. My usual End of Month Update will be delayed until about January 7, 2020. In the meantime, be fearless .. but also aware! The stock market moves in inevitable cycles. I am optimistic in the short term – and will enjoy my holiday. The good news is that even if the Slack view is wrong, there is always the subsequent “Higher Highs”as the market recovers. Good companies will survive any downturn and eventually return to a fair price.

The best of the fest … and a happy new year to all!

The Real October 2019 – End of Month Update … and Australia’s debt binge

Apologies to my faithful email subscribers, two days ago an unfinished version of this post was released into the ether. Slack Investor has rudimentary skills in the blogging arts and didn’t know how to recall the post. Anyway … this is what it was supposed to look like – with all information updated!

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. The Slack Investor followed overseas markets are a mixed bag with a flat ASX200 (-0.4%), and a dropping Brexit plagued FTSE100 (-2.2%). The good old US has shrugged off chants of “Lock him up” for their president and the S&P500 has had a monthly increase of 2.4%.

The Federal Reserve bank of Cleveland have the probability of a US recession within the next year at 31.0%, this has been gradually dropping since a peak at 41% two months ago. However, the current value exceeds the Slack Investor threshold of 20% and my monthly stop losses for Index funds are definitely “switched ON”

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

Household debt – the couch is getting a little uncomfortable

According to 55,000 respondents to the ABC’s Australia Talks National Survey, debt is a major problem for the nation.

On an individual level, 37 per cent are struggling to pay off their own debts, with almost half of millennials reporting that debt is a problem for them personally …
Australia Talks National Survey

Australia may not be in the top four countries for Rugby these days but we are one of the world leaders in terms of household debt. In fact, we are second only to Switzerland. I am ashamed to say Australia’s Household Debt is world class and edging towards 200% of income. With such a big chunk of our disposable income leaking to debt, it is no wonder that recent interest rate cuts are not having much effect on the economy as Australian consumers try to tighten the belts. According to the Reserve Bank, it seems that, with stagnant wages growth, most are coping with their debt by reducing their consumption.

Basically, the Australian economy is facing a long period of sluggish demand growth as our record high household debt becomes a giant millstone around the economy’s neck.
From macrobusiness.com.au

Debt can be multi-headed with mortgage, credit card, personal loans and education components. The ME Bank survey has found that there is stress in some parts of the community. If your employment income is steady, in these reducing interest rate times, the fortunate have been able to keep up existing monthly payments to reduce overall debt. This is a good strategy. Most Australian homeowners are ahead of their payments – so there is a bit of a buffer. RBA statistics show that the average borrower is almost 36 months ahead of their required payments. Though, there are worrying signs in some households.

Of households with debt, there was an increase in the
number expecting they ‘will not be able to meet their
required minimum payments on their debt’ and ‘can just
manage to make minimum payments on their debt’ in
the next 6–12 months – 43% combined compared to
38% in December 2017.
ME Bank survey

With the number of mature-age Australians carrying mortgage debt into retirement increasing rapidly, many are intending to use a portion of their super (which was supposed to fund retirement!) to try to extinguish their debts when they retire. The ME Bank Survey found that even with compulsory superannuation, only around 18% of households expect to ‘fund retirement with their own super’ (down four points in the past six months). The proportion of households expecting to ‘use both private savings and the government pension’ increased two points to 42%.

I hope that our politicians have a plan for all of this – although, as this involves a bit of thinking beyond the next election, I doubt it!

Portfolio Trim and Fitcats

From House Beautiful – May be subject to copyright

On the theme of a trim … who doesn’t like a bit of topiary. My portfolio has had a little haircut in the past 3 months as I have been thinking about the potential of a recession and the effect it might have on my investments. Lacking the skills of Nostradamus, Slack Investor has chosen the “middle path” for his individual stocks i.e . Between doing nothing and “selling everything”, I have chosen to fiddle with about 20% of the portfolio. Some of the things I have bought are expanded on below, in order of investment commitment. This is not advice, just a random walk through stock selection. To make room for the new purchases I sold a few high PE stocks and a few underperformers. The sold stocks include APX, CGC, PMC, AGL and CTD.

Alphabet -Google ( GOOGL)

This is new ground for Slack Investor as GOOGL is US based company and the investment has the additional complexity that I have to use an international broker (Saxo) to purchase shares on the NASDAQ exchange. But, I feel the extra effort is worth it as I can’t think of a better company to ride with through the next 10 years.

Google search has 92% global market share. Chrome is the world’s most widely used web browser. Android is the world’s most popular mobile operating system with 2 billion-plus active users. YouTube is watched for more than 1 billion hours a day. Alphabet has about US$100 billion in cash which, for a sense of scope, is larger than the combined market values of Telstra, Woolworths, and Macquarie.
Joe Magyer from Motley Fool on the dominance of Google’s Alphabet

I use Google products countless times a day and with a Return on Equity of 21 % and a reasonable Price Earnings ratio (for the growth tech sector!) of 24. I would like to own more of this and will seek to add to my position over time. The international shares thing is a bit of a hassle and has some extra expenses. A far easier, way to get a slice of Google (and other great tech growth companies) is by buying the Australian-listed NASDAQ ETF (NDQ). Alphabet represents 8.6% of the NASDAQ Index.

Vanguard Australian Fixed Interest ETF (VAF)

For ETF’s, I naturally lean towards Vanguard due to their relatively low fees and a commitment to keep them low (Thanks Jack Bogle!) I bought this ETF to try and derisk my shares portfolio by getting some exposure to the Australian Government Bond and Fixed Interest Market. I have also bought some Vanguard Emerging Markets ETF (VGE) and Vanguard Global Infrastructure (VBLD).

Centuria Industrial REIT (CIP)

The lure of property rentals during tough times and a bit of exposure to Industrial Real Estate has brought me to this area. I was tossing up buying Goodman (GMG) or Centuria. Both have a similar Weighted Average Lease Expiry (WALE) and occupancy rate. GMG has a relatively high 2020 PE of 26.1 compared with a CIP 2020 PE of 14.8. CIP also has a more fruity yield of 5.7%. Case Closed.

United Overseas Australia (UOS)

A Malaysian real estate developer … Steady on, this sounds a bit wacky! – UOS is a bit of a speculator for Slack Investor. Real estate is a place where I am underdone and I am alway convinced by good arguments. A respected investor (by me), Tony Hansen, from EGP Capital has this stock as his highest portfolio allocation. UOS has a solid cash position, a decent yield and the discount to net worth got me over the line. What is life without a little bit of risk!

Fitcats – Get your super runnin’

With apologies to the legendary Steppenwolf, Slack Investor has the news from Chris Brycki (the tireless CEO of Stockspot and author of the Fatcat/Fitcat report). He has produced his yearly assessment of the best super funds (Fit Cats) and the worst (Fat Cats). Fat Cat Super Funds on average charge 2% a year in fees, while, in comparison Fit Cat Super Funds charge less than 1% a year in fees.

“One of our golden rules of superannuation is; the less you pay, the more you get. Always pay less than 1% p.a. in fees so your super isn’t eroded by high fees. I know 1% doesn’t sound like a lot, but for the Aussies stuck in these Fat Cat Funds they’ll be worse off by $200,000 or more compared to their friends who are in a low-fee fund,”
Chris Brycki, Stockspot

So, if you haven’t already done so … get financially fit, grab yourself an account number in one of these top performers. Most will allow new customers. Then continue to get some Fit Cat action by asking your employer to make any future contributions to your new account. Then rollover your super to the new fund and your sweet.

September 2019 – End of Month Update … and Portfolio Trim

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. The Slack Investor followed overseas markets have had a bit of a recovery this month ( ASX 200 +1.3%; FTSE100 +2.8%; S&P500 +1.7%).

The Federal Reserve bank of Cleveland have the probability of recession within the next year at 37.9%. This exceeds the Slack Investor threshold of 20% and my monthly stop losses for Index funds are definitely “switched ON”

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index). As it is the end of the quarter, the Slack Portfolio has been updated with some readjustment of the portfolio and a solid whack of cash (5.1%).

Trim the Sails … things might get rough

Trimming the Sails by Anton Otto Fischer – from Artnet

The economists at the Cleveland Fed are rating the chances of recession as significant. This is enough for Slack Investor to do a little portfolio trimming and try to dampen the effect on my capital if a recession does happen. I am a long way from going “all the way” and converting my entire share portfolio to cash-like products – though some pundits already have. There are a few reasons for this Slack approach

I am not a very good predictor of exactly when things might go bad
The returns for the safety of cash are not good at the moment, under 2%
I have a buffer of cash income that will help me weather through any economic downturn without having to sell any stocks at downtrodden prices – Those without a cash buffer or subject to sequencing risk should take a more prudent approach than Slack Investor.
Most of my stocks are producing reasonable dividends

Sequencing risk peaks in the seven or so years before and after retirement. Investors at this stage have a higher retirement balance and typically more of it invested in shares, meaning they have more to lose if sharemarkets tumble …
From an AFR article by Tony Featherstone

Sequencing risk refers to the possibility that a retiree that depends on his savings for income may have his capital (and future income) greatly reduced by a sequence of poor returning years (such as a recession!). The retiree would be in danger of having to draw down on capital at depressed prices.

A solution for retirees to the problem of sequencing risk is to set aside 2-3 years of income in cash assets that can be used for income while the underlying assets are waiting to recover. This strategy avoids a “fire sale of assets” during a recession.

Those younger folk still in the accumulation stage can hope that any future economic downturn does not affect the employment market too much – Jobs and income are a key to survival in tough times. As far as investments are concerned, the effects of a recession are only temporary and things will recover (see chart below). Downturns are a good time to start buying if you have any spare funds.

I am happy with my minimal trim approach as I generally invest in solid money earning companies that may suffer in earnings during a recession … but wont go broke and disappear.

For stock owners, recessions and economic downturns are only bad if you have to sell your stock before the inevitable recovery. In these trying times I am often comforted by long term share charts. Please note that any downturn is always followed by a recovery- though in some cases, it may take a few years.

This Long-term S&P chart for US stocks over 120 years (On a log scale). Periodic recessions are shown as grey columns – and the ability of stock prices to recover after any major world crisis is illustrated by the general increase in stock prices as you go forward in time. -From Business Insider Australia

My Slack trimming strategy has several components

Sell some of my stocks that have increased in price and now have extremely high PE Ratios – Although some, like Altium, are hard to let go. They are “old friends” and I am very sentimental to consistent company performance over many years.
Increase the weighting of my portfolio towards cash or bonds or fixed interest.
Try to be invested in companies may not suffer too much during an economic downturn i.e. Healthcare, Essential products.
Re-focus on dividends – the dividends might reduce a little in a downturn but the income is important. Dividends have in the past been much less volatile than share prices.

I have not changed the core of my portfolio, just fiddled around with 20% of it. Some more detail on the portfolio trimming in the next post.