Nuns Know Best

In Nuns … Wisdom – The New Indian Express

Slack Investor loves a good story – whether its true or not! I like the owning of stocks and I also admire anyone who can stick to their vows. All of this seems to intersect with the story of the Coppock Curve – a technical indicator that can be mapped on stock price charts that has a great track record for showing when the market has reached the “bottom” of a cycle.

When I first started to think a bit more seriously about financial things, I was going to an evening investment class in Townsville. The class was held by a personal Slack Investor Hero, Robbie Fuller, who put on these classes for no personal gain … he just wanted to educate people about the opportunities that lay waiting in the stock market. Robbie would teach us about fundamental analysis (trying to measure the intrinsic value of a stock) and technical analysis (charts and trends). There was always a particular beauty when fundamental and technical information aligned about a company.

The class was usually a lot of fun, but I remember a time around 2011 when the markets were going through a bit of a lacklustre period and we had all had a few recent losing trades – there was just not much excitement about stocks.

Robbie came bounding in one evening after 31 July 2012 with the news that the Coppock Indicator had just turned … it was a sign that “good things will happen”- He was right – It was the start of a 3-yr period where the Australian market was mostly rising. It is much easier to trade when the “tide is coming in”.

The Coppock Curve is a “smoothed” momentum indicator developed by the economist Edwin “Sedge” Coppock and published in in a 1962 issue of Barron’s. It all started when he was commissioned by the Episcopal Church to find long-term investment opportunities for the Church fund.

According to the legend, he asked a group of nuns (or bishops!) how long it took the bereaved to “recover” from their grief. The answer was 11 to 14 months. He took the radical step of thinking that something similar might happen in stock markets after a market high and subsequent downtrend. He assumed that because markets are motivated by emotion, they might be ready to “move on” after a period of 11-14 months of “grief”.

“Crowds do too much too soon”, he wrote. “They overdo. When they get an urge to speculate, their concerted demand forces prices up at a rate far greater than the growth of the company into which they are buying. Likewise, when they liquidate holdings or make short sales during a panicky decline, they ignore basic economic facts. They overdo because they are motivated by emotion rather than reason.”

Edwin “Sedge” Coppock – from Business Insider

The Coppock Indicator has had an incredible track record in signalling the end of a “bear market”. The signal (Green Arrow) is triggered when the indicator (shown in the lower screen below) bottoms from under the zero line and then slopes upwards.

Monthly chart of the ASX 200 together with the Coppock Indicator below. The green arrows show the “bottom of the market” predictions using the Coppock Indicator. The red arrows show a possible time to sell – Click the chart for better resolution – Incrediblecharts.com

The indicator gives buy signals very rarely, only 6 times in the past 30 years for the ASX 200. But it has just given another one, signalling a buy for the ASX 200. The maths of the curve is a little complex, but it looks for the next uptrend after the market establishes a high and then goes through a 11-14-month “greiving” period.

Is Coppock’s Bollocks?

There is no perfect trading indicator. Coppock designed his indicator to try to establish a “bottom of the market” buy signal to identify long term investment opportunities. He didn’t try to use it as a selling tool. However, there is a trading strategy that uses this indicator after a BUY signal.

  • SELL when the Coppock Curve takes its first downwards trajectory OR,
  • SELL when the Coppock Curve falls below zero

I have trialled both methods and the strongest gain (p.a) results were with the first method. I have marked these sell signals on the chart above with red arrows and tabulated the gain results below.

COPPOCK CYCLEBUY DATEASX200SELL DATEASX200GAINPERIOD(yr)GAIN (p.a.)
131-May-95198128-Jan-96217110%0.6614.5%
230-May-03301029-Apr-05398332%1.9116.9%
329-May-09381730-Jun-10449318%1.0916.3%
431-Jul-12426928-Jun-13480212%0.9113.7%
531-May-16537830-Jun-1757216%1.085.9%
630-Nov-20651729-Oct-21732312%0.9113.5%
 31-Jan-237400??????

Slack Investor uses Incredible Charts to do all his charting … but their indicator screen can get complicated. To easily follow the Coppock Indicator on any stock, just use the free, but great, StockCharts and put in the same chart attributes below.

ASX 200 Chart from StockCharts – showing stock price on top and the Coppock Curve below.

Slack Investor is a great believer that market timing is difficult and that the best time to buy stocks is “all the time” – by automating your investments so that their is no decision inertia. Use dollar cost averaging.

However, looking at the chart history of this indicator … and the GAIN results in the above table, this is not advice, but now looks like a good time to get into the Australian market. Although, officially, the Coppock results are based on the end of month data. In addition, using Slack Investor’s CAPE valuation method, at the end of December 2022 the ASX 200 was “fairly valued”.

Nuns are not infallible … but mostly wise.

Vanguard Super … and November 2022 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor Hero, Jack Bogle, reflecting in casual ware – on how to keep costs down – New York Times

Jack Bogle created Vanguard as a “penny-pinching” financial powerhouse that was owned by the shareholders of its funds. Vanguard pioneered the low-cost index funds revolution.

The Vanguard Effect

The cost of financial products is important, and Slack Investor does his best to minimise any fees that come with financial transactions. It is not often I get to talk about two of my favourite finance things in one blog. Vanguard, the low-cost fund trendsetter and superannuation.

Vanguard have long been a fund manager and ETF provider that have been at the forefront of lower fees in the finance sector. The term “Vanguard Effect” has been coined to explain the phenomena that when Vanguard competes in an area, the expense ratios from their competitors tend to decrease.

Tracking the average Management Expense Ratio (MER) for US Index fundsVanguard

Vanguard Superannuation in Australia

This month, Vanguard launched into the Australian Superannuation space with a product that is transparent and amongst the lowest fees for an accumulation account. The beauty of their offering is the straight up bundling of all their fees into one simple number – 0.58% of your super balance. Of course, Slack Investor would like a lower management fee – but this is a good start.

0.35% (Administration) + 0.21% (Investment) + 0.02% (Transaction) = 0.58%

The Vanguard MySuper Lifecycle product fees depend on how much Super you have. For a $50,000 balance, the total annual fee would be $290, for a $500,000 balance, the total annual fee would be $2900. The transparency is good – Drag out your own Super annual statement and try to work out your own total fees.

Using the ATO’s comparison of MySuper products tool for a few of the popular industry funds for a $50K balance.

UniSuperAustralianSuperHostPlusHesta
5-yr Net Return6.44%7.07%7.58%6.53%
Annual Fee$316$452$619$510

Of course, fees are not the only consideration. Many of the Industry funds use some sort of stock picking, and may use private equity to enhance their performance. Vanguard Super is made up of a mixture of index funds. I do like the way that the Vanguard Lifecycle automatically adjusts your exposure to risk as you creep towards retirement. 90% growth assets till age 45, then tapering to below 50% when you reach 60. All this is done automatically by Vanguard.

The adjustment of exposure of the Vanguard Livecycle super between growth and defensive assets as you age – Vanguard

Despite this juicy offering, there is often a lack of engagement of Australian workers with their superannuation. Vanguard will probably have a bit of trouble gaining traction in Australia due to the size and popularity of their industry super competitors. This product is currently only for accumulation accounts at this stage. It is a decent starting point by Vanguard and l0ok forward to details of their pension option (coming soon!). I also am hopeful of a bit of the “Vanguard Effect” to put a bit of pressure on existing superannuation fees – which are still too high.

A note that Slack Investor is not sponsored by Vanguard (or anyone else!), but I own a few of their ETF’s and their original founder, Jack Bogle, is one of the Slack Heroes.

November 2022 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor is now back IN for Australian index shares, UK Index shares and UK Index shares.

Last month’s update describes why I feel glad that my 20-yr index timing experiment is coming to an end in 2024. The frustrating moving out … then quickly back in to my Index funds is getting tiresome. I am likely to become just a “buy and hold” investor for my small portfolio of Index funds.

This month, all markets found there were “Reasons to be Cheerful”. There were positive movements all round. The ASX 200 +6.1%, the FTSE 100 +3.3% and the S&P 500 +5.4%.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX IndexUK IndexUS Index).

Let’s Lay a Few Bricks … and Mid-Month Update

A 1999 extract from The Sydney Morning Herald showing a 13-yr old Chris Brycki – smartcompany.com.au

Slack Investor will admit to being less than young … but I am still capable of being a “Fan boy” when I see something impressive happening in the financial world.

After a series of schoolboy stock picking successes – winning the ASX’s Share Game a remarkable 3 times and, at university, he entered the JP Morgan Trading Competition, which he also won several times. The talented Chris “the Brick” Brycki, launched into a career with stockbrokers and financial houses. After a while, he started to question the long term performance of fund managers.

“… The problem is that over time, even by being right, the value added is not big enough to counteract the 1% fee that a lot of these fund managers charge.”

Chris Brycki – Stockspot – Livewire

Chris founded Stockspot in 2013 as an alternative way to invest. Their Robo Advice model offers a low-cost automated alternative to traditional fund managers and advisors. After a simple online survey to determine your investing stage and risk tolerance, an investment portfolio type is recommended to you.

Stockspot Building Blocks

Chris, founder and CEO of Stockspot, in 2020 – From smartcompany.com.au

Chris (and Stockspot) have come up with the breathtakingly simple, yet genius (Both Slack Investor and Donald Trump have a loose definition of genius), strategy. After researching thousands of ETF’s and, based on exposure, performance and low fee costs – Stockspot has selected just 5 of them as the building blocks for a range of different portfolios. The portfolios are based on risk tolerance, financial situation and the investor’s appetite for volatility. The five component ETF’s are in Australian Shares (VAS), Global Shares (IOO), Emerging Global Markets(IEM), Australian Fixed Income (IAF), and Physical Gold (GOLD).

ETFSymbol (ASX)1-yr PerformanceGrowth since InceptionManagement Fee
Vanguard Australian Shares IndexVAS-7.92%8.25%p.a (13+ years)0.10%p.a.
iShares Global 100 IOO-4.43%7.37%p.a. (15+yearsr)0.40%p.a.
iShares MSCI Emerging MarketsIEM-20.59%7.18%p.a.(19+ years)0.69%p.a.
iShares Core Composite BondIAF-11.42%2.73%p.a.(10+ years)0.15%p.a.
ETFS Physical GoldGOLD+7.34%7.75%p.a.(19+ years)0.40%p.a.
The five ETF’s that Stockspot use to build their portfolios (1-yr Performance is to 13Oct 2022) – most of these ETF’s have a $500 minimum if you are investing directly.

It is best to disregard the above 1-yr performance – It has just been a bad year for most assets. The ETF management fees are low (depending on ETF complexity), there is good long term performance (Growth since Inception) and they have selected Physical Gold for inclusion.

Slack Investor does not naturally lean into Gold as it is a speculative, non-income producing asset. However, I might have to change my mind here. The reason Stockspot include Gold in all their portfolios is based upon historical data and the way gold tends to outperform in times of crisis. The results in this last year performance of +7.34% for Gold, speak for itself – as other asset classes flounder.

Mixing it all up

Slack Investor has written about Stockspot before in terms of Robo Advice and their valuable Superannuation reports. By using these 5 ETF’s in various combinations, Stockspot is able to give their customers a combination of returns and risk at a relatively low cost. There are even sustainable versions of each of the below portfolios available. As an example, the moderately conservative Sapphire portfolio is constructed with the following portions.

VAS: 27.2%
IAF: 35.2%
IEM: 14.4%
IOO: 7.9%
GOLD: 14.8%

A chart showing relative risk and return (grey line) of a portfolio varying between 100% Australian Bonds and 100% Australian Shares. The Stockspot portfolios have historically yielded lower returns than 100% Australian Shares) – but only slightly in their most aggressive Topaz portfolio. Overall, through their diversification, the portfolios represent much lower risk.

After fees, over a 5-yr period, Stockspot has outperformed 99% of similar funds over 5 years.

AMETHYST
Conservative
SAPPHIRE
Moderately conservative
TURQUOISE
Balanced
EMERALD
Growth
TOPAZ
High growth
3.1% p.a4.8% p.a5.3% p.a6.1% p.a6.8% p.a
5-yr annual performance (After Fees) – to 30 September 2022 – From Stockspot

There are fees involved for Stockspot to manage your money. For a balance of $200000, they amount to 0.66%. At first blush, these fees (on top of the ETF fees) sound a bit steep to Slack Investor. However, for all types of investors, with a time horizon of at least 3-5 years, for a stress-free place to put your money, this might be exactly what they are looking for. Stockspot do a tailor-made portfolio construction, all the re-balancing of assets and, they take care of all brokerage costs – Not Bad! They even have zero management fees for children accounts up to $10,000 (for under 18s) and the ability to dollar cost average with regular top-ups.

Stockspot does not earn fees from or have a commercial relationship with the ETFs we recommend. We don’t pay professionals for recommending our service to their clients.

Stockspot

Slack Investor can think of lots of situations where people would like a decision-free, low-fee, diverse investment that is designed to grow in the long term. Well done Chris Brycki (and Stockspot), for advancing the investing cause with particular attention to keeping the fees down … you are a Slack Investor Hero.

October 2022 – Mid-Month Update

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is trend-1445464__180.jpg

Despite the above discussion, my small-scale market timing experiment continues until its projected end in 2024. My frustration with this experiment continues – as it often goes against one of Slack Investors firm beliefs. If you can avoid it – Do not sell an asset when it is undervalued. Using historical CAPE values, at the end of September 2022, the UK Index (FTSE 100) was 13% below its long term mean, the US Index (S&P 500) was 9% above its long term mean, and the Australian Index (S&P 500) was 7% below its long term mean.

At the end of September 2022, Slack Investor was on SELL ALERT for Australian index shares (ASX 200), the US Index (S&P 500) and the UK Index (FTSE 100). Each of them had broken through their monthly stop loss.

 I have a “soft sell” approach when I gauge that the market is not too overvalued. I generally will not sell against the overall trend but monitor my index funds on a weekly basis once the monthly stop loss has been triggered.

Well … I can see no obvious up-trend at the end of the week for the US and UK markets and will exit at the end of week price of 3583 for the S&P 500 and 6858 for the FTSE 100. I am still just hanging in with the ASX 200 as they had a strong finish to the week.

The Index pages and charts  have been updated for the  UK Index and US Index. 

Einstein’s thought experiments

Everyone has heard about Albert Einstein – The theoretical physicist that came up with the famous relationship between Mass and Energy ( E = Mc2 – where c is the speed of light in metres per second). He also came up with ground breaking work in relativity and quantum mechanics. As a student of physics in my younger days, Slack Investor was in awe of this wild-haired genius but, even understanding the very basic concepts of general and special relativity at university … just made my head hurt.

“There are only two ways to live your life. One is as though nothing is a miracle. The other is as though everything is a miracle.”

Albert Einstein

Einstein had a brilliant mind, the 1921 Nobel prize winner was instrumental in developing new ways of looking at energy, time, space and gravity. He often would construct a “thought experiment” to help him visualise the difficult concepts that he was tackling. I will try to explain one of his many thought experiments

Einstein’s elevator thought experiment

The first part of Einstein’s elevator thought experiment is the “equivalence principle” – where Einstein concludes that there is no difference between gravity and acceleration.

To an observer in an elevator drifting along in space experiencing weightlessness. If some “being” attached a rope to the elevator and then started pulling it along with the same acceleration force that gravity provides (9.8 m/s per second), the experience of someone inside the elevator would be exactly the same as if he was in Earth’s gravitational field — they are the same thing to the elevator man.

Because of this acceleration, if a light beam entered one side while the elevator is moving, the beam would appear to drop or curve down as it crossed the elevator. Einstein postulated that light would behave in the same way if the elevator was in a gravitational field. He concluded that gravity could ‘bend’ light.

This prediction was tested by Arthur Eddington in 1919 who devised a very clever experiment during an eclipse that demonstrated a shift in locations of distant stars when recorded during the day (when light would have to move past the sun’s gravitational field) compared with night time measurements.

Celebrating gravity’s light-bending landmark
A drawing showing Eddington’s marvellous experiment. The sun’s gravity really did bend starlight just as Einstein’s theory predicted.

Einstein proposed an extension of this concept with the introduction of the idea of “black holes” in 1916. These strange dense objects have a gravity that is so strong, even light cannot escape their clutches. Black holes remained as theoretical objects for decades – the first physical black hole was not discovered until 1971.

Slack Investor volatility thought experiment

In these tough times where Slack Investor is currently getting a bit of a whack in his share portfolio, he has adapted a thought experiment on coping with volatility.

I go to the end of my driveway and construct a big sign for all the passersby. It says “Shout out how much you would pay for my house”

In this thought experiment, I imagine I am also sitting out the front in a chair and listen to the informed offers as people go past. There would be a great variance in the offers and whenever an offer is heard below what I thought it was worth, I would wince a little. After a while I would just get sick of it and tear down the sign and go back inside my house – completely satisfied that most of these people had got it wrong … and I am happy with my house – it represents a value to me that is higher than nearly all of those shouted offers.

This is exactly how I try to think my share portfolio in troubled times. I own mostly good companies with good management that are projected to increase earnings. Earnings are critical. People can shout out whatever they want about what they will pay for my small percentage of these companies. While their earnings story is basically intact, I will hang on to them.

Albert Einstein Facts
Getty Images

“It is not that I’m so smart. But I stay with the questions much longer.”

Albert Einstein

Throwing toothpicks at a mountain … and November 2021 – End of Month Update

Throwing toothpicks at the mountain': Paul Keating says Aukus submarines  plan will have no impact on China | Australian foreign policy | The Guardian
Paul Keating, at the National Press Club in November 2021, likening Australia’s recent announcement of buying 8 submarines as part of our defence strategy against Chinese expansion as “… like throwing a handful of toothpicks at the mountain.” – The Guardian

Paul Keating is an established Slack Investor hero for helping to modernise Australia’s economy and also introduce compulsory superannuation back in the early 1990’s. He has certainly not lost his ability to cut through with memorable quotes. In amongst the barbs at his latest Press Club interview was a compelling message for the need to feel comfortable with Australia’s place bordering Asia. Keating stressed the positive aspects of Australia’s potential for engagement with the region, particularly with Indonesia and China.

Now, back to finance … and the need to engage with our own mountain. At the end June 2021, Australia’s total superannuation assets were $AUD 3300 billion ($USD 2360). This staggering sum is almost 150% of the whole of Australia’s annual Gross domestic product(GDP) for 2021 of $USD 1610.

Australian superannuation fees are still too high

Although it is far from perfect, we should be proud of our superannuation system – it is the fourth largest pension pool in the world – not bad for a small country. But we can do better.

Data collected by the Productivity Commission showed that superannuation fees and costs were at the upper end of global comparators, and significantly higher than pension top dogs, Denmark and the Netherlands

Harry Chemay – Morningstar
From Morningstar: Why has Australia slipped down the global super ranks?

It is difficult to make direct comparisons to other countries as each country has its own quirks. For instance, the average Netherlands worker contributes 22.5% of salary to their defined benefits super scheme – compared to the current rate in Australia of 10% and (hopefully) moving towards 12% in 2025.

There are some structural changes that must happen to make our superannuation system more efficient. A good start is the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) introduction of a performance test to identify poor performing super funds. But readers of Slack Investor do not need prompting from APRA – they have already engaged with their super and switched to be in one of the top performing funds.

In a recent speech, Margaret Cole, a board member for APRA, pointed out that Australia has too many small super funds – Of the 156 APRA-regulated superannuation funds, there are 116 funds that each have less than $10 billion under management.

The red ellipse shows the multitude of small superannuation funds that exist under APRA’s jurisdiction. From Margaret Cole – speech to the Financial Services Council webinar

To get costs down there must be much greater consolidation of these toothpicks to achieve economies of scale so that they can be at least a “tree on the mountain”. Unfortunately, each of these funds have their own board, investment officers, and other “hangers on”. Self interest keep them going … not the needs of their clients. Their members must overcome their super inertia and change funds if they are performing badly. Or, the funds need to be told … and regulated out of the picture.

November 2021 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100.

Most markets drifted down this month. The Australian market down -0.9%. The FTSE 100 down -2.5% and the S&P 500 down -0.8%. Slack Investor remains watchful with stop losses in place.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX IndexUK IndexUS Index).