Slack Investor remains IN for US, UK (Just!), and Australian index shares.
… a very volatile month and a test for the fainthearted. The monthly overall declines do not tell the whole story – rapid declines then recovering. The Australian Index (-0.4%) had the best recovery and the US index (-3.9%) and UK index (-4.0%) had similar overall monthly falls.
Slack Investor is already off the couch and is still on alert for the US Market considering its high valuation and its recent 10.2% correction. The UK market is also under watch as it is very close to its monthly stop loss (See UK Index page).
The Upside of being Slack
Some of the time there is a price to pay for being Slack – and only making sell decisions on a monthly basis. But it is not this day!
… A day may come when the courage of men fails, when we forsake our friends and break all bonds of fellowship. But it is not this day.–Excerpt from Aragon’s Sons of Gondor speech – Lord of the Rings – Wikiquote
Well, … quoting from Tolkien’s The Return of the King is perhaps is a little dramatic but this post is a bit technical and needed a picture of Viggo Mortensen just to brighten it up.
There are many share traders who set automatic stop losses with their brokers that trigger a sell order when the price moves below a designated value. This technique can be good when you want to set a stop loss and forget about it – But there are pitfalls. Slack Investor has tried this method before and has found that the automatic sells are sometimes triggered by a particularly volatile day and your automatic sell order may trigger at $3.00 but at the close of the day the stock may have recovered to $4.00.
More common (and disappointing!) is when a rapidly falling price jumps below your automatic stop loss without triggering the sell. You then would sell the stock manually – usually at a lower price.
There are many traders who, like Slack Investor, set there stop losses manually … butact on them on a daily basis. The chart below is a daily chart of the US Index S&P 500. As a refresher, each vertical line represents the daily price range for the S&P 500. A red line indicates that the price has dropped during the day, and a blue line shows a daily price rise. Clicking on the chart will increase the resolution and you can then make out little tabs either side of the vertical daily line. The tab on the left represents the opening daily price and the tab on the right the closing price for the day. A daily trader might act on his stop loss immediately the S&P 500 falls below the stop loss (e.g. big red arrow). This technique can be a very good thing if there are further falls! However, in this case, the recovery from the 10.2% correction has rewarded the Slack Investor’s slackness.
Slack Investor does not like the daily grind of decisions. He likes to do most of his trading based on monthly charts (See left) … where each vertical line represents a month of price movement for the US Index S&P 500. At the end of February 2018, the right hand tab of the last vertical red line indicates a closing price of 2713 – well above the stop loss of 2557 (for now!) so my trading method says to hang in there.
Sometimes there is a price to pay for this slackness – For instance, when there is not a recovery in the stock price! But the delight of only making monthly decisions outweighs this concern for me. My monthly trading method together with diversification (~20 stocks) and a bit of effort in selecting growth stocks has proved to be sound so far.
All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX, UK, US).
Slack Investor remains IN for US, UK, and Australian index shares.
… some monthly setbacks for the Australian Index (-0.5%) and the UK index (-2.0%). However, confidence remains high in the USA with another huge (I mean … It’s like … Really Huge!) rise of 5.6% – This is “irrational exuberance” territory!
Slack Investor gets off the couch and is on alert for the US Market. The two strong rises over the last two months have pushed the S&P 500 up to breach the the 20-25% upper limit from his previous stop loss. This involves some necessary action – finding a new stop loss that is a little closer to the current price.
From Incredible Charts
The old S&P 500 upper limit of 2786 was surpassed by the end of month price (2823). I then go back to the charts and find a new, higher stop loss that makes sense to me. This is usually a new “higher low” – and I had to look at the weekly charts to find a sensible stop loss minimum at 2557. If this chart stuff interests you, go back to an earlier post. Otherwise, be happy that Slack Investor has moved his stop loss upward and is ready for the inevitable fall (Correction) in the US markets.
A2 Milk Company (A2M)
Slack Investor was blissfully unaware that there are two types of proteins in Milk – Conveniently labelled A1 and A2 – Who knew?? I am blissfully unaware about most things.
A2M is a New Zealand company listed on the Australian Stock Exchange and they own the patent for identifying cows that only produce the A2 protein in their milk. The selling point, backed up with a slick marketing campaign “Enjoy Milk Again “, is that there is evidence to suggest milk containing just the A2 protein is easier for some people to digest.
Slack Investor has been an owner of this fantastic company since last year and has taken the opportunity to top up his holding when A2M reached a new high in the middle of the month at around $8.00 – This is not advice.
There are many claims for A2 Milk, including that the lactose intolerant folk find it easier to digest than normal milk. Slack Investor has had a glance at A2M’s supporting 100 independent studies and he is refreshingly skeptical of these claims till a large sample, “double blind”, piece of research emerges. There are also other skeptics.
However, he cannot argue with success of A2M’s new campaign and the converts to A2M’s products that are reflected in recent sales growth. The action on the price charts and projected sales get me off the couch. Particularly with a recent announcement that A2M is expanding into the large US market. Suprisingly (for me!), 70 percent of African Americans and 90 percent of Asian Americans are lactose intolerant.
Always, before I invest, I want a deep look at a company – I use the excellent 4-Traders site and, in particular, the Financials tab – for A2M has revealed the type of growth trend that Slack Investor likes – the black columns are projected sales through to 2020. Projected increasing sales and income are the type of thing that I am looking for.
From 4-traders.com – click image for better resolution
A2M’s Current Price to Earnings ratio is an “eye watering” very high 48. This does not compare favourably with the ASX average PE of around 15. A high PE ratio can be a sign of an overpriced stock- but there are exceptions!
The exceptions are made for exceptional companies. A2M is growing its earnings so fast that the forecast PE is much more reasonable in a few years (i.e. A2M estimated PE is a more reasonable 28 in 2019) and A2M is the type of company that is excellent at using its resources to make money – an extremely high Return on Equity (ROE ~50%). These high PE, high growth companies make up a large portion of Slack Investor’s portfolio. They can be a wild ride … as they are often punished (price drops) if they do not meet forecast earnings during reporting season – but I am happy to hang onto this company for now – there might even be some further A2M good news ahead – If not, my monthly stop loss at $6.97, and diversification, will protect me from catastrophe.
All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX, UK, US).
Slack Investor remains IN for US, UK, and Australian index shares.
… and further gains for the Australian Index (+1.6%) and the US index (up 1.0%) on the month. The UK Index is in record high territory, up 4.9% in December.
Slack Investor is on the couch again and congratulates himself for being involved with the world stock markets in an environment where a no risk cash 12-mth term deposit will reward him with a paltry 2-4% p.a.
In order to reach financial independence it is necessary to embrace some risk – but as discussed below, Bitcoin may be a “Bridge too Far”.
Bitcoin Revisited
Bitcoin USD chart from Dec 30 2017. Latest chart can be found at etoro.com
Bitcoin is a regular feature in the papers and even around the Christmas Table. Since my last note on Bitcoin, the price has been on a bit of a wild ride.
Going deeper than Slack Investor really wants to go is a whole world of Bitcoin – and its own language – such as “forking”. This is “sort of” explained by Business Insider. Oh yes … there are “Hard forks” and “Hybrid forks” and “Coin Splits”, and “Bitcoin Cash” and “Bitcoin Gold” and … and … see Wikipedia. The complexity is amazing and “makes my head hurt”
Yet, despite this wild chart, in only a six weeks, Bitcoin has almost doubled in value.
Slack Investor has thought of another way of doubling your money that is much simpler … and faster! Go down to your nearest Casino, stroll to the Roulette table and put your investment money on “red” … No No No … Black! (This is not Investment Advice! – Slack Investor is just experimenting with a Dream Sequence). If you are lucky, you can double your stake in minutes, and walk out with a smile – or, if not, you can walk out feeling like an idiot.
The reason that Slack Investor doesn’t go to the Casino – OR invest in Bitcoin – with his hard-earned investment money is RISK. The bitcoin price might get to $100000 USD, or it might crash to nothing. The trip to the Casino and investing in Bitcoin represents too much risk to my capital.
40% of all bitcoin value is held by 1000 people. There is an obvious price risk if one of the bitcoin “whales” decides to suddenly sell. There also could be a difficulty in getting your bitcoin money out if there is a sudden crash.
What does the great investor and Slack Investor hero Warren Buffet think …
“It doesn’t make sense. This thing is not regulated. It’s not under control. It’s not under the supervision [of] any…United States Federal Reserve or any other central bank. I don’t believe in this whole thing at all. I think it’s going to implode.” – from Forbes
My case rests your honour.
All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX, UK, US). I have also done the quarterly update on the portfolio page. A newcomer to the portfolio is the Vanguard FTSE Asia ex Japan Shares Index ETF – (VAE.AX) on Yahoo. This should give me some exposure to a wide range of companies in the growth region of Asia with not too much expense (MER 0.4%). Bought October 9, $62.34; Monthly Stop Loss $58.79)
Slack Investor remains IN for US, UK, and Australian index shares.
… and further gains for the Australian Index (+1.0%) and the US index (up 2.8%). The UK Index dropped 2.2% in November due to what the Financial Times attributes as the “Firmer Pound contribution”.
marvels at the sage judgement of the Financial Times – and most other financial publications that always assign a reason for the random walk of market fluctuations after the fact.
Asian middle class on the rise
While on the couch, Slack investor has an ear out for world affairs and came across an article from the accomplished fund manager (and Asia Buff) Kerr Neilson – The Rise of Asia – worth a full read if you have the time. The article points to the need to consider Asia, and its effect on the world economy, over the next 10-20 years. It is a powerful collection of facts e.g,
China and India have grown their economies consistently at 6-7% for the past 20 years – they are now 4 times bigger than they were in 1998.
When measuring purchasing power, their combined GDP of US $33 trillion is 50% larger than either the US or the EU!
China and India originate nearly 120 million high-spending overseas travellers each year.
The last point is backed up by CNN Money who report that the number of Chinese tourists travelling internationally has more than doubled to 120 million people over the last five years – 1 in every 10 international travellers now comes from China.
Chinese people tend to begin traveling abroad once their household earns about $35,000 – from CNN Money
The rapidly rising middle class of these countries is behind this increased tourism and the graph below indicates the influence of these two economies will be on the rise.
Based upon fear of what he might discover, Slack Investor keeps most personal introspection to a minimum. However, for a number of reasons, I am particularly fond of reviewing investment performance. … and always looking to tie in a quote from a great scientist and Time Magazine’s 1999 Person of the century – Albert Einstein.
Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new– Albert Einstein (1879-1955)
Slack Investor has made plenty of mistakes and regularly racks up the failures. The 2017 Financial Year, (1 July 2016 – 30 June 2017) annual review of his portfolio has revealed a few “shockers” in the Slack Investor Self Managed Super Fund (SMSF ) portfolio – which I not so proudly list (with their percentage losses) as my financial year investment “fails”
Sirtex (SRX) -34%
TPG Telecom (TPM) -23%
McMillan Shakespeare (MMS) -16%
G8 Education (GEM) -15%
APN Outdoor (APO) -14%
Amaysim (AYS) -11%
These companies have usually dropped in price during reporting season where a bit of bad news, or a failure to reach projected profit forecasts, triggered dramatic price falls. In all cases, these stocks were eventually sold because they breached the end of month stop losses that I had set.
Slack Investor just accepts these setbacks as part of the investment process. The type of companies that I invest in are usually
Growth companies
Have an above average “return on equity” ROE
Have an above average “price to earnings” P/E ratio – Where P/E =Current price/Historical earnings.
The reason that Slack Investor is interested in these stocks is that they usually have higher projected earnings in the years ahead and should perform better than the general market. When I am looking at a stock, the forecast P/E ratios are given much more importance than the actual P/E ratios. However, it is the nature of these stocksto be particularly sensitive to any change in the forecast earnings. If profit forecasts are not met during a reporting season (sometimes referred to as the “confession season”), then there is a mad rush for the exits and the price plummets. Slack Investor is not a day trader and prefers not to watch his stocks continuously. As a result, he is never able to pick the precise right time to bail out.
I am sure there is a cost to this monthly decision making technique – but it is a price a pay gladly. The “peace of mind” in knowing that I only have to make stock decisions once a month – and that I can ignore the daily fluctuations of share prices is priceless to me.
The upside of dealing with these type of companies is that they have excellent growth potential. Thankfully, there was some good news in the portfolio this last financial year due to some heavy lifting from the following stocks.
So far, the Slack Investor approach has been very fruitful. I usually own about 20 different stocks and this diversity allows my portfolio to have some individual failures and still do well.
The point of this post is that you can fail in the stock market … but also succeed. I certainly do not dwell on these failures – they are just part of investing.
For the 2017 financial year my SMSF portfolio achieved an overall return (IRR) of 19.5%.
Slack Investor remains IN for US, UK, and Australian index shares.
… and what a bumper month it has been with all markets that I follow on the rise – The Australian Index rockets 4.0%, the UK index up 1.6% and the booming US market up a further 2.1%.
Slack Investor gets off the couch and has a look at the UK Index … as it is recovering from a small fall in September where the monthly price range (the red third bar from right) breached the 10-month moving average (black line). This breaching is a trigger for the Slack Investor trading method as it establishes a new “higher low” for a moving of the stop loss upward – as a new support price has been established. The stop loss for the UK Index was moved upward from 6677 to 7196.
I have undertaken a major change to the Index pages (ASX, UK, US). Previously I have been basing my decisions on Exchange Traded Funds (ETF’s) that I own that are proxies the actual Indexes for each market. As there are a multitude of these ETF’s, it makes more sense to make my decisions on the actual indexes – as this will have more relevance to the readers that are exposed to the general market indicies through whatever means e.g. another index-based ETF, Superannuation funds or Retirement Plans (US).
From the current investment cycle, Slack Investor will base his decision on the following charts
All Index pages are updated together with the charts to reflect these changes. Also, the the previous charts based upon the Index ETF’s are also kept at the bottom of the page for reference (for the super keen!) on the index pages – (ASX, UK, US).
“….when you cannot measure it, when you cannot express it in numbers, your knowledge is of a meagre and unsatisfactory kind…”
Lord Kelvin, a Science “Hall of Fame” member was right … Particularly so when it comes to your investments. As well as some notable scientific discoveries, including the invention of the absolute temperature scale which defines the lowest possible temperature – at which atoms stop moving (-273.15C) – The wise Lord Kelvin showed a respect for measurement … and the nerd in me remembers the graffiti homage from Physics Lab toilet doors …
Absolute Zero is Cool!
Slack Investor takes the measurement of investment performance very seriously and puts some effort into doing it right. Slack Investor is old enough to recall the famous case of the Beardstown Ladies Investment Club – a club that published a book in 1994 that claimed a market-beating investment performance from a group of talented, but amateur, investors from a small town in Illinois, USA.
The Beardstown Ladies are a group that are still going, a 14-woman investment club that hit the financial headlines with their “The Beardstown Ladies’ Common-Sense Investment Guide” which included a seemingly astounding financial performance that beat the best of Wall Street with their investment returns of 23.4% pa between 1984 and 1993.
This gave other amateur investors a real kick and did wonders for their book sales. It was far better than the 14.9% gained by the index S & P 500 and almost twice the 12.6% return of the average US stock mutual fund.
However, after an independent audit, according to the LA Times, in 1998, their was a recalculation of their the performance figures amid questions about accuracy. The ladies, sadly, have an audited revised portfolio return of a 9.1% a year – a great effort … but lagging the index!
The problem was, the lovely ladies from Beardstown had innocently forgotten to account for their cash flows into the fund (Contributions) and these had been added into their portfolio performance to give an inflated figure. Their book is still for sale … and they have published four others … The US loves winners(?)!
The Slack Investor message is to not always believe what you read … wait for the independent audits … and, like Lord Kelvin, to avoid “meagre and unsatisfactory knowledge”, take some time in your measurement of portfolio performance. More of this next month …
Slack Investor remains IN for US, UK, and Australian index shares.
Despite a bad month for the UK index where the previous month gains were wiped out, there are no alarm bells yet. All markets have had a reasonable financial year (to Jun 30, 2017) with 12-month returns for the US, UK and Australian Index of 15.2%, 13.0% and 9.6%, respectively. These returns, for simplicity of calculation, do not include dividends. For the Australian market, the dividends would add another 4-5%!
And now for a confession …. Slack Investor has been slack … and not moving his market index stop losses properly! I put this down to an oversight and have included an extra few columns on the Index pages to help me not do this again.
Stop Losses are very important to the Slack Investor’s method and offer a detached way in which to make decisions at the end of every month. The stop losses are set at the time of share purchase and moved upward according to a modified version of Dow theory. This trend method was discussed in an earlier post The Trend is Your Friend …
Slack Investors’s Index trading method involves moving the stop loss level upwards to a new higher low when it is established on the monthly chart. There are a couple of rules that I have to keep me in the index trade as long as possible.
Stop Loss Rule No. 1: A Higher Low can only be established below the 10-month moving average (the wavy black line on the index chart pages).
Stop Loss Rule No. 2: Stop Loss Rule No. 1. does not apply if the monthly closing price is more than 20% above the set stop loss.
For the UK Index, back at the end of February, the end of month price rose 21% above the stop loss level. I should have moved the Stop Loss level then … but I have now caught up and include the adjustment on the UK Index page. I include the technical chart information for some readers who are interested … but don’t worry, Slack Investor will tell you at the start of each month what each of his decisions are in the monthly updates for the US, UK and Australian Index.
Warren Buffet has some much more famous investment rules …
Rule No. 1: Never Lose Money.
Rule No. 2: Never Forget Rule No. 1.
Mr Buffet is being a little flippant here, and even the great investment master has lost money at times on individual investments. However, overall he has not lost money … and this is the same approach that Slack Investor is trying to emulate. It is impossible to completely avoid losses, it is just part of investing, and there is no use beating yourself up about a loss when it happens … However, you can limit losses by using stop loss levels … and, with Slack Investor Stop Loss rules … they should be limited to around 20% (there may be some slippage!.
I have updated all Index pages and the Portfolio page.
Slack Investor remains IN for US, UK, and Australian index shares.
April 2017 has seen rises, in the US and Australian markets and a dip in the UK Index. So far, the Slack Investment Cycle returns for the US, UK and Australian markets are 141.0%, 7.6% and 12.0%, respectively.
Bull markets are a funny thing – and there is no doubt that all markets that Slack Investor follows are in various stages of a bull run – they are comforting as the Slack Investor can congratulate himself on what a stock market genius he is (Ironic comment!) – And yet, I can’t help but feel a sense of unease that things have been “too good for too long”.
Looking at the index chart pages, I get the feeling that it has been a long time since my stop losses have been adjusted upwards in the UK and ASX markets – and this will have the potential to erode any gains should the markets fall suddenly. However, I am comforted that the Slack Investor monthly-decision based method is tried and true and has brought rewards in the past … so I’m staying the course … the objective Slack method is designed to keep you in the markets as long as possible and only withdraw from the fray during a major downturn.
I am also comforted by the fact that we frail humans have behavioural biases, we lack patience and we want to tinker with things! Although Slack Investor is unable to track down the original source, an often quoted study by Fidelity (e.g., Business Insider) investigating the Fidelity trading accounts between 2003 and 2013, found that its best performing accounts were the inactive ones – Either owned by people who had forgotten that they had an account, or by dead people!
The Slack Investor does not recommend complete inaction though – but trading less has its merits.
While it is fresh in my mind I will drop in another example of the fine New Zealand experience below…
Day 3 Milford Track NZ – Slack Investor’s corpulence is almost eclipsed by the magnificence of Sutherland Falls. Reminder … must exercise more often!
For more information on parameters such as progressive gains, look on the Slack investor ASX Index, US Index and UK Index pages for updated details – and a look at the charts. Next end of month update on the index charts will be early in June.
There is that smell in the air … Is it love? Winter is breaking … New growth erupting on the stems… and Ah Yes, It is Dividend Season – the Prince of Seasons! That time of the year when the companies that you have invested in reward you for your efforts and present you with a fraction of the results of their toil.
There is no finer season – it occurs twice a year! Each company has worked hard during the financial year trying to increase sales and profits … they have crunched the numbers and made reports and hopefully held their numbers close to their chests ready for a festive occasion where the managers and shareholders gather. There is a triumphant report to the shareholders and final dividends are calculated from a share of the profits and a date is set where the patient shareholders receive a cash gift into their accounts as a reward for supporting the company through this last financial year. Hopefully there is growth in sales and dividend, and prospects for the coming few years are good …
Well, this is how its supposed to happen … and if you have done a bit of homework and assessed the company and industry … and management … and competitors … and economic environment … and heaps of other stuff … OR, you may have just been lucky! … Its how it often happens.
Because Slack Investor is not the most fastidious of researchers (He would much prefer others did the hard work for him!). Sometimes his luck doesn’t run and reporting season brings some bad news and there is a drastic price slide as other investors bale out.
Investors seem very sensitive in dividend season and tend to react strongly when there is a perception of bad things in the air. Particularly stocks that have a lot of good news forward-priced into them (high PE). Triggers such as as when analyst expectations are not met … or profit guidance is revised down … or a product disaster … can reduce share prices by 20 -30% in a matter of hours.
Slack Investor is not watching his stocks hour by hour and has suffered from a few of these corrections. But the beauty of his slack approach is that no decisions need be done on the day … absorb the bad news overnight and ask yourself the question
Given this bad news … Would I still buy the stock at its new price?
If the answer is no, sell at the next opportunity. If the answer is yes, keep an eye on the stock for the next few days … One of two things will happen
The drastic stock price retreat was an over-reaction and value buyers start pouring in and the price returns to its former glory… your slackness has been rewarded.
The bad news filters through to the general community and analyst and brokers change their recommendations to their clients, people continue to sell and the price slides further.
Unfortunately, the second scenario is more common and even though you may think the stock is more of a bargain now … through experience, Slack Investor has known other bad news to follow bad news and it is prudent to sell the stock (perhaps at a loss) – you can’t hold back the tide! If it is a stock that you like … you can always buy it back when sentiment improves.
Slack Investor remains IN for US, UK (Just!), and Australian index shares.
